Corry Sanders is banking on a pardon from Gov. Tom Wolf to clear the way for him to serve as a McKeesport councilman despite convictions for drug dealing from 23 years ago which the district attorney says bar him from taking office.
He'll have a long wait, though. The Board of Pardons has a three-year backlog, and Sanders' application has not even been processed yet. To put more of a damper on his chances for quick action, the board doesn't fast-track anyone.
Under the version of McKeesport's home rule charter on file with Allegheny County's Elections Division, a vacancy on council can occur through death, resignation, failure to take office within 30 days after the term begins, removal or "if the member lacks at any time during the term of office any qualification for the office prescribed by this Charter or by law."
With the District Attorney's office preparing to file an action called a quo warranto (Latin for "by what warrant or authority"), which challenges a person's right to hold office, it will be up to a judge to sort things out. And by that time, Sanders' seat might very well be vacant. If not, and a judge rules against him, it does not appear that he will get to hold the seat for the duration of the term -- despite the will of the electorate.
The home rule charter calls for remaining council members to fill a vacancy by appointment until the next municipal election, which would be November 2017.
At issue is specific language in the state constitution that deals with holders of elective office in Pennsylvania. Article II, Section 7 states: "No person hereafter convicted of embezzlement of public moneys, bribery, perjury or other infamous crime, shall be eligible to the General Assembly, or capable of holding any office of trust or profit in this Commonwealth."
Read More
Sanders won election in November, but was blocked Monday from taking his seat in council. Earlier that day, Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Joseph K. Williams III administered the oath of office after Sanders presented a certificate of election from the county's elections division. The judge would not speak with a reporter, according to his secretary, who refused to give her name.
Sanders pleaded no contest in 1993 to various drug crimes and criminal conspiracy. Court paperwork shows that police identified him as a cocaine dealer, having bought drugs from him on four occasions and at one point stopping a vehicle he was in and finding baggies of cocaine on him. Two of the counts were felonies, but none was embezzlement, bribery or perjury.
So does drug dealing count as an infamous crime?
Legal experts say if the convictions are for felonies, the answer is yes.
(And before we delve any further, it's worth pointing out that under the state's crimes code, "a conviction includes a plea of guilty, a plea of nolo contendere, a finding of guilty by a court or an unvacated forfeiture of bail or collateral deposited to secure a defendant's appearance in court." In other words, a conviction, even under a no contest plea, is still a conviction.)
"The Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled that anybody with a felony conviction is ineligible to hold office," said Chuck Pascal, a Leechburg attorney who practices election law. "That has been their interpretation of the provision that says 'infamous crime.' ”
He points to a "seminal" case from 1842, Commonwealth v. Shaver, which involved a sheriff bribing a voter. In the opinion, the court quoted Webster's dictionary. Infamy, the court wrote, was defined as "that loss of character, or public disgrace which a convict incurs, and by which he is rendered incapable of being a witness or juror."
The court continued: "The offences which disqualify a person to give evidence, when convicted of the same, are treason, felony, and every species of the crimen falsi [crimes involving falsehood or deceit], such as forgery, subornation of perjury, attaint of false verdict, and other offences of the like description, which involve the charge of falsehood, and affect the public administration of justice."
Fast forward 158 years to Commonwealth ex.rel. Baldwin v. Richard. The state Supreme Court wrote: "...we reaffirm that a crime is infamous for purposes of Article II, Section 7, if its underlying facts establish a felony, a crimen falsi offense, or a like offense involving the charge of falsehood that affects the public administration of justice."
"Basically," Mr. Pascal said, "the standard is any felony, or any crime of crimen falsi."
Philadelphia lawyer and election law expert Adam Bonin agrees.
He points to a more recent case from 2011, Commonwealth ex.rel. Kearney v Rambler.
In that case, the state Supreme Court wrote: "[U]nder the early common law certain crimes were called “infamous” on account of the shameful status which resulted to the person convicted of one of them. Crimes which were regarded as infamous were treason, felonies, any offense tending to pervert the administration of justice, and such crimes as came within the general scope of the term “crimen falsi” of the Roman law, such as perjury, subornation of perjury, barratry, conspiracy, swindling, cheating, and other crimes of a kindred nature."
Mr. Bonin broke down for the lay person what the court was saying this way: "You should take into account, basically, whether this is a crime that involves the person’s honestly, decency and good moral character,” Mr. Bonin said.
So does drug-dealing fit into that category, especially from more than two decades ago?
“That is, honestly, the kind of offense for which I think the courts have been more lenient," Mr. Bonin said. “The sorts of facts you’re discussing here, when they don’t involve dishonesty, a judge is going to decide if the better course of action is to allow to him to serve.” (As an aside, in 2010, The Associated Press took an exhaustive look at this issue here: http://www.post-gazette.com/news/state/2010/11/14/arrest-records-of-state-lawmakers-raise-questions-of-standards/201011140255).
Mr. Bonin is sympathetic to Sanders' situation.
