With just days until Tuesday's general election, a firestorm is brewing in one Washington County municipality, where a race for district judge is getting ugly.

Voters in the district, which includes Peters, Nottingham and Union, have been barraged in recent days with mailers, including one that prompted a letter to the editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Friday.

The Republican Party of Peters Township late Friday disavowed knowledge of what it called “the fear mongering postcard,” as did candidate Jacob Machel.

Although a district judge seat is usually considered minor by political standards, this race has become surprisingly spirited after a strange set of circumstances launched one candidate into a favorable position.

Advertise with us

The incumbent, James Ellis, 62, has occupied the seat for 30 years and was expected to run for his sixth six-year term in the May primary election.

But, Judge Ellis unexpectedly announced his intention to retire on March 7, the last day that nominating petitions could be submitted, effectively preventing anyone who hadn’t already circulated petitions from running.

As a result, the only candidate on the May primary ballot was Mr. Machel, 29, of Peters, who won both the Democratic and Republican nominations.

Mr. Machel bested two write-in candidates who scrambled to campaign after Judge Ellis’ surprise announcement.

And although Mr. Machel won both nominations, the races were close and the write-in candidates — one from each party — secured more than 42 percent of the vote in both races.

Advertise with us

Encouraged by the number of write-in votes in the primary, Peters lawyer Jesse Pettit changed his party registration from Democrat to Independent in order to appear on the November ballot.

“I just started asking around and it seemed to be odd for there to be only one person on this ballot with no opposition and nobody making an attempt to run,” Mr. Pettit said. “There were a lot of people who said they were thinking of running, but [Judge Ellis] said he would run again, so nobody made the attempt to circulate petitions.”

Mr. Pettit is the son of the late John Pettit, the longtime Washington County district attorney.

Mr. Machel, a commercial real estate broker and former minor-league hockey player, declined to participate in a debate last week sponsored by the county League of Women Voters.

“It just seemed like it was a witch hunt by [Mr. Pettit’s] people to get me into a room and embarrass me,” said Mr. Machel, who said he felt there was no upside to participating in the debate. “Some of his supporters have been very foul.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Machel said he has also heard accusations, mostly on social media, that the announcement by Judge Ellis was timed to suppress interest in the race, ensuring Mr. Machel would be the lone contender on the ballot.

“He dropped out for health reasons, which was not widely known,” Mr. Machel said of Judge Ellis, who has been silent on the subject since his retirement announcement. “A lot of people have made conspiracies up, but the truth is he’s been pretty sick for about a year. He lost 80 pounds in a year.”

Talk became so heated that Mr. Machel said he was forced to seek the permission of Judge Ellis’ family to make his health condition known. Mr. Machel said he was prepared to run against Judge Ellis before his withdrawal.

Mr. Machel said he has known the judge since he was a teen, when a high school civics class field trip to the district judge office convinced him of his future.

“I knew that’s what I wanted to do. I was there every spare second I had even after college,” said Mr. Machel, who has a bachelor’s degree in political science from Washington & Jefferson College.

Advertise with us

Although he’s not a lawyer, Mr. Machel said he has spent hundreds of hours observing the lower-court proceedings. Earlier this year, Mr. Machel said he received the necessary certification from the state Supreme Court to serve on the bench. The four-week course and exam are required for district judges who aren’t lawyers.

Mr. Pettit said his background as a lawyer in private practice and former prosecutor will be valuable for an office that some mistake for “traffic court,” he said.

“I spent a considerable amount of time in the district justice level office when I worked in the Philadelphia District Attorney’s Office and the state Attorney General’s Office,” said Mr. Pettit, who is a partner in a private law firm in Pittsburgh. “I probably presented evidence in 2,500 preliminary hearings.”

The Republican Party in Peters last week announced that after interviewing both candidates, it found Mr. Pettit to be “a superior candidate and significantly more qualified for the position than Jacob Machel,” according to the group’s website.

If he’s elected, Mr. Machel has pledged to stay in office for the full six-year term, and has questioned Mr. Pettit’s intentions. Mr. Pettit said he has no plans nor has he discussed running for any other office in the future.

Advertise with us

Despite some of the last-minute backbiting, Mr. Machel said, he isn’t discouraged about his chances on Tuesday.

“I’ve wanted to do this for long time and my intentions are great,” he said. “Going negative turns people off because it gets so nasty. The hatred is just sad. If I’m elected, I’d like to do something to change that. I think a lot of young people are turned off to politics because they’ve seen the way this has gone.”

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1159 or on Twitter @janicecrompton.