A former official at the Elizabeth Township Sanitary Authority has been ordered to pay a $10,000 fine and $1,000 in restitution after the State Ethics Commission found that he violated ethical guidelines.
Robert Similo, 73, of Elizabeth, this week said he signed a consent agreement and paid the fine and restitution to the Ethics Commission. The action followed a lengthy investigation that found he improperly benefited from his longstanding relationship with the sanitary authority.
Mr. Similo had served as a board member of the sanitary authority from August 1993 through the end of 2012, when a new slate of township commissioners didn’t reappoint him to the board. He served as chairman of the authority from 2000 through 2012.
The Elizabeth Township Sanitary Authority no longer exists. The authority has been folded into the Elizabeth Township Authority.
Released last month, the report capped an investigation launched in 2013 and resulted in a consent agreement between the parties.
Mr. Similo was a science teacher at Thomas Jefferson High School, until his retirement in 1997. Since 1980 he also has operated a company called S&S Scientific Supply Inc.
State ethics guidelines prohibit officials from doing business with or profiting from agencies where they previously have served for a period of at least one year, but Mr. Similo served as a paid consultant and a vendor to the authority in the months following his final term, according to a report from the commission.
In a split vote in February 2013, the sanitary authority appointed Mr. Similo as a “business consultant,” being paid $75 per hour for no more than 20 hours per week, according to the commission report.
“Some members of the ETSA board...wanted [Mr. Similo] to remain involved with the ETSA despite the actions of the Elizabeth Township commissioners,” the report stated.
In the meantime, the solicitor for the sanitary authority queried the Ethics Commission about whether Mr. Similo’s appointment would be proper.
In late April, the Ethics Commission released an opinion that Mr. Similo could not work for the sanitary authority for a period of at least one year after he left the board. But by that time, Mr. Similo had already been paid $2,144 for consulting work performed from February through April 2013.
“[Mr. Similo] decided not to wait for a commission determination and instead entered into a contract with the ETSA within one year of him leaving service as a member of the ETSA board,” the report said.
After an unsuccessful appeal, Mr. Similo offered to work at no charge for the authority, and in August 2013, the board approved an amended contract in which Mr. Similo would continue to work as a consultant until the end of 2013 with no compensation.
But that wasn’t the end of the issue.
During the same time period -- August 2013 -- Mr. Similo’s scientific supply company began supplying the authority with a device for manhole covers that reduces the amount of rainwater that enters sanitary sewer systems. Years earlier, Mr. Similo had designed the device, called an “eliminator” and he owned the exclusive distribution rights to it in the Eastern U.S.
From December 2002 through June 2012, a company called COTT Manufacturing had been supplying the eliminators to the sanitary authority and other local authorities. Mr. Similo had contracted COTT to make the eliminators and had previously agreed to have the manufacturer sell them to the Elizabeth Township Sanitary Authority for cost, which was $28 each.
Mr. Similo’s involvement with the eliminators had previously drawn the attention of the Ethics Commission, which in 2003 ruled that his involvement with the devices didn’t constitute a conflict of interest because Mr. Similo wasn’t earning a profit on the eliminators sold to ETSA.
But that changed in 2013, when Mr. Similo began selling the eliminators to the sanitary authority at a rate of $45 each, which was earning him and his company a profit of $28.50 on each unit sold the ethics commission said.
“Similo had a markup of approximately 72.3 percent on each eliminator sold to the ETSA,” the State Ethics Commission noted.
The report said Mr. Similo’s company billed the authority for 100 of them in August 2013.
Reached at home this week, Mr. Similo said he was thankful to put the matter to rest, though he felt the investigation was politically motivated.
“It was a political vendetta that’s all it was,” he said. “By the time you pay the attorneys and everything it isn’t worth it. We could have fought them and probably won but it would have cost more money.”
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1159 or on Twitter @janicecrompton.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.