For the first time in more than two decades, the race for district judge for South Park, Pleasant Hills and Jefferson Hills is wide open. Seven candidates are competing.
Longtime District Judge Mary Grace Boyle held the office for 25 years before retiring in March 2006 as she was under investigation by the state Judicial Conduct Board for using her office and staff for election purposes. The office has been staffed by retired judges since her retirement.
Those vying for the seat, which has a six-year term and a salary of $76,058, include lawyers James E. Miscavage 52, of Pleasant Hills; D. Scott Lautner, 36, of Jefferson Hills; and Pat A. Capolupo, 63, of Jefferson Hills.
Also in race are Mary Larcinese, 54, a former Jefferson Hills mayor and a field representative for the state House of Representatives; Nicholas J. Rudolph. 28 of South Park, executive director of the Physican Medicine Assist program; Gim Yee, 56, of South Park, a sheriff's deputy; and Edward Snee, 55, a recently retired South Park police officer.
The lawyers all said they believed it was important for a district judge to have a law degree in order to interpret the complexities of the law. They said they were familiar with the procedures of district courts because their practices involve criminal and other types of cases that frequently bring them before the local district judges..
Mr. Lautner ran against Mrs. Boyle in 2005 and is running for the same reason this time: "To restore honor and integrity to the office."
Mr. Lautner, who has operated a private law practice in Pleasant Hills for the past 10 years, said Mrs. Boyle's retirement appeared to "confirm the allegations of impropriety" against her.
He said the current problem in the office was that, for the past 18 months, the communities have had no local representation as the office has been filled by retired judges.
Mr. Lautner said he was nominated by state Sen. John Pippy, R-Moon, for the post after Mrs. Boyle's retirement, but that the governor took no action to fill the vacancy.
He said that, if elected, he would make the district court his full-time job, but that he still would maintain a part-time law practice.
Mr. Miscavage has a practice in Pleasant Hills that he has operated for 23 years.
He said he was running for district judge in part because he believes that a number of district judges who aren't lawyers don't understand the laws relating to evidence.
"I've done hundreds of magistrate hearings and the one simple problem is that most magistrates have a problem with what is evidence," he said.
Mr. Miscavage said he planned to keep a part-time law practice if he is elected district judge.
Mr. Capolupo has operated a private law practice, currently in Jefferson Hills, since 1982. Before that, he served as a special assistant state attorney general in 1973-82..
He was a Jefferson Hills councilman in 1995-99, serving as council president in 1995-97.
In addition to his private practice, Mr. Capolupo has served as an arbitrator for the American Arbitration Association and the Allegheny County Court of Common Pleas. As an arbitrator in civil matters, Mr. Capolupo hears the arguments on both sides of cases and issues rulings.
He served on the now-defunct Jefferson Juvenile Crime Commission, which handled some first-time juvenile offenders outside of the juvenile court system. He'd like to re-establish the commission if elected.
He would like to spend time in elementary schools teaching students about drunken driving and drug offenses. Mr. Capolupo also would like to make the district judge office a place where senior citizens can get help with issues. He said he would retire from his law practice if elected.
Mr. Yee and Mr. Snee cite their extensive experience in law enforcement and in appearing before district judges as their qualifications for running.
Mr. Snee retired from the South Park police March 12 after 33 years on the force, but he is busy as a landlord of residential properties in the area and as the owner of South Park Tanning and Nails.
"I am qualified. I have had hands-on experience with the criminal law and procedures, the motor vehicle law and the landlord/tenant law," he said.
He taught the police department's DARE course in the township's public and parochial schools for 14 years.
Mr. Snee said that, if elected, he would hold evening hours for people who can't make it to district court during the day. In addition, he said, he would stagger the reporting times of defendants on criminal court day rather than having everyone show up at the beginning of the session and stand around. He would like to create separate waiting rooms for lawyers and police and defendants.
Mr. Yee, also of South Park, has been a sheriff's deputy for 27 years and a firearms instructor who is certified by the National Rifle Association. He said he was the recipient of numerous awards for his work in law enforcement.
As district judge, he would "be fair, but enforce the law." He said he would retire from the sheriff's office if elected.
Mr. Yee was in the news in January when he was called to testify before a federal grand jury about Common Pleas Court Judge Jeffrey Manning, in whose courtroom Mr. Yee worked. Mr. Yee was reassigned to family court.
Mr. Yee was asked to testify about guns that were evidence in a trial before Judge Manning that were used by Mr. Yee in an NRA-sponsored gun safety course at the Carrick Sportsman's Club. He said the judge gave him permission to sign the guns out.
Mr. Yee said he asked for the reassignment because of the grand jury testimony. He said there was nothing wrong with the way he signed the gun out, and that he broke no laws or policies of the sheriff's office.
"The sheriff's office has been terminating people right and left. If I did anything wrong, I would be gone," he said.
Mrs. Larcinese, who spent eight years on Jefferson Hills council and eight years as mayor, leaving office in 2005, said she was drawn to the district judge office as a result of work she did with families while mayor.
She said she helped get services for families with children with drug and alcohol problems.
She said that, as district judge, she would like to set up programs "to help these children before charges are filed against them."
She believes there are a number of juvenile cases that can be handled at the district judge level without being sent to juvenile court. She said that, as mayor, she learned to be an effective mediator.
Mr. Rudolph, who is a South Park school director, also is interested in dealing with youth. "My experience on the school board has shown that the magistrate really had the first opportunity to interact with the community, especially the younger people," he said.
As magistrate, he would start community education programs that would educate the youth about such topics as drinking and driving and other traffic violations and would update the entire community on new laws affecting the public, such as recent legislation that requires the use of headlights on cars when windshield wipers are in use.
Mr. Rudolph said he had already completed the state certification course required for all non-lawyers who are elected as district judges.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.