Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Eugene F. Scanlon Jr. has ruled there is nothing in the McKeesport Home Rule Charter that specifically prohibits city employees from running for elected office. Consequently, he dismissed a lawsuit that would have forced city employees to choose between their jobs and political aspirations.
The finding is a timely one for the seven candidates who are vying for five open seats on the McKeesport Area school board this November.
Four of the candidates -- Jim Brown, Steven Kondroski, Joseph Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski -- work for the city.
McKeesport school board member Dave Donato filed a complaint before the spring primary election against McKeesport Mayor Jim Brewster to compel the mayor to enforce a provision of the charter which Mr. Donato claimed prohibited city employees from holding any elected positions.
The provision of the charter in question currently reads: "No person who holds any compensated appointive City position shall make, solicit, or receive any contribution to the campaign funds of any political party or any candidate for public office or take any part in the management affairs or political campaigns of any political party, but he may exercise his rights as a citizen to express his opinions and to cast his vote."
Mr. Donato has charged that the mayor is trying to take control of the school district by having city employees run for that office, a claim Mr. Brewster has repeatedly denied as being absurd.
The mayor has said that prior to the candidates filing, he had advance knowledge that only one city employee, Mr. Brown, the Parks and Recreation director, was planning to run. Defending against the lawsuit has amounted to a waste of taxpayer money, Mr. Brewster has said.
Mr. Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski are employed by McKeesport's Police department. Mr. Kondrosky is an administrator for the city.
Whether city employees are permitted to run for office under the charter has been a matter of debate for years in McKeesport. Several city employees have held elected office through the years, including current members Mark Holtzman, who is deputy chief of police, and Mr. Donato.
In the 1980s, Mr. Donato was on the school board while serving as recreation director for the city. Though he acknowledges he was essentially acting as a representative of then-mayor Lou Washowich while on the board, Mr. Donato said the practice in that instance was excusable because "at the time, it wasn't a board takeover."
Mr. Donato said he isn't sure if he will appeal the court's decision.
He said he may contact the Allegheny County District Attorney's office to discuss the possibility of having criminal charges filed against the city-employed candidates.
McKeesport City Council in September approved a request to the Allegheny Department of Elections to place a referendum on the ballot next year that would alter the charter. Though the language has not been finalized, council is looking to clarify the provision to specifically allow employees to run for most elected offices in the city, except for mayor, city council, controller and district judge.
The four candidates who work for McKeesport all won the Democratic nomination in May, along with local restaurant owner Joseph Chiaverini.
Candidate Ocie Paige, who was appointed to the board two years ago and is current board president, and Jerome Halaszynski are running on the Republican ticket, as are cross-registered candidates Christopher Halaszynski, Mr. Kondrosky and Mr. Lopretto.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.