Allegheny County Medical Examiner Karl E. Williams is reconsidering his office’s decision to rule the death of a West Mifflin man a homicide following questions raised by the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and a new look at the medical record.
“It is under active review,” Dr. Williams said Friday.
Mark Kleist died Jan. 25, 2016, after toppling down a flight of stairs in his West Mifflin home after suffering a seizure. Authorities blamed the seizure on a traumatic injury they said Mr. Kleist received a decade earlier during an assault outside a Duquesne bar.
Mr. Kleist’s manner of death was originally listed as pending while his brain was sent to a neuropathologist at the University of Pittsburgh’s medical school for examination. Five months later, on June 23, the medical examiner’s office changed the ruling to homicide based on the study of the brain, a review of Mr. Kleist’s medical records and consultations with several forensic pathologists.
If not for the injury in 2006, authorities determined, Mr. Kleist would never have developed seizures. And if not for the seizure while standing at the top of a set of steps in the home he shared with his mother, they believed, Mr. Kleist would not have tumbled and fatally struck his head at the bottom.
On Thursday, Pittsburgh Crime Stoppers issued a news release seeking the public’s help that disclosed for the first time that police were investigating Mr. Kleist’s death as a homicide. They referenced the “2006 assault.”
But it is not clear there was ever an assault.
Without a doubt, Mr. Kleist suffered a head injury on Aug. 13, 2006, outside Craig’s Bar in Duquesne. A woman arriving at the bar around 1:22 a.m. that day found him outside, bloody and unresponsive, according to Duquesne police Chief R. Scott Adams. Mr. Kleist had to be taken by medical helicopter to a hospital, where Dr. Williams said his seizures first manifested.
How did Mr. Kleist, a regular at the bar, get hurt?
Chief Adams, whose department investigated the incident, does not know.
“No one has ever come forward and said this guy was assaulted,” Chief Adams said Friday.
On Friday, Dr. Williams checked his office’s records and consulted with the forensic pathologist who handled the Kleist case, which he called “complex.” Dr. Williams could not say definitively whether Mr. Kleist’s traumatic brain injury stemmed from an assault.
“Right now I have no definite evidence to indicate whether it was an assault or a fall. There are indications both ways in the report, and I’m trying to resolve that discrepancy,” Dr. Williams said. “It’s labeled both ways in the hospital records. It’s labeled both ways throughout the file that I have in my office. I can’t determine right now what, in fact, happened. We’re going to look into that a little bit more.”
Dr. Williams said there are references in his files to a “possible assault.”
However, he said, “I don’t have anything at this point to prove it’s an assault.”
And if there is no assault that caused the seizures that led to Mr. Kleist’s death, there might not be any culprits. And without culprits, there might not be a homicide.
“The key findings are just not there,” Dr. Williams said. “If we can’t resolve it, we’ll have to change the manner to undetermined.”
Asked how his office decided to rule Mr. Kleist’s death a homicide after months of investigation and in light of a lack of clarity in the record, Dr. Williams said he did not know.
For now, the 2006 incident remains a mystery. County police said Mr. Kleist walked into the bar with a blue bag and made a phone call. Then he left. He was found a short time later.
Although Mr. Kleist did not report being assaulted that day, Chief Adams said the man did report an assault three years later.
On June 21, 2009, around 7:45 p.m., Mr. Kleist told police he was attacked by three men inside Craig’s Bar.
Mr. Kleist told police that one of the three men approached him outside the bar and said he owed him $50 and wanted to be repaid. Mr. Kleist said he told them he didn’t owe any money. He said he went back inside the bar. A short time later, the chief said, the men returned and assaulted him.
The chief said that his officers could never identify the assailants.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.