In Mt. Lebanon, the cull is on.

The state Game Commission has authorized the municipality’s controversial plan to hire a Tioga County wildlife consultant to corral and shoot white-tailed deer in six public parks.

In a message posted Tuesday on Mt. Lebanon’s official website, municipal manager Stephen Feller said the program would begin immediately and continue through March 31.

“Although this deer management strategy is very safe, the contractor will post signs at the entrances to the parks indicating that deer management is taking place,” he wrote. “Parents and teachers may want to ask children to avoid these parks for the duration, as the traps will be clearly visible.”

Advertise with us

Commissioner Kelly Fraasch, who has opposed lethal means of deer reduction, said the deer density problem needs to be addressed. But with some 33,000 residents in Mt. Lebanon’s 6 square miles, she hoped her fellow commissioners would have chosen another plan.

“I find we’re a municipality that is highly dense. It’s hard to add any lethal methods here without some element of risk,” she said. “I want to see other methods that are less risky done first. I don’t think this particular plan is the best.”

During months of public meetings, Mt. Lebanon commissioners said the deer presented a nuisance as well as a public safety hazard. From 2011 through January 2015, 807 deer-related incidents were reported to local police, and in 2014, 83 incidents were reported to Mt. Lebanon police involving injured deer on roads or deer-vehicle collisions.

With public comment from both sides of the issue, commissioners debated the merits of various plans to quickly reduce deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent. In January, they voted 3-1 — Ms. Fraasch opposing, council president John Bendel absent — to hire Wildlife Specialists LLC of Wellsboro to cull the deer, paying $500 per deer with the amount not to exceed $75,000.

As approved by the Game Commission, the plan calls for baited enclosure traps to be set in McNeilly, Bird, Robb Hollow and Twin Hills parks, Mt. Lebanon Golf Course and the Connor Road conservation district. When a group of deer enters the enclosure, the door will close and trained shooters will climb onto elevated platforms and kill the deer using small-caliber rifles at close range.

Advertise with us

Starting next week, bait will be placed at the sites to condition deer to frequent those sites. After a week, trapping and culling will begin. The culls will occur mostly at night with noise-suppression devices used to reduce the sound. The venison will be donated to regional food banks. The goal is to remove 150 deer per year from the municipality.

Deer control has divided the Mt. Lebanon community for years. A deer reduction program that combined trap-and-kill and U.S. Department of Agriculture sharpshooters was credited with removing 230 deer in two years. In 2008 in Mt. Lebanon, 13 deer were killed in the traps, 133 were culled by sharpshooters. The program was discontinued six years ago.

Since then, with no predators of mature deer and little public archery hunting, the deer population has grown. Two aerial surveys counted 340 and 190 deer. Commissioners passed a ban on feeding deer that has proven difficult to enforce. In October, 2014, council allocated $68,000 for deer management. A closed archery hunt was cancelled in December when antlerless deer hunting permits became unavailable.

Last week, scores of protesters rallied at a commission meeting carrying petitions signed by 3,200 Mt. Lebanon residents opposed to the cull and 1,400 supporting it.

Game Commission deer and elk specialists recommended approval of the Mt. Lebanon plan, and the agency’s special permits division authorized it Feb. 13. Biologist Chris Rosenberry, supervisor of the deer team, said Title 34 of the Pennsylvania Code requires that public hunting must be attempted, if possible, as a wildlife control method before other plans can be approved. A few archers hunt discretely in Mt. Lebanon with little effect on the population.

Advertise with us

“The main difference between this plan and what Mt. Lebanon did before is that in the past they were also doing sharpshooting at the same time,” Mr. Rosenberry said. “Now it’s just trap-and-euthanize.”

Nonlethal methods have been suggested for Mt. Lebanon’s problem, but Mr. Rosenberry said there is no practical alternative to killing the deer.

“Hysterectomies have been suggested, and some forms of birth control,” he said. “If you could catch every female and sterilize them, you’d stop population growth but it would take many years for enough deer to die off for the population to drop. The community is telling us that the problem is too many deer now. In some way, some of the animals have to come out of the population.”