A Bethel Park school board member whose request for information from district officials was denied by the board president found another way to get the information he wanted by submitting a Right to Know request as a private citizen.
Board member Ken Nagel in July made a request to Superintendent Joseph Pasquerilla for regarding long term-plans for building maintenance, staffing levels and curriculum. But board President Donna Cook intervened, and directed the superintendent not to provide the information.
At a meeting Tuesday, Mr. Nagel said he no longer was making a request for that information as a board member because the district provided it under his right to know request.
Mr. Nagel requested the information shortly after the board voted in June 6-3 to cut taxes by 8 percent with no public discussion. He said he wanted the information so he could better understand the long-term impacts of the board vote to cut taxes, which will reduce revenue.
“It’s pretty ‘out there’ that the board cannot provide me with information that I am entitled to as a private citizen,” Mr. Nagel said during Tuesday’s board meeting, that featured a testy exchange between him and Ms. Cook.
Ms. Cook said she directed Mr. Pasquerilla not to share it with him because a vote by the majority of the board was needed in order to provide that type of information. She said it has been a long term board policy that requests for information go through the board president and have to reflect the wishes of the majority of the board.
“The board has always operated that one board member doesn’t carry all the weight,” Ms. Cook said.
District solicitor Patricia Andrews said requests for information have always had to go through the board president “to prevent one board member from requesting a lot of information from the administration.”
“That is the role of the president — to make sure the operating practices are being followed and that one individual board member doesn’t have the authority to get information that the entire board doesn’t want,” she said.
“The sad thing is, this information is all information we need in order to make informed decisions,” said board member Pamela Dobos.
Board member Jim Means told Mr. Nagel, “It’s completely inappropriate to ask for information from subordinates,” saying that Mr. Nagel asked individual staff members for information and not the superintendent.
“The email was directed to the superintendent,” Mr. Nagel said. “I’ve been asking these questions for well over a year. It was clear I wasn’t denied by him (the superintendent) but by an individual board member,” he said.
In June, the board voted 6-3 to reduce the school tax rate by 1.87 mills, with no public discussion, prompting a protest by residents.
Voting for the tax cut were Ms. Cook, Mr. Means and board members David Amaditz, Connie Ruhl, Ron Werkmeister and the late Cynthia Buckley. Voting no were Mr. Nagel, Ms. Dobos and Barry Christenson voted no.
Three of the six who voted for the tax decrease — Ms. Cook, Mr. Werkmeister and Mr. Amaditz — were defeated in the May primary and will not be on the November ballot.
Mr. Nagel said Thursday that he requested the information so that he could have a “firm grasp” of what was going on in the district “so we can assess whether we are spending money efficiently.”
He said because he gathered the information via right to know request as a citizen and not as a board member he said it gives him some leeway as far as sharing it.
“If anybody asks me what the information was, I don’t have a problem sharing,” he said.
He added that of the information he has read thus far, “It’s enlightened me a lot as far as some of the questions that have been open ended.”
Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.