Jared Henkel, a convicted killer from Mt. Lebanon serving life in prison for a drug-related slaying in 2002, will get a new trial because his lawyer made a mistake, a federal magistrate ruled this week.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Robert Mitchell said Henkel’s lawyer, the late Thomas Ceraso, was ineffective in that he didn’t have Henkel testify on his own behalf or prepare him to testify at the trial in Allegheny County Common Pleas Court.
A jury convicted Henkel and Jared Lischner of second-degree murder in the killing of Andrew Jones, 19, a drug dealer from Ridgemont. Another man, Craig Elias, was convicted of first-degree murder.
Prosecutors said the three men, all Mt. Lebanon High School classmates, kidnapped and killed Jones and then dumped his body in the Ohio River after weighing it down with chains and a barbell plate.
All received life in prison.
Lischner had raised a similar complaint that his lawyer was ineffective and in 2012 won a new trial under the Post-Conviction Relief Act. He later pleaded guilty to third-degree murder and is serving a 10-to-20-year term.
Elias’ appeal is pending.
Prosecutors said the three men tortured and killed Jones because they believed he had broken into their stash house on Mount Washington and stole safes containing cocaine and cash.
Henkel had exhausted his state appeals, but in a habeas petition filed in U.S. District Court in April he argued that Mr. Ceraso and Duke George, the lawyer for Elias, had agreed that Elias would testify and say that Henkel and Lischner had left the house where Jones was being held before he was killed. Henkel’s defense was that when he left, he thought Jones would be let go.
But he said that during the trial, Mr. George told Mr. Ceraso that Elias would not take the stand after all.
That left Henkel without a defense, because he said Mr. Ceraso had not prepared him to testify on his own behalf.
“Mr. Ceraso made absolutely no pre-trial or trial preparation for Henkel to testify,” he said.
Henkel also accused Mr. Ceraso of refusing to let him testify, saying he “would not put him on the witness stand ‘cold,’ which he believed would only make matters worse.”
Judge Mitchell agreed Thursday that Mr. Ceraso was ineffective and ordered a new trial. The district attorney’s office declined to comment Friday.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.