A Whitehall man accused of making threatening phone calls to three Baldwin-Whitehall school board members testified Monday that he made the calls because he was frustrated by the board having him removed from a public meeting and forbidding him from attending in the future.

In the voicemail messages he left, which were played during his nonjury trial before Common Pleas Judge Jill E. Rangos, Thomas Barchfeld said that since the "school board stopped him from exercising his First Amendment right then he would be forced to exercise his Second Amendment right. ‘I have been reasonable long enough. It's time to start being unreasonable,’'" the criminal complaint said.

He is charged with harassment and making terroristic threats. Judge Rangos is permitting attorneys to file additional briefs on the matter, and she will issue her verdict on Feb. 17.

During his testimony, Mr. Barchfeld, 60, said at the April 2, 2014, school meeting, board members instructed two armed state constables to remove him.

Advertise with us

"They didn't give me a reason I had to leave," Mr. Barchfeld said. "They didn't give me a warning."

Four days later, he received a letter from the school solicitor instructing him that he was not welcome in the future.

According to proseuctors, Mr. Barchfeld called school board members Martin Schmotzer, Ray Rosing and Larry Pantuso on May 23-24, 2014, and threatened them.

During his testimony Monday, Mr. Pantuso said he took Mr. Barchfeld's message to be a "direct threat to my life, which, to me, left no other interpretation other than that my life was threatened."

But Mr. Barchfeld said the phone calls were his way of saying that, while the school board could infringe on his First Amendment right to attend and speak at their meetings, they could not take away his Second Amendment right to bear arms.

Advertise with us

Mr. Barchfeld, who has a history of problems with Mr. Schmotzer, said he owned a shotgun at the time, but had never used it, and didn't consider it to be a weapon.

"Did you have an intent to terrorize anyone?" asked his defense attorney, Thomas N. Farrell.

"No, I didn't," Mr. Barchfeld answered."I just wanted to exercise my Second Amendment right to possess a firearm. They brought in deadly force against me at that school board meeting.

“Everybody has a Constitutional right to bear arms.”

On cross-examination, Mr. Barchfeld admitted that after his first phone call to Mr. Schmotzer early in the morning on May 23, he was warned by Whitehall police to have no further contact with board members. Still, he said he then made the additional calls, including three in a row to Mr. Rosing.

Advertise with us

“He hung up on me,” Mr. Barchfeld said.

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.