Politics is more than personal in the city's South Hills -- It is about blood. It has been for years in the 19th Ward, and it continues this spring in the battle between the families and allies of two former friends who no longer speak, Councilman Jim Motznik and former state Rep. Michael Diven.
On its face the May 19 primary battle is just over the district judge seat serving Beechview, Brookline, Duquesne Heights and Mount Washington. In reality it goes much deeper, with ties to old Democratic Party political feuds going back three decades, over soil long populated by city employees whose grocery-bill worries have a direct connection to the shenanigans on Grant Street.
Mr. Motznik, like Mr. Diven, was born and raised in Brookline, and recently moved back to the hilltop street where he grew up, three doors down from his parents. He gave a car tour of the modest, ranch-style houses dotting the street last week. "Cop. My house. Detective. Firefighter," he said, pointing at his neighbors' homes from his black sedan. "Cop. Cop. Cop."
Mr. Motznik, 45, began working as a city public works laborer at age 19. The next year he ran for a Democratic committee spot in the 19th Ward, then chaired by Frank Gigliotti, a fellow Brookline public works employee and ally of then Mayor Richard S. Caliguiri. (The ward chairmanship would be wrested away in 1986 by his rival, Beechview's Pete Wagner, who still has the position.)
Mr. Motznik's clan -- many of whom, including his mother, he rallied to take other 19th Ward party positions under Gigliotti -- would break with the future state representative, who was indicted for extortion in 1999.
"I don't play that crap. I know there's tree-huggers who think I'm a no-good [jerk] -- you know what they say, the East Enders, who say Motznik's smoking cigars in the back room -- but you know that's not true," he said. "I'm not going to be around people like that."
So in 1996 he supported a failed attempt to take Mr. Gigliotti's House seat by another young Brookline guy, Michael Diven.
Political allies
Michael Diven's father was the legendary Joey Diven, a friend of boxer Billy Conn's and known as the "world's toughest street fighter." He had worked for powerful Allegheny County Commissioner Tom Foerster, and Michael would go to work for Mr. Foerster, too, after losing a 1993 City Council race to Joe Cusick as a Duquesne University senior.
Mr. Cusick was arrested for fighting with police and entered alcohol rehabilitation three times while in office, a record that helped Michael Diven defeat him in 1997. He then made Mr. Motznik his council chief of staff. Three years later he moved onto the state House after Mr. Gigliotti's guilty plea and he supported Mr. Motznik for his former council seat over his own cousin, Amy Barrett-Montgomery. Mr. Diven would employ Mr. Motznik's mother for six years in his Brookline legislative office.
In Harrisburg, Mr. Diven quickly chafed at the strong-arm tactics of House Democratic leaders Bill DeWeese and Mike Veon -- terming them "cowards" and calling them out in an e-mail that said in part, "I'm 6' 5," 280 lbs. And a former Golden Gloves fighter, so don't let your mouth write checks your body can't cash." He voted against Gov. Ed Rendell's inaugural budget.
Mr. DeWeese has since been demoted in leadership and Mr. Veon has been twice indicted. But the Democratic leaders still ruled in 2004 and narrowly failed in an attempt to oust Mr. Diven from office. The following year he switched his registration to Republican to run for the state Senate seat vacated by Jack Wagner, Pete's younger brother. He lost that race and then his House seat to Democrat Chelsa Wagner, Pete's daughter, in 2006.
"I lost my job as a legislator over principle. Since losing my job I think it's become very apparent to everybody else how corrupt and vindictive they were," Mr. Diven, 39, said last week.
He and his older brother Joe Jr. were moving furniture into the mostly empty office on Brookline Boulevard, just two doors down from the former Garrubba Bros. Meat Market, owned by Mr. Motznik's mother's family.
"What's the consolation now? I'm right? I lost my job," Mr. Diven said. "I didn't get a job with the state, I didn't get a cushion to land on. I've had a number of conversations with my wife over paying bills because of the principles I stood up for."
Mr. Motznik, he continued, "can say whatever he wants. I think if you look at my history I've demonstrated I'll stand up to do what I think is right. People who get involved [with party squabbles] are people like Jimmy who go along to get along, to save their own (behind)."
Two versions of the story
In 2005, the same year Mr. Diven switched parties, his former aide stood by him, supporting his friend's Republican run. Mr. Motznik was facing his first full re-election campaign, and his backing of Mr. Diven brought the full weight of the Democratic politics-mad 19th Ward down on him. He barely won and it scared him. He said he went to Mr. Diven and asked him to switch back to the Democratic side before his House seat was up the next year.
