Barack Obama won a historic election Tuesday to become the next president of these United States and he did it with the help of at least two voters from the South Hills.
Donn Nemchick and Roy Hanbury, two of the four voters we had profiled in a four-part series about undecided voters here, said they voted for the Illinois senator after months of reading the headlines, watching television -- and soul searching.
Mr. Obama has the "youth and exuberance" for this task, Mr. Nemchick said.
Our panelists
Meet the four voters who voiced their concerns about the election (2.1 MB PDF)
Mr. Hanbury said he ultimately chose Mr. Obama because "it takes a certain person to be a leader."
Another panelist, Erika Tatrai, a Pitt student casting her first-ever vote for president, said she voted for Republican John McCain.
And, panelist Sue Klose decided to keep her vote between her and her Maker -- as, of course, is every American's right. But she said she voted for one of the two major party candidates. There were, after all, four people on Pennsylvania's presidential ballot Tuesday: Bob Barr on the Libertarian ticket and Ralph Nader as an Independent.
But, in interviews with freelance writer Erin Gibson Allen, the other panel members eagerly shared their choices and talked about what was, for them, the defining "ah-ha" moment.
Interestingly, the historic aspect of this election, regardless of who won, did not seem to factor in our panelists' choices. Mr. Obama was on track to become the first black president, and Republican vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin could have become the first woman vice president.
Voters here and everywhere had a lot of time to study the issues in this seemingly endless campaign. Mr. Obama officially kicked off his run more than 20 months ago; John McCain has been running off and on for president for the past eight years.
We asked our voters -- all of whom made their pick at the 11th hour-- whether headlines in the week impacted their choice. And, we were curious to know whether they watched last week's highly touted and expensive 30-minute Obama infomercial, and if they stayed up into the wee hours to watch the returns late Tuesday and early yesterday.
We also asked panelists which candidate they thought had viable proposals about energy independence. And, because immigration has been an important issue, we asked voters if that topic was part of their calculation.
All voters said in previous weeks that foreign affairs were important. So, this week we asked which candidate they thought had the best ideas on the issue of homeland security.
We also asked if they felt their vote mattered and how the winner should reach out to all Americans.
Finally, we asked a lofty question: What are your hopes for America's future?
Today, Mr. Obama has to start working on his.
Donn Nemchick
Age: 57
Hometown: Munhall
Job: Business consultant
Mr. Nemchick made his decision, he said, based on a sense that Mr. Obama "continues to keep an eye on his bearings" and is "cool and focused."
Also, Mr. Obama is more likely to help the working class of Western Pennsylvania, Mr. Nemchick said.
Still, he said, neither candidate was particularly better suited to handle issues of national security, energy independence or immigration.
Homeland security and energy independence are complex issues that require a president to surround himself with a strong knowledgeable team of advisers, he said.
America should seek "the best and the brightest" from other countries to come here, he said.
Mr. Nemchick did not watch the vaunted Obama infomercial a few days before the election, he said, but he did stay up into the wee hours of yesterday morning to watch returns and he "enjoyed the spectacle."
Despite Mr. Obama's lopsided win, Mr. Nemchick said "all votes matter."'
Mr. Nemchick said he hopes our new president gets to work immediately to "bind this nation together again."
"We're America -- we shouldn't be so divided," he said of the current political climate.
He said he hoped America can return to a position of strength in the world and resume the international leadership role that "we lost that with the last administration."
Mr. Nemchick said he feared Mr. McCain would continue to alienate other countries.
He said he was encouraged by seeing younger people energized and by the high voter turnout.
Erika Tatrai
Age: 19
Hometown: West Homestead
Job: Student at Pitt
The first time was not the charm for Ms. Tatrai. After analyzing each candidates' policies, she said she made her decision in her first presidential vote because more of Mr. McCain's views aligned with her own.
Issues that did not enter into her calculation, she said, were immigration, energy independence and national security.
"Both candidates have the country's best interest at heart," she said about national security.
Also, on issues affecting Western Pennsylvania, Ms. Tatrai said that she looks to the governor, not the president, to have an impact. "The president is concerned more with national issues," she said.
She did not watch the Obama infomercial, she said, and felt his last-minute appeal to voters was "unfair" and that he should have instead used the debates to communicate with voters.
However, she said, she did enjoy watching "Saturday Night Live" skits with the candidates, such as the episode last week in which John and Cindy McCain pretended to be on the shopping network, QVC.
While she believes her vote matters, she said, she is concerned because some of her peers are not registered to vote.
"Many kids my age don't take voting seriously," she said.
Ms. Tatrai said she was glued to the television set into the early hours of yesterday watching returns.
The new president must immediately reach out to voters who supported the losing candidate and "try to reassure them he'll do a good job," she said.
"I hope the new president can accomplish [his] goals in Iraq and get the soldiers home," she said. "And I hope the economy turns around."
Sue Klose
Age: 58
Hometown: South Fayette
Job: Mortgage originator
Ms. Klose said that in the end she wanted to keep her vote private.
But she said her vote was cast based on "a feeling" and on "what she values," she said. She did not focus on the candidates' pasts, she said, but looked at the issues and what is important to her and those around her.
Still, she said she favored Mr. McCain on energy independence, saying that Mr. Obama's ideas are "insufficient."
Both men are equally qualified to protect national security, she said, and success in this area will depend on the people the candidate "surrounds himself with."
She said she respected Mr. McCain's efforts toward immigration reform, although she conceded that the candidates' positions are similar on the issue.
And, she said she believes Mr. McCain would better address local needs because he supports clean coal technology, which is important to the area.
"Obama did not talk about these things," she said.
America needs to become energy-efficient, she said, and the economy needs to turn around.
Unlike her fellow panelists in this popular South series -- both CNN and MSNBC tried to interview our panelists -- Ms. Klose "went to bed at a reasonable hour" Tuesday night.
Now, she said, Mr. Obama should reach out to everyone.
"Democrats and Republicans have to come together," she said, "although I'm not sure how that can be accomplished.
"I support the winner now," she said.
Roy Hanbury
Age: 61
Hometown: Mount Oliver
Job: Maintenance worker
In the end, Mr. Hanbury cast his vote for Mr. Obama, saying, "you should vote so you have something to believe in."
He stayed up until 1 a.m. yesterday morning watching the returns but missed last week's Obama infomercial.
Campaign ads and results aside, Mr. Hanbury fears that neither man nor party can further America's energy independence.
"People need to stop using so much [energy]," he said. "We abuse our natural resources more than any other country in the world."
Immigration was not among the issues Mr. Hanbury considered in voting, he said.
If Mr. Obama brings the troops home from Iraq, Mr. Hanbury said, some of those men and women may be more available to protect the country in the event of a natural disaster or other crisis.
He said he is suspicious that gas prices have been falsely inflated, and he hopes that Mr. Obama can help keep gas and utility costs in check, which would help the working people of Western Pennsylvania.
"The winning candidate needs to say, 'I hope you put your trust in me and I'm going to run the country in the best way for everyone,' " Mr. Hanbury said.
He hopes the economy turns around and that other nations regain their trust in the United States.
Also, he hopes American children can have more "carefree days" playing outside like he did when he was young.
"Things seemed so much easier then," he said.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.