News that local property taxes are going down normally would be greeted as a welcome development.

But a 6-3 vote by Bethel Park school directors this week to reduce the tax rate by 8 percent and use $5 million from the district’s coffers to balance the budget has prompted angry accusations from other board members and the teachers union that the vote was one of politics and sour grapes.

Many of the board members who voted to reduce taxes are lame duck directors who lost their seats in the May primary election.

The action occurred at a meeting Tuesday night, when the board was scheduled to adopt a new budget for the 2019-20 school year. In a previous meeting, the board had approved a preliminary budget that would keep the millage rate at 22.8763 mills.

Advertise with us

But at Tuesday’s meeting, board member Ron Werkmeister, one of the incumbents who was defeated in the primary, made a motion to reduce the tax rate to 21 mills, catching several board members by surprise.

Board members Ken Nagel and Barry Christenson said they were unaware that a motion was going to be made to decrease taxes.

“It was not discussed with the three of us who voted against the change, or at any time in a public meeting,” Mr. Christenson said. “For five months of the budgeting process, the tax rate was recommended to be 22.8763,” he said.

Mr. Nagel said there “wasn’t even a hint” that someone would make a motion to decrease taxes as part of the $89 million budget.

The new tax rate was approved in a 6-3 vote, with board President  Donna Cook, Mr. Werkmeister, David Amaditz, Connie Ruhl, Cynthia Buckley and Jim Means voting yes. Mr. Nagel, Mr. Christenson and Pamela Dobos voted no.

Advertise with us

The new millage rate, which reduces the tax rate by about 1.87 mills, means that taxpayers will pay about $2,100 per every $100,000 of assessed property value in the next school year. To make up for the millage reduction, the district will be using approximately $5 million of its unassigned fund balance to balance the budget.

“This completely diminishes our unassigned fund balance,” said Mr. Nagel, who added the unassigned fund balance is in place for unexpected expenses that come up throughout the year.

He added that residents of the district that have reached out to him regarding the matter are “sick to their stomachs, hurt and outraged that our children are being put out as pawns.”

“I hate to speculate, but there were six people who voted for that decrease without any discussion - against the recommendation of our director of finance and our superintendent - with hardly any due diligence or asking any questions,” Mr. Nagel said.

“Out of those six, three of them were rejected by the voters in the primary on both ballots, so they will not be on the November ballot and the fourth one is very likely to lose,” Mr. Nagel said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Werkmeister, Mr. Amaditz and Ms. Cook all were defeated on both parties’ ballots in the primary. Mr. Means and Mr. Christenson are the only incumbents who will be on the November ballot.

Neither Mr. Werkmeister or Ms. Cook could be reached for comment.

“The move seems like a political calculation to benefit a small group of people at the expense of our children,” Mr. Nagel said. He noted that none of the six who voted for the decrease has children in the school district.

Mr. Nagel said it will likely take “five years of maximum tax increases just to catch up to where we are now.”

Mr. Christenson said he voted “no” on the motion to decrease taxes “because of the lack of analysis that went into the recommendation.”

Advertise with us

“I’m in favor of reducing taxes if we can do it in a sustainable way that ensures a high-quality education for our students,” he said, but added, “This was an irresponsible step driven by emotional frustration of some departing board members.”

Mr. Christenson said the motion went against the recommendation of the district’s administration and that no financial analysis was done regarding the long-term sustainability or impact of the tax rate change.

Asked to comment about the board’s decision that went against the administration’s recommendation, Superintendent Joseph Pasquerilla issued a statement through a spokeswoman.

“The Administration put the motion on the agenda to pass the 2019-2020 budget with a zero millage increase, but the final budget that is adopted is ultimately the Board’s decision. It is the Administration’s job to work within the budget parameters the board sets,” the statement said.

Mr. Nagel said he has a lot of confidence in the district’s administration and staff and he hopes that the board can find savings in other ways and said he and Mr. Christenson and Ms. Dobos “are going to everything we can to rectify this situation and we’ll continue working on it diligently to try to provide the best education we can for our children.”

Advertise with us

The union representing Bethel Park teachers was sharply critical of the decision to decrease the tax rate, calling it “short-sighted” and “irresponsible.” The Bethel Park Federation of Teachers said in a statement issued Thursday that the decision went against the recommendation of the superintendent and took action without any public discussion.

“They knew the administration had not hired any teachers for three years and planned to use some of the reserves to hire staff that provides direct services to our students,” said a statement from William Wells, the union president. “While cutting taxes might make the outgoing directors popular now, it forces incoming school directors to take the heat for raising taxes in the future to continue to provide children a high-quality, rigorous and well-rounded education.”

Deana Carpenter, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.