The community deer-management meeting started civilly with an opening statement, insight from a panel of experts, and residents’ questions and comments before someone in the back stood up, shouted out of turn and tried to dominate the agenda.
This time it wasn’t in Mt. Lebanon. It was in Whitehall.
As the opening day of a controlled hunt approaches in Mt. Lebanon’s ongoing deer control drama, Whitehall, a borough in the South Hills, took its first step toward providing stewardship of its wild places last week. Mayor Jim Nowalk read the results of a recent community survey on deer density and speakers provided information on Lyme disease, conventional whitetail management, experimental non-lethal techniques and a Westmoreland County community’s successful do-it-yourself deer control efforts.
In Mt. Lebanon, however, they’re way beyond that. With the municipality unable for seven years to agree on routine wildlife management solutions, deer-vehicle collisions rose, according to police statistics; neighbors argued about lost rose bushes and animal rights; demonstrators dominated town hall meetings; and the community was left with a series of uncomfortable options.
In the spring, government dithering was largely blamed for the failure of a contractor’s unconventional trap-and-kill remedy. Saturday, another contractor will launch a $15,000 controlled archery hunt on private and public lands, welcome by many but opposed by residents who’ve posted their properties with signs saying, “Not in my yard.”
Beginning at dawn, several vetted archers — 11 in total, not all hunting at the same time — will be camouflaged and perched in tree stands on 18 “property groups,” or clusters of properties, mostly on private land.
Read More
At a public meeting Sept. 8, Jody Maddock of the nonprofit wildlife management group White Buffalo said some hunting would occur in some parks while they’re open but agreed to not position archers in the parks on Saturdays, at commissioners’ request. The hunt will continue through the end of Pennsylvania’s final 2015-16 archery deer season in mid-January.
The commissioners’ goal is to reduce deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent in five years.
White Buffalo president Tony DeNicola said later he has been pleased with community cooperation.
“The support from the residents of Mt. Lebanon has been overwhelming and we are pleased with all that project team has accomplished since July,” he said. “We have properties in place, more being volunteered each day, and the team is ready to start. We are working to tie up any loose ends before this weekend.”
Archers will be permitted to claim some venison, but Mr. Maddock said most would be donated to the Hunters Sharing the Harvest program, which processes the lean meat and donates it to local food pantries.
Despite the unprosecuted acts of trespass, sabotage, destruction of property and attempts to disrupt the spring cull by anti-hunt activists, Mr. DeNicola said he was not aware of any plans to interfere with the hunt. Game Commission spokesman Tom Fazi said no additional wildlife conservation officers would be on patrol in Allegheny County. Mt. Lebanon police had no plans to provide security for participating archers.
In Whitehall, Mayor Nowalk said he’s watching Mt. Lebanon and other municipalities to learn from their deer management successes and failures.
“We don’t have a big problem now, but people are starting to complain,” he said. “I don’t believe public officials should walk away from controversial issues. We should solve them.”
Early efforts to gather information and educate Whitehall residents have been mostly successful, with just a few missteps. In a community survey that drew a 4 percent response, 54 percent agreed that deer management was necessary, but some 37 percent of respondents said their preferred method was contraception, a process that requires biannual booster shots on wild, roaming animals. It is not used in any state in the nation and has never been approved by the state Game Commission.
“Since putting out the survey I’m learning,” Mr. Nowalk said. “I now know from talking with our speakers that some things are possible and some aren’t, but what I saw at the meeting was residents thinking about wildlife management, and I learned how serious they consider this problem.”
One of the Whitehall speakers described how she nipped her Westmoreland County community’s deer problem in the bud. Michele Clarke, retired director of the Murrysville Department of Parks and Recreation, significantly dropped the municipality’s deer-vehicle collisions and road kill rate by organizing a controlled archery hunt in Murrysville’s parks. In 2002, overbrowsing by deer was affecting the parks and moving into residential areas, and 194 deer road kills were cleaned up by a contractor.
“We wanted a program we could run ourselves,” she said. “We formed a committee, talked with local hunters and let them set it up. It’s much simpler to keep control if you control it yourself.”
In 2013-14, road kills in Murrysville dropped to 90. Cost to the community: zero.
John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.