A sewage and sewer line tap-in dispute between the Clairton Municipal Authority, nearby municipalities and authorities has spilled over into the Monongahela River and the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas.
In a civil action filed Wednesday, the Peters Creek Sanitary Authority, Jefferson Hills and South Park Township asked the court to require the Clairton Municipal Authority to end a tap-in ban that has limited development in those municipalities, and provide information on a much delayed, $40 million sewage plant expansion.
The Clairton authority “has banned Plaintiffs from issuing sanitary sewer taps thus stopping development in Plaintiffs’ watersheds,” the filing claims.
Peters Creek operates a public sanitary sewer system that serves South Park and Jefferson Hills, and links to the Clairton sewer plant. Under a May 2012 agreement, Clairton agreed to treat sewage transported to it, expand its sewage treatment plant, provide sanitary sewer taps to the Peters Creek authority and the communities it services, and provide capacity for additional tap connections into the future.
According to the lawsuit, the ongoing sewage plant expansion project has experienced overruns that have increased the cost of the project by 39 percent.
The lawsuit asks the court to order Clairton to document the reasons for the cost overruns, provide audit information and provide details on what is being called “Phase 2” of the expansion project.
Gary Matta, attorney for the Clairton Municipal Authority, said Peters Creek has been threatening legal action ever since the sewage plant expansion was done, and has been difficult to deal with on the tap-ins.
"Unfortunately this is something that is going to cost the rate payers more money by filing lawsuits that are frivolous in nature and could be resolved if we were to get into a meeting," Mr. Matta said.
He said the sewage plant expansion, although mandated by the state Department of Environmental Protection, was delayed several times because the Peters Creek Sanitary Authority failed to approve a new “537 Plan,” also known as a sewage facilities plan.
Such plans provide for the resolution of existing sewage disposal problems, provide for the future sewage disposal needs of new land development, and provide for future municipal sewage disposal needs.
"Due to this delay, we had to suspend any additional taps being issued to any of the upstream communities," Mr. Matta said. "We have an overflow issue going on now, with sewage going into the river because the plant is not capable of expanding. Due to that, we cannot have anymore taps provided until we get the plant expanded."
The filing asked the court for a “judicial declaration of the parties’ rights and liabilities” in an effort to prevent “probable future litigation.”
Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1983, or on Twitter @donhopey. Staff writer Julian Routh contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.