A convicted felon and former nursing home administrator was held for trial today on charges that last year she fleeced an 89-year-old Mt. Lebanon man out of more than $300,000 through a complicated scheme.

Martha Bell, 70, of West Mifflin, who served both federal and state time, appeared in court with a walker, shackled and wearing a red jail shirt and pants. Her right hand shook as if from tremors. She is charged with theft by deception, receiving stolen property and deceptive or fraudulent business practices.

She faced her accuser, Richard Chatak, who walked with a cane and said he tried to help her because her former late business partner was his lifelong friend. He said he trusted her and called himself "stupid" for doing so.

"She lied to me. I was trying to help a poor woman," he testified. "I just want my money that's for my pension...I'm sorry I ever talked to her. I'm sorry I met her."

Advertise with us

During the two-hour preliminary hearing, Bell's attorney tried to convince District Judge Blaise Larotonda that the prosecution did not prove that Bell engaged in any deceptive business practices when she got the alleged victim to write 33 checks to her for $322,000 between April and August 2015.

"There is a lot of conflicting testimony, your honor," attorney James Paulick said during his closing argument, trying to get the charges dismissed.

The testimony to which he referred concerned so-called bed licenses for nursing homes, and government reimbursements Bell contends she is owed.

Detectives with the Allegheny County district attorney's office accused Bell of claiming she needed money from the victim to get lucrative bed licenses out of escrow so she could sell them for up to $3 million and split the proceeds with the victim.

Mr. Chatak said Bell told him that the bed licenses "were money in the bank..."

Advertise with us

“Every time the victim asked for his money to be repaid, the actor had a different excuse as to why she couldn’t pay him back," a criminal complaint against Bell said.

DA's Detective Jackelyn Weibel claimed in court paperwork and in testimony today that her research showed the licenses to which Bell referred do not exist. But Mr. Paulick disagreed with her analysis.

"This is a case with a paper trail a mile long...Not one of them says Martha and her companies do not own these bed licenses," Mr. Paulick said. "There's no letter. Nothing was produced. I would say that would be the central piece of evidence."

According to the complaint, state officials said that any bed licenses Bell “purported to still own are now ‘dead,’” after her former nursing home, Ronald Reagan Atrium I Nursing and Rehabilitation Center, was closed in 2004, and that there is “no such thing as bed licenses being held in escrow.”

According to the complaint, Bell deposited the money in her account and then withdrew about $122,000 of it, with many transactions occurring at the Rivers casino, the Meadows casino and stores such as Levin Furniture, Macy’s, Victoria’s Secret and restaurants. The money was also used to make restitution payments and pay tax bills, the complaint said.

Advertise with us

When detectives interviewed Bell, she showed them documents, emails and court transcripts she alleged proved that she had bed licenses, and that showed there was a shortage of nursing home beds in Allegheny County. She also gave them a document dated Nov. 1 that said the $322,000 she received was “for her services... time she worked trying to get the bed licenses and ... funds issues worked out,” the complaint said.

Assistant District Attorney John Fitzgerald said that Bell's comments to the victim kept changing, claiming that she needed the money from him first as a loan, then as a buy-in from a prospective business partner, then as a salary.

"It was all materially misleading if not outright false," Mr. Fitzgerald said. "She's essentially selling a lottery ticket and disguising it as a good business investment."

Mr. Fitzgerald told the court, "Its just one lie after another after another. She can't stick to one story because none of them make sense."

District Judge Larotonda said he was not convinced to hold Bell for trial until the victim testified in a strong, clear voice about his experience.

Advertise with us

"I just think she misrepresented herself," District Judge Larotonda said.

Bell was convicted of health care fraud in federal court in 2005, and then of involuntary manslaughter and neglect of a care-dependent person in state court in 2007, stemming from the 2001 death of Mabel Taylor, a resident at the facility. She was also convicted of theft in state court a year later.

Bell was ordered to serve five years in federal prison and was released June 24, 2011. She then began serving a 22- to 44-month state prison term for Ms. Taylor’s death.

She was released from state prison April 28, 2013, according to a spokeswoman with the Pennsylvania Board of Probation and Parole. Her probation does not end until Oct. 3, 2023.

Bell faces a potential hearing for violating her probation, which state officials said runs until 2023.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.