If Mt. Lebanon deer management is a work in progress, Monday’s working meeting of the municipal commission made some progress in managing the growing problem.

No protests, no yelling, no vandalism -- the meeting at Mt. Lebanon High School Fine Arts Auditorium was a refreshing change from the spring drama, when contradictory views on a failed measure to reduce deer density split the community.

The meeting was not billed as a decision-making event, and no decisions were made. About 50 residents showed up as commissioners met again with deer experts to further discuss the current state of Mt. Lebanon deer, deer management options, the permit application process for each and organization of a managed archery hunt as mandated by the state when the community applied for the spring cull.

"We learned a lot through the process, and from the several meetings held by [deer-proof gardening expert] Sandy Baker," said commission president John Bendel. "Tonight we'll continue that discussion, and we've assembled a terrific panel of experts to help us.

Advertise with us

Confirmed deer-vehicle collisions are up. In 2011, there were just 23 in Mt. Lebanon.

"That number increased to 42 in 2012, 44 in 2013 and 58 in 2014," said municipal manager Keith McGill.

Commissioner Kelly Fraasch questioned whether those numbers were normal for communities, and what percentage of total collisions those numbers represented.

Mr. McGill said he didn't have the answers, but that the important thing to note was the upward trend in Mt. Lebanon deer-vehicle collisions.

"The stated goal of the commission is to reduce deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent, so if there were 58 last year we'd want it to go down to 29,“ he said. ”The commission stopped a successful deer-reduction program [in 2008] with the U.S. Agriculture Department's Wildlife Services, but since then has taken multiple steps to reduce density including plantings and landscaping, signage, public education and a feeding ban.“

Advertise with us

Mr. McGill said the municipality is updating its zoning plan to permit high fencing to prevent deer access.

Since 1998, he said, the nearby community of Upper St. Clair has used several deer management tactics, and deer-vehicle collisions in 2014 were fewer than 90. Peters Township and Fox Chapel, he said, also keep deer accidents down through management programs.

That’s no easy feat in Pennsylvania, the No. 1 state in the United States for deer-vehicle collisions, said Jeannine Fleegle, a deer biologist for the state Game Commission. Mt. Lebanon commissioners had plenty of questions for her, and Ms. Fleegle was polite but firm in her responses.

”You had some success, but you stopped [managing deer] and the problem reared its ugly head again,“ she said. ”You need to have a plan. I can’t stress that enough. This is where many communities fail.“

The goal for Mt. Lebanon, she said, should be to develop the right plan for this community. One of the problems, she said, is trying to get a count of deer before initiating a plan.

Advertise with us

”If you try to determine a number before you have a plan it will not work because your plan will be influenced by the number of deer you think you have, and the hard count won’t be reliable,“ she said. ”The first thing you have to define as a community is whether there is a problem. If you don’t determine that, you’re just going to keep finding yourself here.“

Jody Maddock, founder of the Whitetail Associates vetted archery group of eastern Pennsylvania, explained that property owners are protected from hunting liability by 1965 state legislation that was recently updated. Archers in the deer management program follow rules that exceed Game Commission regulations, the program seeks the consent of landowners, has a perfect safety record and costs the taxpayers nothing.

Anthony DeNicola of Connecticut-based White Buffalo, explained what he said was a costly and labor-intensive procedure for conducting deer ovarictomies, but which can be successful in stabilizing the population. Mr. DeNicola explained that the process does not immediately lower the number of deer, and would work best in conjunction with other deer reduction measures.

John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.