Voters might feel a sense of deja vu May 15 when they see the names of Phyllis Ranko Matheny and Judith Fisher on the Democratic ballot for prothonotary.

Four years ago, the two squared off in a bitter battle, with Ms. Fisher, the current county Democratic jury commissioner, garnering the Democratic nomination for the county office that handles the filing of civil cases, judgements and liens.

The incumbent, Ms. Ranko Matheny, stayed in the race by securing the GOP nod and won re-election by seven votes. At the time, though, there were court challenges and spirited debate over some ballot boxes that were left uncounted.

It is clear some bitter feelings remain, especially among factions in the local Democratic Party, but Ms. Fisher, 68, of South Strabane, said she accepted her loss in 2003 and had moved on with ideas for the future. She shies from discussing the subject at campaign appearances, despite frequently hearing about it from voters.

Advertise with us

Ms. Fisher said she wanted no sympathy votes, and that she hoped people understand her message of change for the office.

"My goal is to continue serving by initiating changes and continuously improving services," she said.

Ms. Fisher said 13 years as jury commissioner had taught her to deal with large numbers of people and how important it is to present a courteous and polite staff to the public, something she feels is lacking in the prothonotary's office today.

She said her management style differed from that of Ms. Ranko Matheny, and that she would like to modernize the office with an electronic filing system for lawyers and judges. Such a system has been incorporated with paper filing in several counties and recently was mandated in Beaver County, which no longer accepts paper filing.

Ms. Ranko Matheny, 66, of North Strabane, said e-filing was discussed briefly, then shot down by county judges when it became available.

Advertise with us

The office unveiled in-house remote access about a year ago for title searchers and plans to take the service to the Internet soon, she said.

The county recently contracted an Internet service that will make the information available online, along with docket entries for civil cases, judgements and liens.

Four other counties in the state provide the service, she said, including Philadelphia and Allegheny.

"Really, I think we're ahead of the game," she said.

Ms. Ranko Matheny has worked in the office for more than 30 years, first as a clerk/typist for nine years, then as a deputy prothonotary for another nine years. She is seeking a fourth term.

Advertise with us

She said she was committed to the job and works full time with her staff of 12 because it's necessary to manage the workload.

"We have 21/2 to three times the work we had 30 years ago and the same number of people," she said.

A wildcard in the equation could be yet a third Democratic candidate, John Trappuzano, of Cecil.

An account manager for a gas manufacturer and supplier, Mr. Trappuzano, 47, said he didn't know or care about the management styles of Ms. Ranko Matheny versus Ms. Fisher. He said he'd managed 60 people, including union and clerical workers, for nine years by getting them to work together.

"I want to know the people around me, and I want them to work as a team," he said. "I want people to want to come into the office and feel welcomed."

Advertise with us

Mr. Trappuzano hasn't been involved in politics in recent years, but has run for district justice and county controller.

He said he couldn't understand why no information from the prothonotary's office is available on the Internet, and why it's taking so long for plans to be made.

"The Internet is not new to people in Washington County," he said.

Mr. Trappuzano faces felony drug charges after Peters police charged him in December with attempting to pass a prescription that was not issued by the physician listed at a local Giant Eagle pharmacy.

Mr. Trappuzano has said he was doing a favor for a friend, and that he is confident of being cleared of the charges. He faces a preliminary hearing next month.

There is no Republican candidate for prothonotary.