A Connecticut construction company was ordered Monday to pay $15.8 million in damages to the family of a Finleyville woman injured in a Route 51 crash in Pleasant Hills, a day before her daughter’s wedding four years ago.
An Allegheny County Common Pleas Court jury Monday found Lane Construction Corp., PennDOT and the driver of the other vehicle negligent in a civil case brought by relatives of Brenda Gump-Schragl, then 52, who suffered brain injuries and was in a coma for five weeks after the June 11, 2010, crash.
The lawsuit contended that the construction zone was dangerous and no improvements were made after several earlier collisions in the same area.
PennDOT and the other driver, Adam Mains, 25, who in 2010 was found guilty of speeding and related offenses in connection with the crash, settled before the trial. That leaves Lane Construction, a PennDOT contractor, responsible for all $15.8 million because the case dates before the 2011 Fair Share Act, in which defendants are required to pay only their share of the judgment, with some exceptions.
Jurors found Mr. Mains was 42 percent negligent, PennDOT 40 percent and Lane Construction 18 percent.
The Gump family’s attorney, Anthony Mengine, said he expects Lane, which has an office in Crafton, to file an appeal. Common Pleas Judge Michael A. Della Vecchia also intimated as much.
“I would guess this battle isn’t over yet,” he said.
Lane spokeswoman Lauralee Heckman said: "We are just researching our options at this time regarding the appeal," declining further comment. A PennDOT spokesman said the department can't comment on litigation.
Damages from the case total about $16.5 million. Mr. Mengine said Ms. Gump-Schragl’s future medical and care expenses total an estimated $4.8 million.
However tentative the decision, the Gump family hugged one another and cried as the jury returned the verdict.
Robert McDermott, a state attorney general’s office lawyer representing PennDOT, argued in closing remarks that the department “acted in a reasonable way.” Plenty of signs were posted with the recommended speed, and while rumble strips and message displays might have reinforced those markings, the highway wasn’t dangerous without them.
A plaintiff’s expert suggested during testimony that PennDOT could have banned left turns in the area, Mr. McDermott said, countering in closing remarks that the left turning radius was not sufficient at the next traffic light.
Mark McKenna, an attorney for Lane Construction, said in closing remarks that as a contractor, the company could not make changes to the traffic control plan.
For his part, Mr. Mengine told jurors: “This case is not about sympathy; it’s about safety.”
The collision occurred as Ms. Gump-Schragl’s son, Daniel Gump, tried to turn left from northbound Route 51 into Primanti Bros. restaurant, where a rehearsal dinner was scheduled for his sister, Dana Gump. Oncoming traffic was backed up in the left lane as drivers merged from two lanes to one for the construction area.
A driver in the left lane allowed Mr. Gump to turn, but he didn’t see Mr. Mains’ pickup truck approaching in the otherwise clear right lane.
After learning to walk again, Ms. Gump-Schragl, now 56, still can’t use her left hand, her attorney told jurors. She can’t remember some things, including when she has eaten. The morning before her husband was set to testify last week, she got out of the shower and asked him who he was, Mr. Mengine said.
“Brenda Gump, will have no memories in her life,” Mr. Mengine said.
The wedding was postponed one year. Mr. Mains of West Elizabeth was found guilty in 2010 of speeding, driving too fast for conditions and careless driving near a work zone.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.