U.S. Rep. Tim Murphy attended an early screening of “Hacksaw Ridge,” the story of Pvt. Desmond Doss, the first conscientious objector to be awarded the Medal of Honor.
At about the same time, cheerleaders at Cornell High School made national headlines when they upset local veterans by kneeling on one knee instead of standing for the national anthem at a Sept. 30 home football game.
The two events got the Republican from Upper St. Clair thinking about how the movie could be used as an educational opportunity for those in his 18th District, which covers southern Allegheny County and parts of Greene, Washington and Westmoreland counties.
The World War II film was the “perfect catalyst” for starting a conversation on how to take a stand and live by your convictions, said Mr. Murphy, who serves as a commander in the Navy Reserves.
Arrangements were made for students, veterans and church leaders to view the film together and then discuss topics including courage, patriotism, conflict, beliefs and society’s treatment of those who take a stand on an issue.
“I want to have a conversation about what is courage and what is patriotism,” Mr. Murphy said. “How does a person with a point of view on something stand up and fight for what they believe in and still remain patriotic?”
Read More
“Without these conversations, you have students who are uninformed and veterans who are angry,” said Mr. Murphy, who is known by teachers in his 18th congressional district for his willingness to discuss political participation and policy issues in the classroom.
The viewings were held Nov. 2 and 3 at theaters in Bridgeville and Robinson. Each showing drew a crowd of about 175, including students from Bethel Park, Mt. Lebanon, Montour, Moon Area, Our Lady of the Sacred Heart, South Fayette, Upper St. Clair, West Allegheny high schools and Robert Morris University.
Scott DeVivo, a teacher at Our Lady of the Sacred Heart, encouraged students in his honors government/economics course, to attend. He said some of his students were at the football game where Cornell cheerleaders knelt to silently protest treatment of African-Americans, a move started by San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick.
Before the screenings, Mr. DeVivo and his students had discussed the First Amendment, which allows for peaceful protest. During the discussions, he said, he tried to get across why some people might consider certain peaceful protests actions to be disrespectful.
The movie proved to be a great addition to his lesson, he said.
The discussions after the Nov. 3 viewing were stilted at first. Then, students mostly asked questions of the veterans.
The veterans, who represented conflicts from World War II through the Iraq War, were asked what prompted them to enlist. Answers included Uncle Sam’s encouragement, adventure, honoring a parent’s former service and love of country.
When asked what goes through a person’s mind when entering into combat, a veteran said: “Survival. You want to live to see another day, but you want your brothers to see another day as well. You don’t care about politics, you don’t care about anything to do with that, you just care about getting to see another day.”
When Mr. Murphy asked for reactions to those who refuse to stand during the Pledge of Allegiance or the “The Star-Spangled Banner,” a Vietnam-era veteran responded, “I feel the same way when I see that as I did when I stepped off the plane in 1969 and got spit on at the airport. They’re spitting on my country.”
Others concurred, some by saying “amen.”
Rachel Muti, a senior at Moon Area High School, said many people have not been educated as to what these symbols truly signify. Elizabeth Cross, another Moon Area senior, said there is a time and a place for protest and during “The Star-Spangled Banner” is not one of those.
While students at the Robinson showing said they haven’t noticed students at their schools refusing to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance, Mr. Murphy said a student at the Bridgeville screening said the discussion with veterans helped him realize why it was disrespectful.
The discussion concluded with the audience standing to recite the Pledge of Allegiance and Mr. Murphy encouraging everyone to keep the conversation going on twitter @reptimmurphy using #whatisfaith and #whatiscourage.
Sonja Reis, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.