A sharpshooting program designed to reduce Mt. Lebanon’s deer population ended Wednesday with an unofficial count of 115 animals culled. The program was held on public land and private property with the owners’ permission.
“We are considering it a success,” said municipal spokeswoman Susan Morgans. “It’s too early to assess what impact the program will have on the commission’s goal of reducing vehicle accidents, but this should go a long way toward the long-term maintenance goal.”
Commissioners want to drop deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent in five years. Police records show those incidents had increased from 42 in 2012 to 58 in 2014. The nuisance animal patrol picked up 71 whitetail road kills in 2011 and 106 in 2014.
A state Game Commission special permit authorized nonprofit wildlife management organization White Buffalo to continue the program through March, but warm weather and the early arrival of flora made deer less likely to be attracted to bait. White Buffalo president Anthony DeNicola said high temperatures also increased human traffic, reducing the program’s feasibility.
“Considering all the factors that we were confronted with in the field, we were pretty pleased with the outcome,” he said. Mt. Lebanon will be charged $74,375 for the service, he added.
The deer were taken by three shooters on elevated stands. Ms. Morgans said police received one complaint that a gunshot was heard, but it happened on a day when sharpshooters were not in the municipality. Mr. DeNicola said one person tried to frighten deer from a bait pile by repeatedly yelling “murderers.” More disturbing to him, he said, was what he called an attempt to incriminate White Buffalo.
“[Police Chief Aaron Lauth] got a call a few days ago from someone saying we were violating the 1,000-foot school radius at McNeely Park,” Mr. DeNicola said. “The bait was not ours — it was nowhere near where police knew we were stationed. Somebody put a pile of corn in a field and called in and said it was us. Unbelievable.”
A cull opponent said she’s still unconvinced.
“What the Mt. Lebanon government deems credible is usually rather far removed from the truth,” said resident Nita Fandray. “Shooting guns in a community with 5,500 people per square mile is a symptom of a broken local government.”
A 2015-16 controlled archery hunt, also conducted by White Buffalo, removed another 104 deer at an additional cost of $15,460. Municipal officials are expected to decide soon whether and how to proceed with deer control.
John Hayes: jhayes@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1991.
EDITOR’S NOTE: An earlier version of this story had an inaccurate amount that Mt. Lebanon would be billed for the sharpshooting deer removal program.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.