U.S. Attorney David Hickton said last summer that if his office could prove heroin dealers killed someone with their wares, federal prosecutors would bring a case and try to put dealers away for 20 years to life.
“This heroin crisis requires that response,” he said in announcing charges against five men in the overdose deaths of three people.
Now his office has added to that tally, charging three men with the deaths of two heroin users in Allegheny and Cambria counties last spring.
A grand jury has charged Andre Higgs, 32, of Pittsburgh; Romar Watts, 34, of Homestead; and Brian Borruto, 40, of Ebensberg, with selling fentanyl-laced heroin that killed people in March and April. The indictment, handed up under seal Tuesday and unsealed Thursday, also charges Mr. Higgs with trafficking in heroin on four occasions during 2015.
As is typical in such cases, the victims are identified only by their initials — “S.S.,” who died March 26 in Cambria County, and “R.S.,” who died April 3 in Allegheny County.
The U.S. Attorney’s office will not comment beyond the indictment.
The charge of delivering heroin resulting in death has been relatively rare in federal courts because the burden of proof is high, but prosecutors here and elsewhere have promised an aggressive approach.
The U.S. Attorney’s office brought three indictments in July against five men accused of selling heroin that killed three people. In one case, Richard Toland, Edward Skrine and Anthony McCullough, all in their 50s, are accused of selling the heroin that killed a 47-year-old man in an Oakland hotel room. Pittsburgh police said they established that the man received a brick of heroin from Mr. McCullough.
In a second case, prosecutors said Antonio Rutherford of Lawrenceville sold the heroin that killed a 26-year-old man Jan. 19, 2015.
In the third case, prosecutors charged Andrew Micheli, 22, of Bridgeville with selling the heroin that killed a 20-year-old woman Jan. 15, 2015.
In a more recent case, a Hill District man, Allen Coleman, was indicted this week on charges of heroin distribution, and federal agents are examining whether the brand of heroin he is accused of selling, called “Super,” caused the death of a 37-year-old man in Westmoreland County.
The federal penalty for dealing drugs that kill people is a mandatory minimum 20 years in prison up to life.
But the cases are hard to prove. Addicts take all kinds of drugs, and pinpointing the one that killed someone is a challenge. That challenge is even harder now because the U.S. Supreme Court in 2014 raised the bar.
Prosecutors used to have to prove only that the drug in question was a contributing factor for a dealer to get the mandatory minimum. But the Supreme Court ruled in a case from Iowa that a dealer can get that sentence only if prosecutors prove that the supplied drug was the one that killed the user.
That ruling had a direct impact on a major federal heroin case in a neighboring federal district, where the U.S. attorney in Wheeling, W.Va., charged Justin Withers with supplying heroin to a Waynesburg man who died of an overdose in 2011.
Because the man had also ingested oxycodone, prosecutors dropped their original indictment and allowed Withers to plead to aiding and abetting heroin distribution. He is serving 72 months in federal prison instead of the 20 years or more he could have received.
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1504.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.