Here's a closer look at some of the more interesting races in Tuesday's election '07.

The always-interesting races for South school boards provided some of the biggest surprises. In Baldwin-Whitehall, a well known incumbent of more than two decades lost. Two incumbent directors also lost in Mt. Lebanon as did the president of the McKeesport school board in a contentious race there that involved a lawsuit.

In Upper St. Clair, a last minute write-in campaign livened the waning days of the campaign. Still, the efforts of three write-in candidates who failed to win general election slots in the primary were futile. They lost again.

Remember that these election results remain unofficial until certified by the state.

Advertise with us

This report was compiled by staff writers Mary Niederberger and Maria Sciullo. Freelance writers Jim McMahon and Brittany McCandless also contributed.

Baldwin-Whitehall

Incumbent and current board President Kevin Fischer was the top vote getter in Tuesday's election, in which seven candidates were vying for five seats on the nine-member board.

"I am humbled and proud of the support demonstrated by the electorate, and I look forward to working with the new members to continue our efforts to move our district in the right direction," Mr. Fischer said.

Four other Democrats were elected to four-year terms as directors of a district that just ratified a new teachers' agreement and is in the middle of a major high school renovation project.

Advertise with us

Two former school board members, Martin Michael Schmotzer and E. John Egger, were elected, as were newcomers Diana Kazour and Kevin A. Stiffey.

Longtime Republican incumbent Jane Hunnewell, known for her outspoken comments and staunch support of fundamental educational programs, lost in her bid for re-election. Ms. Hunnewell, 70, served on the board for more than 20 years.

Three present board members, John Palmiere, who has served for 23 years, and Richard Caponi and Dana Etzel-Hardman, each of whom served one four-year term, decided not to seek re-election.

"It will be an interesting combination of people and personalities," said Mr. Fischer, of the newly elected members, who expressed optimism that all shared the common goals of serving the educational needs of the children, while providing fiscal accountability to the district's taxpayers.

McKeesport

Advertise with us

Voters Tuesday showed what they thought of a recent lawsuit intended to block city employees from running for office.

In the contentious school board election, the electorate ousted incumbent President Ocie Paige and elected all four candidates who were targeted by the suit to fill four of the five empty seats. Democrat Joe Chiaverini captured the fifth seat.

Jim Brown, Steven Kondrosky, Joe Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski, all city employees, won over Republicans Jerome Halaszynski and Mr. Paige.

"It speaks volumes about what the public thinks of the lawsuit," said McKeesport Mayor Jim Brewster.

Earlier this year, school board member Dave Donato sued Mr. Brewster over city employees running for office. Charging that the mayor was trying to take control of the school district by having city employees run, Mr. Donato invoked a provision of McKeesport's Home Rule Charter that prohibits city employees from soliciting or receiving campaign funds for public office.

Advertise with us

Mr. Kondrosky, who is an administrator for the City of McKeesport, was the only city employee not named in the suit.

Late last month, Judge Eugene F. Scanlon Jr. dismissed the lawsuit, saying nothing in the McKeesport Home Rule Charter specifically prohibits city employees from running for elected office.

Calling the lawsuit a crime and a waste of taxpayer money, Mr. Brewster said Tuesday night that the court rectified the problem by giving the public the ability to decide.

"It isn't the mayor saying they could run. It's the voting public," the mayor said. "Once the judge said the names stayed on the ballot, the people could have opted not to vote at all. They could have voted for the other two people that were on the ballot. The democratic process worked."

The provision Mr. Donato cited also grants the mayor the right to either fire employees who are running for office or force them to give up campaigning. Mr. Brewster assured the candidates he would support them and never make them choose between their jobs and elected office.

Advertise with us

Both Mr. Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski are employed by McKeesport's Police Department. Mr. Brown is the Parks and Recreation director.

This election marks Mr. Brown's third attempt at running for school board while being employed as recreation director.

In the 1980s, Mr. Donato also served as recreation director for the city while sitting on the school board, and in the years since, the debate over city employees running for office has continued. Most recently, current board member Mark Holtzman is the deputy chief of police.

Mr. Donato's lawsuit wasn't the only issue surrounding the school board elections. This spring, both he and current board member Lori Spando sought to run for re-election before their present terms expires.

The Commonwealth Court upheld an order by the county Common Pleas Court to have their names removed from the election ballot because each member is only halfway through a four-year term.

Advertise with us

Mr. Donato has previously acknowledged his suit against the mayor had elements of retaliation because of his and Ms. Spando's names being removed from the ballot.

Mr. Chiaverini, a restaurant owner, felt that while the lawsuit treated the city employees unfairly, all the candidates ran a clean campaign. He said that the school board will unite to vote for "the best results for the city."

Mt. Lebanon

There will be four new faces on the school board when it reorganizes in December, and two familiar faces will be gone.

Longtime School Director Carol Walton lost her bid for a sixth term on the board, and Rene Garson, who was vying for a second term, also came up a loser in the race.

Advertise with us

The defeat of Mrs. Walton, 64, a community volunteer, was surprising since she had won on both the Democratic and Republican tickets in the primary. Mrs. Garson, 49, an office manager, had won only a Democratic nomination in the primary.

