Elizabeth Borough Council President Monica Douglas said she is running against state Rep. David Levdansky, D-Forward, in the state's 39th House district because she didn't want to see him go unopposed in his bid for a 13th term.
But Mr. Levdansky, 54, said the real reason is that she was asked to do so by a state arm of the National Rifle Association known as the Firearm Owners Against Crime, which has sponsored campaign activities for Ms. Douglas.
Ms. Douglas, 37, a Republican, acknowledges that the NRA is providing support for her campaign, but denies that it prompted her to run.
"That is absolutely not true. I did not have any contact with any representative of the NRA until after the primary," said Ms. Douglas, who won the Republican nomination with a write-in campaign after another GOP candidate was knocked off of the ballot by petition challenge.
Mr. Levdansky said the gun rights organizations are opposing his re-election because he sponsored "lost and stolen" legislation earlier this year that would have required gun owners who discover their firearms are missing to report the loss or theft within 72 hours.
The measure had support among lawmakers in larger urban areas but not in the more rural districts where many constituents are hunters and sportsmen. It failed 128-75 in early April.
Mr. Levdansky said he believed the legislation was necessary because too often criminals get others to purchase guns for them and when the firearms are used in a crime, the real owners claim the guns were lost or stolen.
But Ms. Douglas said she believes the legislation was "unworkable" and "puts the burden on the individual and turns the victim into the criminal."
The gun legislation is not the only disagreement between Ms. Douglas and Mr. Levdansky, nor is this the first time the two have faced off. Ms. Douglas challenged Mr. Levdansky unsuccessfully in 2002.
In the intervening years, she was elected to Elizabeth Borough council. She said when she first ran against Mr. Levdansky six years ago, she was "young and naive and politically green." Her years on council, she said, have taught her about state government and how it interacts with local government.
She said Mr. Levdansky refers to himself as a reformer, but in her opinion he has not done enough.
Mr. Levdansky counters that he needs to have enough votes among his colleagues to make changes.
Mr. Levdansky cites his efforts toward calling for a constitutional convention in order to reduce the size of the Legislature and his tax reform proposal to reduce property taxes by 50 percent and replace the revenue by increasing sales and income taxes.
Ms. Douglas said she supports reducing the size of the state Legislature and liked a bill that was introduced by state Rep. Mark Mustio, R-Moon, last year that called for reducing the number of state representatives from 203 to 161 and senators from 50 to 40.
Mr. Levdansky said he wants to reduce the size of the Legislature through a state constitutional convention, which would require not only the state House and Senate to approve a bill in two different sessions, but would call for a vote from the public as well. That way, other constitutional issues could be discussed, too, he said.
Neither proposal has had enough support to prompt a vote.
Mr. Levdansky, who calls himself "the chief statewide advocate" of tax reform, said his tax proposal is stalled in the House Appropriations Committee. He vowed to introduce it again next year if he is re-elected.
Ms. Douglas said she liked a bill sponsored by state Rep. Sam Rohrer, R-Berks, that called for eliminating school property taxes by expanding the state sales tax to include previously exempt services and increasing the personal income tax rate.
On health care, Ms. Douglas said she believes members of the Legislature should pay for part of their health care.
Mr. Levdansky said he agreed, and that the issue would have to be addressed at the beginning of the new session through a change in House rules.
Ms. Douglas said as she campaigns door-to-door, residents of her district tell her they are tired of the same old politics in Harrisburg.
"I keep telling them 'If we keep electing the same leaders over and over again, you won't get different results,' " Ms. Douglas said.
But Mr. Levdansky said some experience in the Legislature is necessary.
"These young legislators need experienced legislators to help them put this [reform] into action. Experience does matter," said Mr. Levdansky, who is chair of the House Finance Committee and a member of the Games & Fisheries and Environmental Resources & Energy committees.
The 39th district is made up of Clairton, Forward, South Park, Elizabeth Borough, Jefferson Hills, West Elizabeth and part of Elizabeth Township in Allegheny County, plus Nottingham, Union, Finleyville, New Eagle and part of Carroll in Washington County.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.