The West Mifflin school board voted Thursday to accept a settlement agreement with the Pennsylvania Department of Education and the Duquesne City School District, ending a years-long tussle over student funding.
The West Mifflin School District sued the Duquesne district and the state department of education in 2016, claiming it was owed hundreds of thousands of dollars for educating Duquesne’s students as part of an agreement that was inked in 2007.
According to the settlement, the West Mifflin district will receive even more than that — potentially $13 million over the next decade.
“Our kids are going to get a better education and there’s no tax increase,” said board member Phil Shar, who championed the effort to get the state and Duquesne to contribute more funds after it began sending students to West Mifflin schools. “I never thought we would get this much money.”
As part of the settlement, the Duquesne district will pay West Mifflin $500,000 within 60 days. Additionally, it will receive $175,000 annually in IDEA-B special education funding, and Duquesne will pay a per student tuition of $12,718 for this school year, a $1,245 increase per student over last school year. The tuition will increase by at least 2 percent a year in subsequent years, West Mifflin said.
Duquesne will also pay the Steel Center Vo-Tech school directly for Duquesne students who attend there, saving West Mifflin $11,000 annually, according to the district.
And since 2014, when the district began discussions about pursuing a lawsuit, West Mifflin has received federal Title I funding for each Duquesne student enrolled, Mr. Shar said. Last year, the district received more than $620,000 in federal funding, and anticipates more than $1 million for 2017-18.
When the state was forced to close Duquesne High School due to chronically low test scores and dire finances, a majority of Duquesne’s ninth- through 12th-grade students moved to West Mifflin High School. Five years later, Duquesne’s seventh- and eighth-grade students also moved to West Mifflin schools.
This year, the district enrolls 299 Duquesne students, the West Miffln district said. A number of Duquesne secondary students also attend schools in the East Allegheny School District.
As part of the original partnership agreement, West Mifflin was reimbursed per student, but argued in the lawsuit that the Legislature miscalculated when it created the funding formula in 2012. The district claimed it was owed about $819,000 in back payments, or the equivalent of nearly 1 mill in property taxes paid by West Mifflin taxpayers, the district alleged.
The district’s suit also maintained that it had been shortchanged for transportation costs and for educating special education students and students enrolled in career and technical schools.
A spokeswoman for the Pennsylvania Department of Education said the department had no comment on the settlement.
Bill Andrews, the solicitor for the Duquesne district, declined to comment until the settlement was finalized.
The West Mifflin board unanimously agreed to accept the settlement at it’s meeting Thursday, and also agreed to ask the East Allegheny district to contribute about half of West Mifflin’s $200,000 in legal costs.
East Allegheny benefits from the settlement because that district will also receive the higher per-student tuition payments from Duquesne, Mr. Shar said.
As a result of the savings and new revenues agreed to as part of the settlement, Mr. Shar estimates the district will receive between $11 million and $13 million over the next decade.
“I think we have a fair settlement offer,” West Mifflin Superintendent Daniel Castagna said during the meeting. “This is a win for students who live in the Duquesne City School District … this is a win for the students who live in the West Mifflin School District.”
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1590.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.