A black woman elected to be Uniontown’s treasurer is claiming in a federal lawsuit that a sitting councilman, the city clerk and others conspired to block her from taking office because of her race.
Antoinette L. Hodge, who was overwhelmingly elected, has accused Councilman Martin Gatti, City Clerk Kimberly Marshall (identified as Mr. Gatti’s sister-in-law) and other unnamed defendants of a conspiracy to target her and thwart the will of voters.
Mr. Gatti and Ms. Marshall are described as "caucasian" in the lawsuit, filed Tuesday in U.S. District Court by attorney Joel Sansone.
“This case is about racism and the actions of persons who believe racism is the way to go,” Mr. Sansone said during a news conference Wednesday afternoon at his Downtown office. “I’m not sure how deep this conspiracy goes.”
Mr. Sansone on Wednesday asked the court to issue an injunction and force Uniontown to install Ms. Hodge as treasurer.
As treasurer, Ms. Hodge must be bonded to hold office. In her lawsuit, Ms. Hodge claims that Mr. Gatti canceled her bond without authority by telling the agency that issued it that "incriminating evidence" about her was uncovered during a background check.
Read More
Ms. Hodge also claims that in the call to BondExchange, a Charlotte, NC-based surety bond wholesale agency, Mr. Gatti referred to her as "colored." Mr. Sansone described that alleged comment as a "slip of the tongue" that revealed Mr. Gatti's "real motivation."
The bond agency denied that Mr. Gatti used the word "colored" in conversation with its employee and said the councilman would have no authority to cancel the bond.
Additionally, Ms. Hodge's lawsuit claims that Ms. Marshall told her, “We’ll get you,” the day that she was supposed to be sworn in.
The complaint alleges retaliation, racial discrimination, conspiracy and violations of the First and 14th Amendments. It seeks a jury trial.
Ms. Hodge, 50, of Uniontown, said she was “shocked” and “disgusted” by the situation.
Kenneth L. Huston, president of the state branch of the NAACP, also attended the news conference and called the situation “blatant racism.”
The defendants could not be reached for comment Wednesday.
Ms. Hodge, who ran as a Democrat, won more than 97% of the vote in the Nov. 5 general election. She was due to take office Jan. 6.
The lawsuit says that someone from the Fayette County Election Bureau told Ms. Hodge that official documentation of the election results would be given to the City of Uniontown. Ms. Hodge believes that the information was given to Ms. Marshall.
On Nov. 25, Ms. Hodge was informed that she had to apply to be bonded. She contacted Uniontown’s solicitor, Timothy Witt, about the procedure and was told, according to the lawsuit, that Ms. Marshall typically completed bond applications on behalf of elected officials.
Ms. Hodge gave her completed application to Mr. Witt. In the meantime, the lawsuit said, Mr. Witt and the head of the county’s Democratic Party “made repeated requests” for the certification of Ms. Hodge’s election results to Uniontown.
Roughly 48 days later, on Dec. 23, Ms. Marshall provided Ms. Hodge and the solicitor with the necessary documentation to certify the election results, the complaint said.
But five days later, Ms. Hodge was told that Penn National, a bonding company that handles coverage for Uniontown, could not provide her with the necessary bond because of credit report problems, according to the lawsuit.
Mr. Sansone said that Ms. Hodge was the victim of identity theft years ago, which has led to continuing credit problems. He also said that despite that, his client has been able to be bonded at her former job as a purchasing agent for The Johns Hopkins Hospital in Baltimore as well as currently as a trustee for a nonprofit church organization.
“The notion that she’s not trustworthy is nonsense,” Mr. Sansone said.
Ms. Hodge asked the solicitor if she could obtain bond on her own. She was told she could, and she did so.
But on Dec. 31, Ms. Hodge said she learned from the incoming mayor that she had to take an exam before assuming office as well as submit an affidavit of residency. Ms. Hodge said she believes that Ms. Marshall should have made her aware of the requirements but did not.