“I think you could argue that especially earlier in one’s life, these sorts of choices don’t necessarily go to your fundamental character in terms of honesty. It's not a plot to steal money from people. It doesn’t go to the core of 'Can voters trust you?' in the same way. I think we all understand people make stupid decisions around drugs, and they can lead to other stupid decisions. But you can break out of that loop and that doesn’t define who you are,” Mr. Bonin said. “You're not talking about kingpins," he added. "You're not talking about Walter White from 'Breaking Bad' running a $100 million meth business.”
It should be pointed out that Mr. Bonin is working for the US Senate campaign of Braddock Mayor John Fetterman, who publicly proclaimed that he is on Sanders' side.
"The voters of McKeesport have democratically chosen [Corry] Sanders to serve as their representative, and we should not let a drug conviction from a quarter-century ago block the will of the people. I call on Governor Wolf to issue a pardon for Mr. Sanders to give the people of McKeesport the democratic representative they voted for," according to a statement from Mr. Fetterman. "Sadly, this incident represents so much about what is wrong with our broken system. A drug conviction should not banish one for life from fully participating in our democracy. But in this country, non-violent offenders are denied opportunities for the rest of their lives – whether it’s being shut out of jobs or deprived of their fundamental rights. We can’t be surprised that so many end up back on drugs and back in prison."
District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. feels for Sanders, too.
In a Sept. 2 letter he sent to Sanders alerting him to the pifalls of his candidacy, Mr. Zappala wrote, "Although I personally believe that the electorate should decide who they want to represent them, I regret that your record precludes you from seeking and/or holding public office."
Sanders' strategy going forward is murky. His attorney, Rachel Morocco, has not returned calls seeking comment.
Clifton Pitts, chairman of the Mon Valley People’s Action Committee, which he said represents 70 percent of the black elected officials in the Mon Valley, was in Sanders' barbershop, Kool Kutz, earlier this week offering support.
“It’s totally unfair," Mr. Pitts said. "He was elected by his peers; he should be able to be seated. Here is a young man who has completely turned his life around. He’s a businessman, he’s a community man.” The 45-year-old holds himself up as a rehabilitated ex-offender. He owns a barbershop in McKeesport and walked out of prison in 1998, never to return.
“A lot of people asked me to run. I have black and white supporters. I’ve always said I’d be that voice that speaks for the community. People are tired of things getting swept under the rug. They are sick of unjust, unfair laws,” Sanders said.
While Sanders is putting his past behind him, one element of his long-ago convictions dogs him: roughly $36,151.50 in court fines, fees and restitution that remain outstanding. According to county spokeswoman Amie Downs, Sanders paid a total of $998 on the two cases for which he was convicted. A collection agency took over, but Sanders filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy protection in 2011, "and so the account was pulled back as is provided in the bankruptcy proceedings. The larger balance was re-sent to a collection agency in November of 2014," Ms. Downs said.
Asked about the money owed, Sanders said, “I didn’t pay any of it because I didn’t have all that money for all that time” while in prison. "“I did all of that time. It was ridiculous, and then I get that fine?” It remains to be seen whether those outstanding court costs could derail his bid for a pardon.
Sanders questioned why he is being targeted.
“It was no problem until I won. All the crybabies knew about this. This is the only way they can beat me,” Sanders said.
One of his rivals, Dale McCall, whom he beat in the primary, is the person who raised the issue of his criminal history with the DA's office. But no one ever challenged the candidacy of another former McKeesport councilman, Daniel Carr, who lost in the May primary. Mr. Carr was sentenced in July 2014 (by Judge Williams, as it happens) to 18 months probation and ordered to pay a $300 fine for having illegal gaming machines in his bar, the Viking Lounge.
He pleaded guilty to two counts of gambling devices and one count of conspiracy -- all misdemeanors -- as part of a sweep by the state Attorney General's office called "Operation Pork Chop" that dismantled a purported million-dollar video gambling ring run by Ronald "Porky" Melocchi.
During his sentencing, Mr. Carr apologized to Judge Williams and said he'd never been in trouble before. He told the judge that the machines were only to help pay his overhead.
"From what I see here, you're a pillar of your community," Judge Williams said. But he continued, "You violated the law with respect to having these games in your establishment."
Mike Manko, a spokesman for the DA's office, said no one complained about Mr. Carr, a necessary trigger for the office to challenge his eligibility to hold office. And besides, Mr. Manko added, Mr. Carr's case did not meet the office standard.
"Carr does not qualify for review because his conviction does not involve felonies," Mr. Manko said.
In theory, problems could have been avoided early on if the question of Sanders' eligibility had come up before the primary. But Mark Wolosik, elections divisions manager, said his staff does not have fliers or pamphlets reminding candidates that they could run into problems if they have a criminal conviction. Similarly, he said, his people are not responsible for checking residency, age or any other requirements for someone to be an eligible candidate.
“Ultimately," Mr. Wolosik said, "the burden’s on the candidate to see if they’re qualified.”
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg. Janice Crompton contributed.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.