One of the most watched and, perhaps, most passionate local elections in the South Hills on Tuesday was the race for school board in Upper St. Clair. Voters there went to the polls not only to vote their choice for school board members, but, perhaps, also to give voice to a political philosophy.
The hot button in the USC contest was the much debated International Baccalaureate program there, a high school educational program with a global perspective, which has been the centerpiece of a contentious past several years in the district.
The new complexion of the board, all but determined Tuesday, seems to solidify the program.
But this new board, as others across the school-rich, parent-wise and tax burdened South Hills, will determine a lot more than the future of just one program.
Should there be more, or remodeled school buildings? Does a district's overall curriculum prepare children for the future and reflect the community's standards? How much is too much, or not enough sports? Are our children safe in school?
And the pesky bottom line: Can property owners afford to pay for it all?
A look at who won the voters' confidence in USC and other South school board races follows.
Upper St Clair
The race for school board in Upper St. Clair is essentially over as the five-person slate of "Restore USC" won all five seats on both the Republican and Democratic side.
The move signals a shift in political power on the board, which will likely now move from a current conservative majority to a new majority that supports the contested International Baccalaureate program.
Incumbents Barbara Bolas and Angela Petersen, and contenders Rebecca Stern, Amy L. Billerbeck and Louis Piconi won by huge margins on the Democratic side with more than 1,000 votes each and 10 percent of the vote separating the two tickets.
Challengers Trish Donlon, Bob Walker and Ernie Harris fared better on the Republican race, but did not garner enough votes to secure any nominations, with 166 votes and almost a percentage point separating the tickets.
Baldwin-Whitehall
In a crowded field in Baldwin-Whitehall, 10 candidates battled for five seats, with as little as one vote making the difference.
In November, seven candidates will vie for the five seats.
On the Democratic side, incumbent Kevin J. Fischer came in first, with 1,886 votes, followed by Martin Michael Schmotzer with 1,725, E. John Egger with 1,679, Diana Kazour with 1,662 and Kevin A. Stiffey with 1,624.
Mr. Stiffey beat the next candidate in line, Greg A. Zeman, by only one vote in unofficial totals.
On the Republican side, incumbent Kevin J. Fischer came in first, with 812 votes, followed by incumbent Jane W. Hunnewell, with 731 votes, and contenders Martin Michael Schmotzer with 723 votes, Greg A. Zeman with 698 votes and Kevin A. Stiffey with 688 votes.
Chartiers Valley
Incumbent first-term school director Anthony Moses, one of 10 candidates seeking five nominations, finished last on both party ballots. He one of five board members who voted April 24 to open the job of varsity basketball coach Tim McConnell, prompting an uproar among parents.
He was the only board member two weeks later not to rescind his vote and the only incumbent not to win nomination.
Incumbents Patti Frey and Patti Figorski and newcomers Herb Ohlinger and Pam Poletti won nominations on both ballots. Incumbent Mary Lou Petronsky who won a Democratic nomination, and John Vaccarello, the GOP winner, will battle for the fifth spot in November.
Keystone Oaks
In Keystone Oaks Region 3, which represents Green Tree, three candidates squared off for two spots on each ticket. The decision wasn't unanimous but only two votes separated the nominees in one of the races.
All three candidates will move on to the general election in November, to fight for the two available seats in the region.
On the Democratic side, the incumbents prevailed, with Evelyn Weaver capturing 38.05 percent of the vote and Dennis J. Fuga earning 33.22 percent, to challenger Gary R. Alward's 28.62 percent.
But in the Republican race, Mr. Fuga was locked out, with Mrs. Weaver earning 41.35 percent of the vote, followed by Mr. Alward's 29.26 percent. Mr. Fuga trailed, with 28.98 percent -- a difference of only two votes.
West Jefferson Hills
Several incumbents likely will be returned to office after the fall election, with all but one getting nominations on both parties.
Six candidates will battle for five seats in the fall.
On the Democratic side, incumbents Marianne Neel, David L. Graham and Shauna D'Alessandro won, in addition to contender Dennis Cmar and Anthony Angotti, all with double-digit percentages and more than 1,000 votes each.
On the Republican side, incumbents Marianne Neel, David L. Graham and Shauna D'Alessandro won, in addition to contenders Anthony Angotti and Alan J. Caponi, all with double-digit percentages.
Incumbent Craig I. McVicker did not get a nomination on either ballot.
Elizabeth Forward
In the Elizabeth Forward School District, the race for five seats on the school board was decided in Tuesday's primary with five candidates each winning on both the Democratic and Republican tickets.
Among the winners was Charles Bakewell, the only incumbent candidate in the race. Mr. Bakewell, who is the board vice president, was appointed to the board in September to replace Richard Zaccone, who resigned. Mr. Bakewell was a previous longtime school director who served from 1974 to 1991 and served four terms as president.
Four other school directors whose terms were up chose not to run for re-election.
The winners for those seats were: Megan Ferraro, Margaret Ann Morgan, Stanley Douglas and Michael T. O'Rourke. Mr. O'Rourke previously served as school director from 1999 to 2003.
McKeesport
A bitter race for five seats on the McKeesport Area school board will continue into the fall. Joseph Chiaverini, Joe Lopretto, Christopher Halaszynski, James Brown and Steven Kondrosky won the Democratic nomination.
Candidate Ocie Paige, who was appointed to the board two years ago and is current board president, and Jerome Halaszynski did not succeed on the Democratic side, but both won Republican nominations, along with Christopher Halaszynski, Mr. Kondrosky and Mr. Lopretto.
The race was the source of three separate legal actions related to the eligibility of candidates to run for the office.