Mr. Motznik said his son, Jack, bounced on Mr. Diven's couch as he asked his former boss to return to the Democratic fold and save both of their political futures.
"I tried to explain to him: Here's my son who's 41/2. We're normal people, elected officials -- this is what we do for a living. And I explained that to him. 'I can't go down with you. I'm going to support whoever the Democrat is.' He didn't understand that, and we haven't spoken since."
Hearing that story, Mr. Diven raised his right hand, saying he would swear an oath that the conversation never happened. Mr. Motznik never told him he was switching allegiances to Chelsa Wagner, he said, and his mother kept working for him through his failed November 2006 election -- she even came to an election eve spaghetti dinner the Diven campaign routinely hosted.
"Forty people walked in with this letter her son had sent for my opponent," Mr. Diven said. "And his mom was crying, sitting in the back kitchen. And I was consoling her, saying don't worry about it. And here is the kind of guy who didn't even have the courtesy to say, 'Hey mom, you might want to stay away.' "
Mr. Motznik denies that story, noting his family routinely cooked for those dinners. (Ms. Wagner, who is supporting Mr. Motznik in this race, last week said he publicly endorsed her by early 2006.) "You think I'd surprise my mother like that?" he said.
The old machine
It wasn't always this way in the 19th Ward, really.
From 1950 onward, it was run by one man -- Beechview's Al Conway, a top lieutenant to mayor and governor David L. Lawrence. His influence only started to wane in the late '70s when Mr. Gigliotti, aided by Mayor Caliguiri, attempted to take the ward over. Only Beechview's Pete Wagner -- then chair of the first county home rule study commission -- stood in the way, starting a feud between the Gigliotti and Wagner forces in the 19th Ward that would go on for nearly two decades.
The pair regularly tangled over the ward chairmanship through the 1980s and then competed twice for the 22nd District state House seat in 1988 and 1990. Pete's brother Jack, an at-large City Councilman since 1983, had to beat back a Gigliotti-tied challenger in his first District 4 race in 1989. When Jack Wagner ran for mayor four years later, Tom Murphy used the help of Mr. Gigliotti to beat him.
This year, Mr. Diven is still tangling with the Wagner clan and Mr. Motznik is working with them.
But the first time the old fights really hit the scene was 1979. That year Pete Wagner ran for district justice and beat Al Conway's son Bill, a city police officer. Up for re-election in the 1985 primary, he would lose by only 90 votes to Brookline insurance agent Charlie McLaughlin, who had the support of Mr. Gigliotti and then-state Rep. Mike Dawida of Carrick.
In true 19th Ward style, Mr. McLaughlin is retiring after 24 years from the same seat that the Motznik and Diven families are now fighting for in this year's Democratic primary. (Mr. Diven has re-registered as a Democrat.)
The pair already has been publicly feuding over forged signatures inked on a petition a Diven aide left unattended at a Mount Washington bar. (In 2006, two Diven aides were caught up in another petition forgery probe.) Also in conflict is each man's role in supporting the failed Beechview redevelopment plans by Bernardo Katz, currently the subject of a federal probe and living in Brazil.
Both of the men say they have the government and community experience necessary to referee the housing, truancy and neighborhood issues that commonly go before the district bench. (Neither is an attorney, but that is not required.) Mr. Diven said he is running partially due to his late cousin Danny, a magistrate in Sheraden.
"His philosophy was you have more impact on lives of the people you care about by being in that position. It's the first step in the court system but probably the most important. You need someone willing to listen and act as a problem-solver," he said.
Mr. Motznik -- who comes into the race with a massive lead in fundraising and endorsements, including that of the Democratic committee, said virtually the same thing. As district judge, "I can have a more direct impact on the neighborhood I grew up in than on council," he said. "You can make a bigger difference in that position."
The one-time aide still has the wooden "Diven For Council" bench he painted green and stenciled more than a decade ago sitting in his City-County Building office. "I'm still proud of it," he said. So why still the 19th Ward fratricide? The kind of mass patronage and influence peddling that fueled ward politics decades ago -- and in Mr. Gigliotti's case, led to jail -- is now just a old memory.
"The answer is easy," Mr. Motznik said. "We have to fight harder than anyone because we don't get recognized from the area of the city between the rivers. We're just the crazies up in the South Hills, which isn't the case. That's why people get involved. We have to band together."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.