The debate over masks continued at a recent meeting of the Peters Township School Board of Directors as several parents spoke out both for and against masks in schools.

Earlier this year, Pennsylvania’s Acting Secretary of Health Alison Beam signed an order requiring face coverings to be worn in all school entities.

At the Oct. 18 meeting held in the high school auditorium, attendees wearing masks were directed to sit on one side of the room while unmasked attendees had to sit on the opposite side. The middle section of the auditorium was left empty.

One resident speaking at the meeting accused the district of requiring masks only to receive Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief (ESSER) funding from the government.

Advertise with us

“The district health and safety plan was a direct response of the Peters Township School Board’s acceptance of funding from the American Rescue Plan Act,” Daniel Taormina said. He added, “One primary ingredient in the contractual agreement when accepting the funding was the health and safety plan must stipulate and I quote, ‘universal and correct wearing of masks.’”

“How many silver pieces did it take for the district’s leadership to sell the well-being of our children to the state and federal bureaucracy?” Mr. Taormina asked.

Peters superintendent Jeannine French said there was a district health and safety plan in place last year.

“The current health and safety plan is a return to school plan. It is an ESSER return to safety plan, but there is no requirement for masking,” Ms. French said.

Ms. French said the district’s initial health and safety plan for the start of the current school year had masks optional until it was mandated by the state.

Advertise with us

“There is clearly no tie to masking for our funding,” Ms. French said.

“I can’t believe we’re still here talking about masking, but here we are,” said resident Carolee Ketelaar.

“The pandemic is a temporary situation and until we mask and get vaccinated, it’s just going to continue. I mean, we know how to stop it, let’s just do it,” Ms. Ketelaar said.

She also pointed to a study from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention that she said stated “school districts without mask mandates were more likely to have COVID-19 outbreaks.”

Ginger Hollander asked the board, “I’m curious what you’re afraid of if you just say, ‘OK, masks optional.’ Do you really think someone’s going to shut your doors?”

Advertise with us

Ms. Hollander then asked the board if it would be an option to put unmasked students in the old middle school, which is currently not housing students.

“Why don’t we segregate the kids? You’re already doing it here at a board meeting,” Ms. Hollander said. “I volunteer. I’ll be a free teacher,” for the unmasked students, she added.

Several parents also questioned why the board would not convene a subcommittee of the policy committee to address both sides of the masking issue.

“Right now, there is no specific school issue for which a committee needs to be formed since we are under the government mask mandate,” said school board president Thomas McMurray.

“Should the government mask mandate be lifted, at that time we can revisit the formation of a committee, survey or anything else that might come up,” he said, adding that currently the board will continue to follow the mask mandate.