The dust seems to have settled in the primary election battle between Washington County prothonotary candidates Judith Fisher and Phyllis Ranko Matheny. Ms. Fisher last week announced she would not seek an appeal of the May 15 election results.
Ms. Fisher, the county's current Democratic jury commissioner, won the Democratic nomination for prothonotary, but lost the Republican nomination to Ms. Ranko Matheny by 29 write-in votes.
She had challenged the results of the Republican nomination, saying it was unclear which votes the county's canvassing board counted and why.
The board sought to determine the intent of 969 GOP write-in votes, which included names like "Phyllis Ranko," "Mahoney," "Fischer," and "J. Fisher."
Ms. Fisher thought the board's decisions were arbitrary and said she was looking for a uniform interpretation of the law.
Ms. Fisher said she decided last week to drop her challenge because of the time and cost involved.
"It would take thousands of dollars for me to go and try to change the law," she said. "That's the Legislature's job. It's very unclear."
Ms. Fisher said she believes the system is flawed and she would work within the Democratic state committee to resolve the issue.
Ms. Ranko Matheny said she believed voter intent was obvious in many of the challenged votes.
"I think you have to go with what voters wanted to do," she said.
Ms. Ranko Matheny's Republican nomination sets up a rematch in November with Ms. Fisher.
Four years ago, the three-term incumbent Ms. Ranko Matheny, 66, of North Strabane, won re-election by seven votes as a GOP write-in, even though she lost the Democratic primary to Mrs. Fisher, 68, of South Strabane.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.