Two claims brought by Mr. Brown and Mr. Chiaverini resulted in the names of seated board members Dave Donato and Lori Spando being removed from the ballot. The pair had sought to run out of turn before their current terms expired but were prohibited from doing so by recent amendments to the Pennsylvania Election Code.
In the third, an ongoing lawsuit, Mr. Donato sued Mc-Keesport Mayor Jim Brewster over the eligibility of four of the winning candidates to serve as school directors.
The candidates -- Mr. Lopretto, Mr. Kondrosky, Mr. Brown and Christopher Halaszynski -- are employed by the city. A provision of McKeesport's Home Rule Charter prohibits city employees from soliciting or receiving campaign funds for public office.
Jim Brown, who is recreation director for the city, said being involved in the lawsuits made for a tough campaign but probably helped him gain support among McKeesport voters.
"I'm going to wait for the outcome [of the case]," he said.
Mr. Lopretto and Christopher Halaszynski are employed by McKeesport's police department. Mr. Kondrosky is an administrator for the city. Mr. Chiaverini owns a restaurant.
Mt. Lebanon
The three incumbents in the race will appear on the November ballot as will four newcomers seeking five open seats on the school board.
According to unofficial returns, incumbent Sue Rose and newcomer Elaine Cappucci were the top vote getters in the election, with Mrs. Rose first on the Republican ticket and second on the Democratic slate and Mrs. Cappucci first with the Democrats and second with the Republicans.
Mrs. Cappucci received the highest percentage of votes of all of the candidates in receiving 1,877 votes -- or about 18 percent -- on the Democratic slate.
Also winning on both tickets was incumbent and longtime school director Carol Walton.
Winning Republican nominations were running mates James Fraasch and Ed Kubit. Winning Democratic nominations were incumbent Rene Garson and challenger Faith Ann Stipanovich.
Candidates LaVerne Conley and Zachary Benkovitz, who ran only as Democrats, failed to garner a nomination.
Mr. Fraasch and Mr. Kubit said they will work harder in the general election to get their message out to Democratic voters. Both men said they were not surprised that the primary was producing seven candidates for the general election.
"I think a lot of that has to do with the issues in the district and people's opinions. The primary issue is the new high school, and there is still a lot of debate within the community," Mr. Kubit said.
The incumbents said they were happy to see there was no obvious anti-incumbent sentiment as there had been in the past election. "Evidently people didn't have a huge problem with us," Mrs. Walton said.
Peters Township
In the race for five open seats on the school board, challenges from two write-in candidates have made some of the elections too close to call, but other results are available.
Each of the six candidates on the ballot cross-filed for the four-year seats; slots for the Democratic and Republican nominations will go to incumbent school directors Sandra Gregg, who garnered the most votes from both parties Tuesday, and Thomas McMurray.
Also assured a spot on November's ballot will be Julie Ann Sullivan and Lynn Erenberg for the Democratic nomination. Less clear is the status of incumbent director Mark Buzzatto, who could slip behind write-in candidates Cindy Golembiewski or Frank Lacey.
The Washington County Elections office began counting write-in ballots yesterday.
Steel Valley
In the Steel Valley School District, three incumbents lost their bids for re-election and two received nominations from both parties.
Winning on both tickets were board President Beth Cannon and Vice President Kimberly Kubancsek. Losing the race were incumbents Colleen Fedor, Martha Sloan and Brian Heddleston.
Mrs. Fedor believes the tough stance she and Mrs. Sloan took on some significant financial issues in the district not only cost them their board seats, but put them in last place on both the Democratic and Republican slates.
Both women had favored the district's attempts to investigate cost savings by contracting out cafeteria and custodial jobs, and both women, members of the board's finance committee, recently outlined significant cuts that could be made to the district to dig it out of the $800,000 hole that was recently identified in the 2007-2008 budget.
"I knew going into contract negotiations [with cafeteria and custodial workers] that it would have a negative impact," Mrs. Fedor said. "Nobody wants to lay off employees or change compensation packages. But it is the job of the school board to make prudent decisions."
In early vote returns, it appeared that Mr. Heddleston was headed for a victory on both tickets, but in the final unofficial returns, he was nudged out on both slates by Rose Marie Bartko.
Mrs. Bartko previously served eight years on the school board before losing re-election two years ago. With 1,094 votes on the Democratic ticket, she beat Mr. Heddleston by 24 votes. It was closer on the Republican ticket where unofficial returns show her total of 155 votes was just 12 more than Mr. Heddleston's.
Challenger Vince Natale's strategy of running only on the Democratic ticket seemed to pay off as he led the slate with 1,324 votes, according to unofficial returns. The next closest on the Democratic ticket was Thomas Olson with 1,234 votes. Mr. Olson also garnered a Republican nomination, leading that slate with 226 votes or about 16 percent of the votes.
In addition, challenger Paula Borsch won a Republican nomination.
West Mifflin
Voters will see four incumbents and four newcomers on the November ballot for the five open school board seats.
Incumbent Raymond Butko failed to garner a nomination from either party, according to unofficial results from the county elections department.
Incumbent Kathleen Bracco won both Democratic and Republican nominations and was the top vote getter on each slate. Also winning nods from both parties was challenger Albert Graham, who appeared to have the third highest vote totals on each slate. On the Republican ballot, Mr. Graham with 240 votes was just four votes behind Ms. Bracco, according to unofficial returns.
Also winning Democratic nominations were incumbents Richard Fialkovich, Pat J. Natale and Ned Mervos.
The others who won Republican nominations were challengers Daniel J. Davis, Theodore Cale and Brett A. Vandyke.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.