HARRISBURG -- State House Majority Leader Bill DeWeese has been a force in Pennsylvania politics for two decades, and it's always risky to count him out of any race.
But while the Waynesburg Democrat was able to win a difficult re-election race Tuesday, he could have an even tougher time remaining leader of the ruling Democrats when the new legislative session starts in January.
"There's a serious question whether Bill DeWeese will be in leadership at all in the next legislative session," Tim Potts, leader of a citizens reform group called Democracy Rising PA and a one-time aide to Mr. DeWeese, said yesterday.
"The Bonusgate issue is still hanging over his head. He is an absolute political liability for our caucus," said Rep. David Levdansky, D-Forward, who in August had urged Mr. DeWeese to end his re-election campaign. "A leader should be an asset, but he is a liability."
Democrats will have to choose two important leaders in coming weeks: House speaker and House majority leader. Republicans also will get to vote for speaker, a position held by a compromise choice, Philadelphia Republican Dennis O'Brien, the past two years.
Closed Democratic caucuses on the top jobs are expected to start soon, with some action possible next week when House members return for a short November session.
Mr. DeWeese is expected to try to retain his majority leader job, but other Democrats said to be interested in the top jobs are all from Eastern Pennsylvania: Rep. Keith McCall of Carbon, who is now House Democratic whip; Rep. Todd Eachus of Luzerne, who ran the House Democratic Campaign Committee; and Rep. Dwight Evans of Philadelphia, chairman of the powerful House Appropriations Committee.
While several House races remained undecided yesterday, it appeared that Democrats will control the chamber by a 104-99 margin in the 2009-10 term. That's up from the current bare margin of 102-101.
But the party lost three important seats from Western Pennsylvania Tuesday -- from Beaver, Westmoreland and Elk counties -- and critics say that makes Mr. DeWeese look like an ineffective leader.
Democrats are concerned about their power eroding in Beaver County, a usual stronghold. Besides Rep. Vince Biancucci's loss Tuesday, Rep. Mike Veon lost his seat two years ago, in large part due to public anger over the legislative pay raises of 2005, which almost cost Mr. DeWeese his seat in 2006.
"It reflects badly on DeWeese that those three western seats were lost, while Democrats picked up several seats in Eastern Pennsylvania," Mr. Potts said. "Barack Obama won big on Tuesday. The new House should have at least 107 Democrats."
Mr. DeWeese won his own re-election race by defeating Republican challenger Greg Hopkins.
Some observers thought Mr. DeWeese might not survive the recent testimony by his former chief of staff, Mike Manzo, who linked Mr. DeWeese to Bonusgate, claiming he knew about bonuses that were illegally paid for political work in 2006. Mr. DeWeese has strongly denied the charge.
"DeWeese is damaged in terms of his public reputation, no doubt about it," said Muhlenberg College pollster/political science professor Christopher Borick.
"The specter of the so-called Bonusgate scandal, even if he didn't have a role in it, happened on his watch," Mr. Borick said. "This is an otherwise good period for Democrats, with Obama and other Democrats doing well, but Bonusgate has put a mark against Democrats in the state House."
But Rep. Tom Caltagirone, D-Berks, said, "Don't count Bill out. He's a classic survivor."
The Bonusgate scandal has led 15 House Democrats in recent weeks to call for Mr. DeWeese to resign as their leader. Some feared that it could cause Democrats to lose control of the House on Tuesday, but that didn't happen. Nonetheless, some Democrats say a new face is needed. In addition to Mr. Levdansky, they include Reps. Matt Smith of Mt. Lebanon, Dan Frankel of Squirrel Hill and Harry Readshaw of Carrick.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.