A former police chief charged with stealing heroin from his department’s evidence cache will not undergo electronic home monitoring before his next court appearance, Allegheny County President Judge Jeffrey A. Manning ordered Friday.

Timothy Butler, 42, of Finleyville “shouldn’t be treated any worse or any better than” recovering addicts in similar straits, Judge Manning said from the bench. He assumes Mr. Butler led an otherwise-exemplary life until now, he said.

The office of county District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. sought home monitoring for Mr. Butler, arguing that he violated the public’s trust as Elizabeth Borough police chief. He turned himself in and was arraigned Thursday on charges of theft, obstruction, drug possession and prohibited acts.

Mr. Butler’s attorney, Charles LoPresti, said home monitoring, often known as house arrest, was “never an appropriate response to the bail in this case.” District Judge Beth S. Mills released him Thursday on non-monetary bond pending a preliminary hearing Feb. 6.

Advertise with us

“This is a man who had 20 years of immaculate service and owns a home,” Mr. LoPresti said, going on to mention Mr. Butler’s wife and kids. The former chief has no prior criminal record and is not a flight risk, he said.

In line with Judge Manning’s order, Mr. Butler will undergo an evaluation to determine whether he should be placed into inpatient drug treatment, Mr. LoPresti said. The DA’s office had sought mandatory inpatient care, but the judge ruled that Mr. Butler’s current treatment is sufficient, Zappala spokesman Mike Manko said.

Mr. Butler is continuing outpatient care that began early this month, around the time he confessed misdeeds to a police sergeant who worked under him, Mr. LoPresti said.

That sergeant, Garrett Kimmell, is now the acting police chief in Elizabeth after Mr. Butler resigned. In early December, Sgt. Kimmell discovered the theft from the department, police have said. Just more than 9,800 stamp bags of heroin or fentanyl were found to be missing or empty, according to a criminal complaint.

Upon questioning, Mr. Butler admitted a heroin addiction that developed after he was prescribed Vicodin for neck and back pain, police said in the complaint against the former chief. It appears his problem stemmed from overprescription, Mr. LoPresti has said.

Advertise with us

The former chief worked in the Elizabeth Borough police department 19 years and ascended to the top job in 2014. He resigned Tuesday. Now unemployed, he’s doing volunteer work and taking his kids to and from school, Mr. LoPresti said.

Mr. Butler is “hoping for a new career and a new job so he can support his wife and his kids,” he said. “It’s a tragic case from that standpoint.”

Adam Smeltz: 412-263-2625, asmeltz@post-gazette.com, @asmeltz.