Commissioners in Mt. Lebanon got an earful Monday night from a roomful of residents, parents and students over two controversial decisions.
Along with the expected backlash over a 4-1 decision to continue a whitetail deer sharpshooting program early next year, commissioners heard from many people concerned about high school students parking on residential streets.
After much debate, it was a compromise suggested by Commissioner Dave Brumfield that persuaded the board to temporarily curtail parking on Lebanon Hills Drive and Main Entrance Drive, from Washington Road to Circle Drive. The area will be closed for parking from 7 to 9 a.m. on school days for a trial period of six months. Commissioners plan to reassess the issue in early April. The restrictions are expected to be in place when students return from winter break in early January.
Residents along the streets near Mt. Lebanon High School had been complaining about students parking along the street, blocking driveways, parking on leaf piles and other nuisances. Some called police to express their concern over safety.
Commissioners had planned to close a much larger swath of Lebanon Hills and Main Entrance drives, including Outlook Drive, but students said they that would be unfair and would only push them to park in other neighborhoods.
“I don’t think restricting parking access to students is fair,” said student Sam Rothschild, who said that while parking passes are available for the Mt. Lebanon United Lutheran Church on Washington Road, getting out of the lot is cumbersome and left turns aren’t allowed.
“It takes 10 to 15 minutes to get out of the church lot,” he said.
Other students said they only park a few times a year and don’t feel it’s necessary to purchase the $75 parking pass from the school, where parking space has been limited due to construction.
Residents in the neighborhood were mixed in their views.
“There are visibility and safety issues,” said Matt Wood of Lebanon Hills Drive, who said the issue was traffic in the busy neighborhood, not parking. “We believe the solution should come from the school, not the residents.”
Nancy Klucher of Main Entrance Drive said it was an unfair burden to residents, especially because there are parking restrictions on other streets near schools in Mt. Lebanon.
“The situation seems to be getting worse and worse,” she said.
School district spokeswoman Cissy Bowman said the district has had an agreement with the church to use its parking lot since construction began at the school in 2012, but that parking spaces at the high school should be available again soon.
“Once the construction is completed, students who purchase parking passes will be able to park again in the school lot,” Ms. Bowman said. “The high school parking lot should be open for students during second semester of this school year.”
High school principal Brian McFeeley has sent numerous emails to students and parents asking them not to park on Main Entrance Drive, she said.
Some residents said they have had interruptions in garbage and leaf collection due to the congestion.
Commissioners said they believe the compromise was the fairest way to deal with the issue.
“There still will be residents who are inconvenienced,” Mr. Brumfield said.
On the vote to continue a deer sharpshooting program next year, commission president Kelly Fraasch was only one to vote against the decision.
As usual, the board heard from residents who opposed and favored the program, which is part of a multifaceted approach to deer management. It includes a controlled archery hunt, which is now underway and is slated to finish by Jan. 28.
The $83,477 sharpshooting contract will again be with wildlife management company White Buffalo and will include the culling of up to 100 deer.
Last year, the combined effort removed about 215 deer, but it may not be as successful this year, according to Tony DeNicola, founder and president of White Buffalo.
In a recent update to commissioners, Mr. DeNicola said that archers had harvested only about half of the 100 or so deer that they culled at the same time last year.
Ms. Fraasch said she believes the stated goal of reducing deer/vehicle collisions by half was no longer realistic, because accidents have inexplicably risen by more than 80 percent so far this year compared to last.
“The statistics suggest it’s not working,” Ms. Fraasch said. “It’s actually made it worse.”
“Growing up, we were referred to as ‘cake-eaters.’ Now, we’re just referred to as ‘stupid,’” said resident Bill Hoon, who said he resented spending tax dollars on a cull. “There are deer all around us.”
Mr. Brumfield said he, too, was uncomfortable with the cull but felt it was the only way to manage the issue.
“The Game Commission is giving us deaf ears, but I believe the deer pose a threat to our roads,” said Mr. Brumfield, who lamented the lack of nonlethal options, such as sterilization, which have been denied by the state Game Commission.
But resident Margaret Hooten said she believed the program was beneficial and should be given more of a chance to work.
“Archery and sharpshooting are essential components in keeping the deer population under control,” she said.
The sharpshooting program is expected to run from Feb. 1 to March 31, 2017. More details will be forthcoming on the municipal website: www.mtlebanon.org.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1159 or on Twitter @janicecrompton.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.