WAYNESBURG, Pa. -- When is a Fox not a Fox?

That's the question being raised in a challenge to the results on the Republican ballot in Greene County's race for district attorney.

At issue are two items of contention, but both center on who is properly named Fox and whether voters knowingly voted for the right person.

A hearing on the challenge to the May 15 primary election results was supposed to occur yesterday but was rescheduled until tomorrow after Common Pleas Judge William R. Nalitz recused himself in the case because he had certified the challenged election results May 25 as a member of the board of elections.

Advertise with us

Instead, President Judge H. Terry Grimes tomorrow will hear testimony in the case.

Marjorie J. Fox is the name by which the county's current district attorney has been known for her professional career as a prosecutor, which began in 1989 when she was hired by her Democratic primary challenger, David F. Pollock. Ms. Fox was appointed as the county's district attorney in 2001 and was elected to her first term two years later. She's running for re-election.

But Mr. Pollock contends Ms. Fox was not a legitimate candidate because she is registered to vote as a Democrat under her married name, Marjorie J. Niedbala, and she failed to file an affidavit that stated she was known by another name as a candidate. In essence, Mr. Pollock is arguing that a candidate named Marjorie J. Fox could not exist because there is no registered voter by that name.

In Waynesburg's small legal community, it's no coincidence that the case between Mr. Pollock and Ms. Fox involves lawyers who have been the county's district attorneys for most of the past 27 years. Mr. Pollock's attorney in the case, Charles Morris, was the prosecutor for eight years before he took over in 1988. Mr. Pollock served for 12 years and was followed by Glenn Toothman, whose resignation in 2001 led to Ms. Fox's appointment.

The court case has strained the relationship between Ms. Fox and Mr. Pollock, which Mr. Pollock said has not "been that great for a while." But Ms. Fox is optimistic the dustup won't last long.

Advertise with us

"It's a very small legal community and nobody can stay angry for very long," she said.

Mr. Pollock said he is not entirely sure the legal strategy of Ms. Fox's professional and married names will work because he did not file a challenge to Ms. Fox's nominating petition about the name issue. That's why he is also challenging the primary results on another front.

Ms. Fox and Mr. Pollock are both registered Democrats. Ms. Fox beat Mr. Pollock in the May 15 Democratic primary by 355 votes, 3,524 to 3,169. But at issue are the 877 Republican write-in votes that Ms. Fox won by six votes, according to the results that were certified two weeks ago.

Scattered among the 877 Republican write-in votes are just over 80 votes in which voters wrote in the last names of the candidates, either Fox or Pollock or close variations on the spellings. Mr. Pollock's middle name is Fox, from his mother's maiden name, and he contends the Fox votes could have been meant for him, though it's not commonly known that Fox is his middle name.

"I don't go around telling people that I'm David Fox Pollock," he said.

Advertise with us

As part of his challenge, Mr. Pollock wants to have either the Fox or Pollock surname write-in votes or both tossed out.

If that occurred, he would secure the Republican nomination because it would eliminate the six-vote margin for Ms. Fox.

In a county in which Democrats outnumber Republican registered voters by a nearly 3-1 margin, running as a Republican could be an uphill battle. But Mr. Pollock said he believes voters will vote for him on the Republican ticket because he received 47 percent of the Democratic vote.

"I think there are a lot of people who vote for the individual and not the party," he said.