A Scott woman accused of stealing $46,000 from her 80-year-old mother by refinancing the elderly woman's house several times and then taking her money without paying her bills was held for trial following a preliminary hearing this morning.

Gloria Wertz, 42, is charged with theft by deception, access device fraud and receiving stolen property.

Despite the outcome of the hearing, testimony before District Judge Dennis Joyce became somewhat complicated for the prosecution when the frail victim, Martha Kimble of Ingram, said she could not recall information about various financial transactions alleged to have been made by her daughter without the victim's permission.

Ms. Kimble, who needed assistance standing and walking, did tell defense attorney Robert Stewart, however, that she recalled going to the bank with her daughter on one occasion to borrow money for Ms. Wertz.

Advertise with us

She agreed with Mr. Stewart that she and her daughter love each other and would help one another if possible.

Assistant District Attorney Jon Fodi put on two witnesses from his office's investigative unit who testified that Ms. Wertz used money from a joint bank account with her mother, a Sears credit card and from two mortgage refinancings for her own benefit.

But Mr. Stewart disagreed with the prosecution's basic premise.

"This really isn't a criminal matter. This may belong in Orphans' Court where a judge may decide an issue of competency," Mr. Stewart argued during his closing. "They may want to call it theft, but under the law she was entitled to this money. That's just the way it goes...Ms. Kimble doesn't recall most of this."

Both District Judge Dennis Joyce and Mr. Fodi acknowledged that the prosecution might have issues with the case at trial proving that Ms. Wertz stole the amount alleged in charging documents.

Advertise with us

Investigators with the Allegheny County district attorney's office said Ms. Wertz was helping care for her mother when her brother, who lives out of state, raised concerns.

The county's Department of Aging and the DA's office launched separate probes.

Investigators said they found that Ms. Kimble's home had been refinanced four times between August 2011 and November 2013, but the woman did not know why. She said she signed papers at Dollar Bank with her daughter even though she did not know what they were for because she was afraid, according to an affidavit.

The DA's investigation found checks written on Ms. Kimble's account to "cash" or to Ms. Wertz for more than $17,000; Detective Jackelyn Weibel also discovered that many monthly bills had gone unpaid.

Ms. Kimble told investigators that she wrote out her own bills with her daughter's help, and that Ms. Wertz would take them to be mailed.

Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com.