As a Wednesday budget vote nears for the Baldwin-Whitehall school board, a consultant’s report has raised concerns about how a proposed cut in the number of custodians would affect the the schools. The report also has called into question the district’s purchasing practices.

Consultant John Frombach said that reducing the custodial staff from 33 to 25 full-time equivalents, as proposed in the 2016-17 budget, would diminish the quality of cleaning services to a level “not normally acceptable in a school environment.”

Mr. Frombach also said the district could have saved roughly $170,000 through a cooperative purchasing network for the installation of new lights at the high school stadium this year. Instead, the board issued a standard request for proposal and awarded the contract to the lowest bidder, Allegheny City Electric, for $421,950.

The board hired Mr. Frombach, the district’s retired director of services, in February for $30,000 to evaluate district spending and recommend ways to save money.

Advertise with us

In outlining his recommendations June 8 to the school board, Mr. Frombach said that 10 years ago the district employed 47.5 full-time equivalent custodians to clean 75,000 fewer square feet of space than the district has today. To cut that number by nearly half would have a noticeable impact, he said.

“Classrooms would be cleaned every other day, carpets would be vacuumed every third day, and dusting would occur once a month,” according to his report.

Mr. Frombach’s findings were met with applause from many who attended the meeting, especially members of the Baldwin-Whitehall Service Employees Association, which includes school custodians.

The proposed $62.36 million budget also includes professional staff reductions totaling 13.6 full-time equivalents based largely on enrollment reductions and course changes. Some reductions would be achieved through attrition.

While no academic programs are eliminated, some will not be offered next year due to low enrollment.

Advertise with us

Other budget savings would be realized by realigning schedules for school nurses and district social workers; realigning responsibilities for district guidance counselors; and filling only one of two high school assistant principal positions left vacant by a recent retirement and a resignation.

The spending plan would raise taxes by 0.83 mills and generate an additional $1.5 million to help balance the budget.

Mr. Frombach’s report recommended the district participate in cooperative purchasing, in which districts use combined purchasing power to secure bulk discounts and realize other savings through decreased administrative and advertising expenses.

Mr. Frombach, who is president of Brentwood council, said that two years ago lights for the Brentwood football field were contracted directly to Musco Lighting through the Keystone Purchasing Network in a project similar to that of Baldwin-Whitehall. The total cost, including labor, was $229,000.

Board President Tracy Macek said at the board’s meeting Wednesday night that the board should have been presented with the option of purchasing networks.

Advertise with us

Superintendent Randal Lutz said those options will be presented in the future and noted that there were significant differences between the Baldwin and Brentwood light jobs, so the amount of savings cannot be known.

Other recommendations in the consultant’s report included: use both full-time and part-time employees to perform custodial work and provide an expanded training program for all custodial and maintenance staff; provide electronic devices to maintenance employees so they have immediate access to the work order system; review the landscaping operations to consider subcontracting to cut costs; reorganize the facilities department and hire a manager and assistant manager; enter into energy performance contracting; implement a four-day workweek during summer months; and plan ahead for capital expenditures.

Margaret Smykla, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.