A group of residents is unhappy with the Bethel Park school board’s recent decision to cut taxes without discussion and held a protest before the last board meeting and say that further protests are likely.

About 50 people gathered outside the district offices before the August board meeting to protest the board’s June vote to decrease taxes by 8.2 percent. The protest was organized by Tom Duerr, a resident of Bethel Park. A group called Bethel Park Deserves Better, headed by Sharon Janosik also attended the protest, which was held for about an hour prior to the start of the school board’s regular meeting on Aug. 27.

“The focus of the rally was to demonstrate that the residents of our community demand better from our elected officials — better leadership, transparency, accountability, long-term planning, fiscal responsibility, education, rankings, property values and stakeholder participation,” Ms. Janosik said.

In June, the board voted 6-3 to reduce the school tax rate by 1.87 mills. Board President Donna Cook, along with board members David Amaditz, Connie Ruhl, Cynthia Buckley, Ron Werkmeister and Jim Means voted yes. Board members Ken Nagel, Pamela Dobos and Barry Christenson voted no.

Advertise with us

At that meeting, Mr. Werkmeister made a motion to reduce the millage rate with no public discussion on the matter. At a meeting earlier in the year the board approved a preliminary millage rate of 22.8763, the same as the 2018-19 school year, but on June 25, Mr. Werkmeister made a motion to decrease the millage to 21 mills.

“The majority of the board chose to suddenly reduce the school district’s revenue outside of the public process and that is not acceptable,” Ms. Janosik said, adding that there was no public input or projections on how the reduction would impact the district into the future before the board voted in June.

At the Aug. 27 meeting, Ms. Janosik presented the board with a petition calling for the resignation of the six board members who voted in favor of the decrease. The petition has garnered 558 signatures online and another 50 signed a paper petition.

“Unfortunately there’s no mechanism for the public to remove sitting school directors, so the petition serves more as a vote of no confidence,” Ms. Janosik said.

Of the six who voted for the tax decrease, three — Mr. Werkmeister, Mr. Amaditz and Ms. Cook — were defeated in the May primary and will not be on the November ballot.

Advertise with us

Mr. Means said at the meeting that the June vote was “all about reducing the cost of education for taxpayers.”

Ms. Cook was not at the meeting where the protest occurred, but responded by email when asked to respond the complaints about the vote to change the tax ate.

“As far as citizens' reactions to the tax decrease, there appears to be a very vocal group of citizens; however, I and other board members have heard from other citizens who believe the decrease was a good idea and even think it should have happened sooner,” she wrote.

Also at the Aug. 27 meeting, Mr. Nagel asked district administration officials for information regarding long-term plans for building maintenance, staffing levels and financial information.

“Most of this information is information I’ve been asking for for a year,” Mr. Nagel said after the meeting.

Advertise with us

Mr. Nagel added he asked Superintendent Joseph Pasquerilla for the information back in July, but said that Ms. Cook, the board president, directed Mr. Paquerilla not to share it with him.

Mr. Nagel said he will soon be filing a right to know request with the district for the information.

Ms. Cook said Mr. Nagel’s request was rejected because he was the only one seeking the information.

“We must be cognizant of taking our administrators away from their every day responsibilities in order to do extra work to supply information, charts, etc., and that's why we have always felt said information needs to be at the request of more than one or two members. We try to be cognizant of board requests that are necessary for current voting items on our agenda. Mr. Nagel's requests were not for this type of info.

“We typically also ask that Board members run any such requests through the Board President so that we are also cognizant of how we are using the valuable time of our administrators as the Board President works closely with the Superintendent on such requests.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Means made a motion to censure Mr. Nagel for interrupting the meeting with the request for information, but the motion failed to receive a second.

“There is nothing I’m asking for that the PSBA (Pennsylvania School Boards Association) doesn’t ask for,” Mr. Nagel said. “These are legitimate things for a board member to ask.”

“I’m upset. Regardless of whether or not this (tax decrease) is sustainable, we were not provided the information to make these determinations,” Mr. Nagel said, adding that the vote on the tax decrease was a “spur of the moment amendment” that he was not aware of prior to the June 25 meeting.

Ms. Janosik told the board that the information Mr. Nagel is seeking is information “you should have already had when making the decision to cut the revenue with no plan for the future.”

“I’m sorry that the needs of our children are inconveniencing ‘the six,’” Ms. Janosik said.

Advertise with us

While no other protests are being planned at the moment, Ms. Janosik said, “It seems apparent that the majority of the sitting board is intent on obstructing the minority sitting members and the four incoming members from access to any information necessary to begin addressing this fiscal emergency.”

However, she said, “If they choose to continue down this path, residents are going to become more incensed and angry, so more protests are quite likely.”

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.