A Mt. Lebanon man whose second-degree murder conviction was overturned by a federal judge because his lawyer failed to properly represent him pleaded guilty Monday to third-degree murder.
Jared Henkel, 33, agreed to a deal with prosecutors to serve 10 to 20 years in prison.
“In my opinion, you’re getting a break you didn’t deserve,” said Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey A. Manning. “You deserve more than what this plea agreement says, and I am loath to accept it.”
But he did anyway.
In addition to the prison term — Henkel will get credit for more than 13 years he has already served — he also will spend an additional 10 years on probation. He’s eligible for consideration for release at the discretion of the state parole board.
Judge Manning called Henkel the “mastermind” of the death of Andre Jones.
Mr. Jones, 19, of Ridgemont, sold drugs. Henkel and co-defendants Jared Lischner and Craig Elias believed Mr. Jones stole drugs from their Mount Washington stash house. The men kidnapped him on March 22, 2002, then beat and tortured him before, prosecutors said, Elias killed him.
The men, who attended Mt. Lebanon High School together, then weighed down Mr. Jones’ body with chains and a barbell plate before dumping it in the Ohio River.
In April, Henkel filed a petition to have his case reviewed in U.S. District Court, alleging that his attorney, the late Thomas Ceraso, failed to properly prepare him to testify at trial.
Mr. Ceraso had agreed with Elias’ attorney, Duke George, that Elias would testify and say that Henkel and Lischner left the house where Jones was being held before he was killed. Henkel’s defense at trial was that when he left the house, he thought Mr. Jones would be released.
But Mr. George ended up not having Elias testify, which left Henkel without a defense. Henkel and Lischner were found guilty of second-degree murder, and Elias was found guilty of first-degree.
Lischner won a similar ineffective assistance of counsel appeal in 2012 and also pleaded guilty later to third-degree murder with a sentence of 10 to 20 years.
Elias has an appeal pending and is currently serving a life sentence.
Judge Manning told Henkel during Monday’s hearing that Mr. Ceraso “was never ineffective. He was one of the finest lawyers who ever existed.
“He never got to defend himself as a lawyer or his reputation,” Judge Manning said. “My guess is if we tried this case again, the likely result would be the same.”
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.