Washington County voters in Tuesday's primary election made one thing clear: Experience counts.
Most of the time.
Robert J. Pavuchak for the Post-Gazette
Incumbent County Commissioner Larry Maggi gets good news as volunteer Joe Zupancic, right, and other supporters waited for election results in Commissioner Maggi's seventh-floor office in Washington Courthouse Center on election night.
Click photo for larger image.
The current county board of commissioners had no problem securing renominations from their parties, and deputy Register of Wills Mary Jo Poknis bested three other candidates with her message that she was the most qualified for the office.
Three-term incumbent Prothonotary Phyllis Ranko Matheny, however, again fell to Judith Fisher, who, as in 2003, snapped up the Democratic nomination. And although incumbent Democratic District Attorney John C. Pettit was unchallenged for his party's nomination for a seventh term, voters seemed to be sending him a message with a substantial undervote by Democrats who went to the polls but failed to cast votes for him.
Voter turnout was low, as expected, according to county Elections Director Larry Spahr. About 39,895 voters, or 27.4 percent, turned out.
In a replay of the 2003 election, incumbent Democratic Commissioner Larry Maggi was the top vote-getter among his colleagues for a second term, with 12,805 votes, followed closely by fellow incumbent and running mate J. Bracken Burns, 62, of South Strabane, seeking a fourth term, with 12,122 votes.
Rounding out third and fourth were running mates Joseph Manning, 45, a Washington firefighter, and longtime Chartiers Supervisor Harlan Shober, 61, with 8,655 votes and 7,596 votes, respectively.
In fifth was former Coal Center Councilman Randy Barli, 52, with 2,658 votes. Democratic committeeman Harry Sabatasse, 74, of Smith, finished the race sixth with 2,008 votes.
Mr. Maggi said he believed the message of a thriving Washington County got through to voters. He, Mr. Burns and incumbent Republican Commissioner Diana Irey stumped on the issue of economic progress, showing statistics that Washington County had the second-highest job growth and per-capita income, and second-lowest tax rate in the nine-county southwestern Pennsylvania region.
"I thought I would do OK, but you never know until all of the votes are counted," said Mr. Maggi, 56, of Buffalo Township. "We have a lot to show with our numbers and our statistics. Washington County is growing and we are the cheerleaders for it."
Each party nominates two candidates who vie for three open seats in the November general election.
Mrs. Irey, 44, of Carroll, rode to the top of the GOP ticket with 8,580 votes, along with former Peters Councilman Mike Neville, who eked out a victory over Iraq war veteran Steven Fischer with 5,582 votes to Mr. Fischer's 5,565. By Wednesday, unofficial absentee ballot counting continued to widen Mr. Neville's lead.
A tally of write-in votes is expected to finalize the election results this week.
"I am just thrilled with the outcome of the election," said Mrs. Irey, a masterful fund-raiser who already has met with an outreach committee to begin mapping strategy for November. "I thought that this was my toughest primary."
Mr. Neville, 47, a business banker, began campaigning a year ago. He said he knocked on more than 5,000 doors and attended more than 50 council and supervisor meetings throughout the county.
"We knew from the beginning that this was an uphill battle," he said. "We knew from the beginning that we were the underdog."
Mr. Neville said he had virtually no name recognition outside of Peters, and that he expected a "dog fight" for the primary because he was battling two politically well-connected families.
Mr. Fischer, 31, was seen as having an advantage because his father, the Rev. Roger R. Fischer, is a popular former state legislator and because he shares a last name of other well-known, though unrelated, candidates and state officials.
Mr. Fischer, a captain in the Pennsylvania National Guard, said he was encouraged by his showing in the primary and that he was thankful to have the opportunity to run. He said he was reminded that five members of his combat unit didn't return from Iraq last year.
"That could have been me," he said. Because of the slim vote margin, he said, he will wait for the official tally and certification of the vote before conceding or challenging the election.
The mood in the register of wills office couldn't have been more positive after the primary.
"Is ecstatic too strong a word?" said Ms. Poknis, 51, the deputy register of wills from Fallowfield, who thumped a field of three other candidates in a race that was expected to be much closer after longtime incumbent Kathleen Flynn Reda announced her retirement this year.
Ms. Poknis received nearly twice as many votes as her nearest challenger for the Democratic nomination, with 10,092 cast in her favor.
Former Canonsburg Councilwoman Diane Tatano, 40, came in second with 5,339 votes, followed by Canton lawyer Charles Kurowski, 54, with 5,014 votes. John Rotheram, 57, also of Fallowfield and assistant to state Auditor General Jack Wagner, rounded out the race in fourth with 4,459 votes.
"I'm just so impressed with the voters," Ms. Poknis said. "I'm really happy."
She will face Lynette Leasure, 46, of Cecil, a project manager assistant for an environmental consulting firm, who was unopposed for the Republican nomination.
Four years ago, Prothonotary Mrs. Ranko Matheny, 66, of North Strabane, held tight to win re-election by seven votes as a write-in on the Republican ticket, even though she lost the Democratic primary to Mrs. Fisher.
Whether Mrs. Ranko Matheny will snatch that nomination again this year should be determined this week, after a county canvassing board reviews 969 Republican write-in votes.
Mrs. Ranko Matheny came away from Tuesday's election with 9,014 votes while Mrs. Fisher, who currently serves as the county's Democratic jury commissioner, garnered 9,779 votes. In third was challenger John Trapuzzano, 47, of Cecil, an account manager for an industrial gas supplier, with 5,594 votes.
A recent rift in the Democratic Party over an election for chairman might have split loyalties between the two women, both longtime party members. Mrs. Fisher's supporters have complained for four years that she was robbed of victory in 2003 when not all ballot boxes were counted.
Mrs. Fisher, 68, of South Strabane, credits her victory to the more than 60 Democratic Committee volunteers who pitched in on Election Day, along with union support. Voters she talked to were looking for change, Mrs. Fisher said.
"They felt we needed someone new who would update the office," she said.
Although there was no competition for the Democratic or Republican nominations for district attorney, Mr. Pettit saw a sizable undervote of about 34 percent. According to unofficial election results, of 26,686 Democratic voters, 17,244 cast ballots for Mr. Pettit, 384 wrote in the name of a candidate and 9,058 did not vote in the race.
By comparison, other incumbent county officeholders, such as Treasurer Francis King, Clerk of Courts Barbara Gibbs and Coroner S. Timothy Warco, averaged about 15 percent to 20 percent undervotes, which are typical in a primary election, according to county election office data.
On the Republican side, lawyer Steven Toprani, 28, of Carroll, sewed up his party's nomination for district attorney, but he, too, had a significant undervote of 28 percent. There was a similar undervote for Ms. Leasure, the GOP candidate for register of wills. Both are political newcomers.
An undervote of more than 20 percent is a negative, and could mean one of two things for Mr. Toprani and Mr. Pettit, according to Joseph DiSarro, professor and chairman of the Department of Political Science at Washington and Jefferson College.
It could signify voter confusion, he said, which was apparent at the polls Tuesday over the Act 1 tax referendum question that many voters said they didn't understand.
It also might signal voter apathy or discontent, Mr. DiSarro said.
"I think some of that undervote is dissatisfaction with a candidate," he said.
Either way, Mr. DiSarro said, he doesn't expect the undervotes to play a large part in the November general election, although, he said, surveys could show whether they are symptomatic of a larger problem.
"If I was running the Pettit campaign, I would want to run a poll to find out what's going on," he said.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.