Ms. Hodge passed the test on New Year’s Day and waited to be sworn in Jan. 6 at the next council meeting. Mr. Witt provided all necessary documentation to Ms. Marshall on Jan. 3, the complaint said. That same day, however, Councilman Frank Palumbo told the mayor that Mr. Gatti “had informed him that he had canceled the plaintiff’s bond,” according to the complaint.
Ms. Hodge contacted BondExchange and asked if her bond had been revoked. The woman with whom she spoke asked Ms. Hodge if she was black or white, the complaint claims. Ms. Hodge said that she was African American, and the woman replied, “that sums it up,” according to the lawsuit.
In a later conversation — listened to, at least in part, by Ms. Hodge's mother and Uniontown’s Mayor-elect Bill Gerke — a BondExchange manager told Ms. Hodge that Mr. Gatti “had canceled Plaintiff’s bond at approximately 6:00 p.m. on or about January 3, 2020, shortly after Attorney Witt submitted Plaintiff’s documentation...” the lawsuit claims.
Mr. Gatti told the bonding company “that he had been ‘authorized’ to cancel [Ms. Hodge’s] bond by Defendant Uniontown and that he was doing so because of ‘incriminating evidence’ allegedly uncovered by Plaintiff’s mandated background search,” according to the lawsuit.
The lawsuit claims that Mr. Gatti was not authorized to cancel Ms. Hodge’s bond, and Mr. Sansone disputed the notion that her background check yielded any inappropriate or illegal behavior requiring revocation of her bond.
A. BondExchange manager also said that Mr. Gatti had referred to Ms. Hodge as “colored,” the lawsuit said.
BondExchange denied that either of its employees made or heard any race-related comments. Executives there acknowledged that phone calls are not recorded but said they spoke with both employees involved in the calls.
"Her claim that this individual called us and told us this individual is 'colored' is 100 percent false. If he had done that we would have immediately said that’s illegal," said Richard Popp, BondExchange's general counsel.
“We want to be on the record that what she said is entirely false about our business,” Mr. Popp said. “That’s nothing we would say and nothing we would take into account in a bonding or an underwriting decision.”
Mr. Gerke said that he was patched in to the phone call by Ms. Hodge and was on the line for about eight seconds. He said he did not hear the manager’s alleged “colored” comment.
“I didn’t hear that,” Mr. Gerke said. “The only thing that we talked about was who made this call to you concerning Ms. Hodge’s eligibility to bond. ...The gentleman from BondExchange told me, ‘Martin Gatti.’ That was the only bit of conversation I had with that gentleman.”
At the installation ceremony, Uniontown’s mayor, council members and controller — all white — were sworn in.
But not Ms. Hodges, the complaint said.
Mr. Gerke said that Ms. Hodges was not sworn in on the advice of the solicitor.
After the meeting, the lawsuit claims, Ms. Marshall “aggressively approached” Ms. Hodge and said, “We’ll get you.”
“No matter what color she is, the Third Class City Code says that any official that needs bonded has two weeks after being installed to get bond,” Mr. Sansone said, meaning that his client did not need to be bonded at the time of her installation as treasurer.
“Leave the race out of it for the moment, there’s no excuse,” Mr. Sansone said. “But you come to the inescapable conclusion that you’ve got some racists down there trying to control events.”
Mr. Witt said he had not seen the complaint but expects that Ms. Hodge will be sworn in for her four-year term as soon as he gets the original copy of a $150,000 surety bond that she has secured — through the same bond wholesaler that had originally revoked her — and reviews it.
“There was additional information that was provided by Ms. Hodge which we passed along to the insurance carrier which satisfied their requirement,” said David Gonsalves, BondExchange's president.
Mr. Witt said he is reviewing the overall situation, which publicly came to light Monday.
Mr. Witt, who has been Uniontown solicitor for a few years, said he has never heard Mr. Gatti make any derogatory comments about race.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.