After three years of debate, the Upper St. Clair school board Monday voted to spend as much as $60 million on major upgrades to its middle schools and for other capital improvements.

During several hours of discussion at a committee meeting, which was interrupted for a brief voting meeting, most board members said they were concerned that delaying much-needed improvements to the Boyce and Fort Couch middle schools would be unwise.

The board was persuaded to take action when it learned a two-year postponement could cost the district an additional $5.4 million in increased construction costs and fees, and when bids for the projects came in 17 percent to 25 percent less than estimated.

With the economic downturn and uncertain timetable for recovery, other school districts and municipalities have also realized much lower construction costs this year, including Peters and Bethel Park.

Advertise with us

Frosina Cordisco, district director of business and finance, told board members bid prices were "abnormally low," and encouraged them to act before prices climb again.

Financial advisers also said borrowing conditions were favorable now, and that the district could possibly see interest rates as low as 4 percent if it acted soon.

If the district borrows $60 million, it would cost the owner of a $200,000 home about $344 more per year in taxes, Ms. Cordisco said.

The increase would be phased in over four years.

Dr. William Sulkowski voted against the projects, cautioning that prices might go even lower in the coming years, thanks in part to a collapsing commercial real estate bubble.

Advertise with us

He said he was also concerned about the tax impact to residents, who already have seen hikes in local taxes and a real estate millage increase recently approved by the school board.

"I don't know why we have to rush into this," he said.

Board member Harry Kunselman also urged caution, saying it is still unclear what the financial impact will be in three years, when contributions to the state Public School Employees' Retirement System are expected to triple for school districts statewide.

But, board members said they were concerned about deficiencies in the aging buildings, including roof problems, undersized classrooms and a serious lack of technology infrastructure in the Fort Couch school, which was built in 1951.

The board voted 7-1 to approve $20.2 in spending for the Boyce Middle School, which houses the district's fifth and sixth grades. Because bid prices were so low, $2.2 million in alternatives also were selected, including new parking and a $1.3 million theater.

Advertise with us

Improvements to the 40-year-old school will include five new classrooms, expansions of the kitchen, cafeteria and gymnasium, and increased parking.

The board voted 6-2 in favor of spending $22.2 million on the Fort Couch Middle School, which includes seventh and eighth grades.

About 35 percent of that school will be renovated with a new academic wing and gymnasium, along with increased parking.

Electrical, ventilation and plumbing systems at both schools also will be replaced, and new bus/parent drop-off areas will be designed.

Board members Amy Billerbeck, Barbara Bolas, Angela Petersen, Louis Piconi, Frank Kerber and Rebecca Stern voted in favor of the improvements for both schools. Mr. Kunselman voted for improvements to Boyce Middle School only and member Carol Coliane was absent.

Advertise with us

The lower construction costs also brought up discussion about other projects, such as $3.6 million for high school stadium improvements, new technology spending, and possibly installing artificial turf at one or both of the middle schools.

Two community members, including Upper St. Clair Athletic Association President Tom Burke, spoke in favor of turfing at least one field.

As such, the board approved a proposal to seek bids for up to $60 million in bonds, with Mr. Kunselman and Dr. Sulkowksi again dissenting. Mr. Kerber, who had been participating by phone, was accidentally disconnected and unable to vote on the proposal.

The board is expected to take up discussion Monday over whether to spend additional funds for more improvements.

Also up for debate will be whether to begin accepting tuition students from outside the district. Superintendent Dr. Patrick O'Toole said there is constant interest in the district's International Baccalaureate programs.

The board also voted to move a scheduled board meeting from Aug. 24 to Aug. 25 so a bid contract could be signed.