Parents in Duquesne were already upset not knowing where their children will be assigned this fall when their high school closes, and a meeting last night with the state secretary of education did nothing to calm their frustration.

Meanwhile, West Mifflin residents at a town hall meeting a few miles away made it clear they don't want Duquesne students in their high school and they resent efforts by the state to make that happen.

"We feel strongly that Duquesne should have their own district," said John Donis, West Mifflin school board president.

While education Secretary Gerald Zahorchak refused to name any school district where more than 200 high school students from Duquesne will be sent this fall, the West Mifflin Area School District is an obvious choice because it borders on Duquesne.

Advertise with us

Mr. Donis said Dr. Zahorchak met with the West Mifflin Area school board last month about the idea. Board members voted against the proposal, saying they already have crowded classrooms, low test scores and the district would be worse off with an influx of Duquesne students.

But Duquesne parents are equally opposed to their children being forced to attend a school district where they are clearly unwanted.

"West Mifflin says they don't want our kids and I don't want my son to go there either," said Malik Washington, whose 17-year-old son, Malik Washington Jr., will be a senior this year.

A year ago, the same hard feelings on both sides rose to the surface when the state was considering disbanding Duquesne as a district. Instead, the state hired Pittsburgh Public Schools to provide academic and financial management expertise to Duquesne for this school year.

Parents in Duquesne spent nearly three hours last night meeting with Dr. Zahorchak begging for answers and, at times, screaming at him as loud as they would cheer at any sporting event.

Advertise with us

"It's just a waste of time to come here," said Jody Harris, a Duquesne parent. "They're just saying the same thing over and over and they don't have a plan. They won't tell us what school our kids are going to."

Although the news media was not permitted inside the Duquesne High School auditorium where Dr. Zahorchak met with parents, he made a statement as he left the building.

"We've had great conversations," he said. "There's a lot of anxiety and passion. We're planning transitions, big time. So, everyone has mentoring and ombudsmen. The big thing we want is hope and opportunity."

Dr. Zahorchak urged the state board of control overseeing the district to vote last week to close the high school because he felt the students would be better served in other districts that offer a selection of advanced courses and extracurricular activities.

Mr. Donis said he didn't want his comments or those of the residents to be construed as "bashing Duquesne." He said he believes the solution to the problem is to allow Duquesne to keep its high school.

Advertise with us

His comments were echoed by about a dozen residents who signed up to speak at the meeting. Many referred to overcrowding in the West Mifflin schools and some asked why Dr. Zahorchak didn't meet with the West Mifflin residents as he has met with Duquesne residents in recent weeks.

"What are the positives for our students in this merger?" asked Lynn Flore, whose comment was met with loud applause from the crowd of more than 150 people.

Lance Maha, a high school teacher in West Mifflin, talked about the "elephant in the room" -- a concern that if the Duquesne high school students are taken in by West Mifflin, the K-8 students will be next.

The only one to speak in favor of West Mifflin accepting Duquesne students was Hattie Thoms. She told the board it was unreasonable to think that Duquesne could support its own school system when it has "no tax base" while West Mifflin benefits from taxes from Century III Mall and other businesses.

"Try to run your household without money and see where you get," she said. "If Duquesne cannot afford to educate their children we should not turn our back on them."

Advertise with us

West Mifflin resident Mary Heards said West Mifflin's reluctance to take the Duquesne students was not a racial issue. Ms. Heards, who is black, said part of the reticence is about "gangs and rivalries."

Fred Barker, a West Mifflin resident who has attended Duquesne board of control meetings, noted that he had to pass through a metal detector to enter the Duquesne auditorium. He questioned if accepting the Duquesne students would mean that West Mifflin would have to purchase metal detectors for the school.

Mark Purcell, chief of staff for state Rep. Bill Kortz, D-West Mifflin, said Mr. Kortz offered an alternative solution that calls for keeping Duquesne High School open for another year, installing new leadership there and allowing a charter school to set up for the fall of 2008 to accept the students. The West Mifflin crowd applauded that proposal and many of the speakers said they supported it.