A Washington County judge is expected to hear arguments next week over what voters meant when they wrote in names such as "Phyllis Ranko," "Phyllis," "Judith," and "J. Fisher," in the May 15 primary election for county prothonotary.
Judith Fisher, who won the Democratic nomination for prothonotary but lost the Republican nod by 29 write-in votes to incumbent prothonotary Phyllis Ranko Matheny, recently challenged the Republican write-in results.
Her attorney, Dan Chunko, appealed the final tally by the county's election canvassing board, which reviewed each write-in vote and sought to determine the voter's intention. In the past, the process was made more complicated by deciphering handwriting, but the county's new electronic voting machines require write-in votes to be typed on a keyboard.
"On the one hand, you don't want to disenfranchise the voters," Mr. Chunko said, but he's concerned that votes that were "remotely close" to a candidate's name were counted, along with incorrect surnames, and first names only.
"Anything that looked potentially like a name was being counted," he said.
County Common Pleas Judge Mark Mascara has scheduled a hearing into the matter for June 11.
The elections office is prepared.
"The case law is clear," county Director of Elections Larry Spahr said. "Last names are to be counted."
Before the canvassing board began counting the 969 GOP write-in votes, Mr. Spahr said, he sought legal advice from the county solicitor, J. Lynn DeHaven, and visited the county's law library to investigate relevant case law.
Mr. Spahr said two cases before the state Supreme Court and one decided by Commonwealth Court detail ways to infer the intent of voters, and how to prevent arbitrarily disenfranchising voters.
According to case law, Mr. Spahr said, if a voter writes in a last name only, it is to be counted unless there is another person with the same name in that race, or in a similar race. He said the canvassing board counted votes for "Ranko" because it was clear the intent was a vote for Ms. Ranko Matheny, who uses her maiden name as part of her professional name.
Mr. Chunko disputes that, saying Ranko is not part of her surname. If Ranko Matheny was hyphenated, it would be part of the surname, he said.
Mr. Spahr points out that Ms. Fisher shares a last name with Steven Fischer, a Republican candidate for commissioner. The names sound the same, but are spelled differently, so the canvassing board gave Ms. Fisher credit for votes that were written as "Fisher" or "Fischer."
If Mr. Chunko is successful in getting last names restricted from the count, it could also cost his client some of her votes.
"We gave Judy the benefit of the doubt," Mr. Spahr said. "She may have opened a Pandora's box."
"I fully expected that," said Mr. Chunko, who said he was looking for a uniform interpretation of the law for his client and others.
If Ms. Ranko Matheny's Republican nomination stands, it will set up a rematch in November between her and Ms. Fisher, the county's current Democratic jury commissioner.
Four years ago, Ms. Ranko Matheny, 66, of North Strabane, a three-term incumbent, held tight to win re-election by seven votes as a GOP write-in, even though she lost the Democratic primary to Mrs. Fisher, 68, of South Strabane.
Bitter feelings between the two candidates and their supporters have remained, though, as Ms. Fisher's camp claimed the election was stolen from her when several ballot boxes were not re-counted.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.