The top vote-getter in the race was newcomer Elaine Cappucci, 46, an environmental scientist who has three children in the Mt. Lebanon schools. According to unofficial returns from the county elections department, Mrs. Cappucci has a 1,234 lead over incumbent Sue Rose, who came in second in the race.

The other winners -- all first time school directors -- are Faith Ann Stipanovich, 47, a payroll manager for the Allegheny County Controller's office; Edward Kubit, 47, a district manager for Cadre Computer Resources; and James Fraasch, 34, a network architect for PNC Bank.

Ms. Stipanovich said she believes the vote totals show that Mt. Lebanon residents wanted change on the school board.

"There's going to be a lot of new faces on the board and I hope we can work together and make some good decision," Ms. Stipanovich said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Fraasch, who ran on a ticket with Mr. Kubit, said he believes voters agreed with their campaign stance of being conservative with the upcoming high school improvement project.

Steel Valley

There will be two incumbents and three new members on the Steel Valley school board.

Board President Beth Cannon and Vice President Kimberly Kubancsek, both won re-election.

Also winning seats were Vincent Natale, who garnered the most votes in the race, Thomas Olson, and former school director Rose Marie Bartko.

Advertise with us

Losing her bid for a seat on the board was Paula Borsch.

Upper St. Clair

In the township, it was hardly business as usual on Election Day. As Patricia Donlon stood outside a back entrance to Fort Couch Middle School, the weather served as a metaphor.

"Hello, I'm the one that's running the write-in campaign," she said, handing out leaflets and bracing against a harsh wind sprayed with occasional snow flurries.

It was tough going, all day.

Advertise with us

By 10:30 that night, Mrs. Donlon and two other write-in candidates, Ernie Harris and Bob Walker, appeared to have lost in their bid to become USC school board directors. Although the Allegheny County election totals show 4,723 votes cast for write-in (20.3 percent), individual write-in totals might not be confirmed for days, possibly weeks.

"I'm sure some people split their votes, but generally speaking, it's between their team and our team," said Mrs. Donlon, who noted, "I do believe the other side won."

Winning five seats and representing a majority when the new board is seated Dec. 3 are incumbents Angela Petersen and Barbara Bolas, plus Amy L. Billerback, Louis Piconi and Rebecca Stern.

The five ran on a "Restore USC" platform, which promised to restore "leadership, integrity, dignity, sense and civility" after several years of much-publicized disagreements.

"I've met so many incredible people who are smart and engaged," said Mrs. Stern, 49, who was running for public office for the first time. "I'm very proud of who supports us, what we represent."

Advertise with us

Also making a first run at public office was Mr. Piconi, who yesterday said the victory "hasn't sunk it yet.

"We have to be looking at the future, how we evolve as a district, what our kids need and can gain," Mr. Piconi said.

"At the same time, we must keep the costs down."

Jim Whalen, co-manager of the Restore USC campaign and a former USC school board director, said Tuesday was "an emotional roller coaster."

"All you need is for one person to walk by and make some nasty comment to get you down, and then you get five people who wink at you and you're all the way back up again," he said.

Advertise with us

Many voters appeared confident in their choices before entering the polling sites. One Restore USC advocate offered a woman some printed material at Baker Elementary, adding, "I hope you'll consider our candidates."

"Absolutely not!" she answered.

Tensions escalated in the early afternoon, when an election official at the Westminster Presbyterian Church site was reported offering advice to voters on how to cast write-in ballots.

Mr. Whalen filed a petition in the Court of Common Pleas seeking to halt the practice. Judge Guido A. DeAngelis, who was serving in elections court that day, issued an order forbidding such interaction with voters at the Westminster site.

By 3 p.m., upon hearing of other, similar reports, he expanded the order to cover the remaining 17 sites.

Advertise with us

West Mifflin

The four incumbents in the race for school board said during the campaign they believed they had done a good job and deserved another term.

The voters apparently agreed with them. Unofficial election returns show that seats were won by incumbents Kathleen Bracco, 49, a pharmaceutical representative; Richard Fialkovich, 73, a retired West Mifflin police detective; Pat Natale, 78, a retiree from Mesta Machine Co.; and Ned Mervos, 76, a retired teacher, administrator and coach in the West Mifflin Area district.

They will be joined on the board by Albert Graham, 44, a chiropractor with a practice in Pleasant Hills. It will be Mr. Graham's first term on the board.

Theodore Cale, 47, a police and fire dispatcher for West Miffin Borough, came close to unseating Mr. Mervos. Unofficial election returns show just a 30-vote difference between the candidates.

Advertise with us

"I was just thankful that it worked out that way so [the incumbents] can continue with our educational program here," Mr. Mervos said.

The other unsuccessful candidates in the race were Daniel Davis, 47, a senior project manager for Robert Kimball Associates, and Brett VanDyke, a photographer.

District officials are expected today to file a private criminal charge against Mr. Cale for what they say was the illegal entry of a school bus on Friday.

Philip Martell, West Mifflin Area's assistant business manager, said on Monday that he confronted Mr. Cale on Friday after he stepped onto a school bus at New Emerson Elementary to deliver campaign material to the bus driver.

Mr. Cale said he had the permission of the driver to enter the bus.

Mr. Martell said he planned to meet with a representative of the district attorney's office today at the office of District Justice Richard D. Olasz Jr.