Voters in the Baldwin-Whitehall School District, a district with an unsettled teachers' contract and a costly high school renovation project, will have plenty of choices on the May 15 primary election ballot.
Five school board seats are open. Three incumbents, Directors Richard Caponi, Dana Etzel-Hardman and John Palmiere, are not seeking re-election.
The two incumbents who are running for re-election are Kevin Fischer, the board president, and Jane Hunnewell, a longtime member of the board. They will be challenged by two former school directors, E. John Egger and Martin Schmotzer. Other candidates are Greg A. Zeman, who was unsuccessful in one campaign for a board seat, and newcomers Kevin A. Stiffey, Alan Clemence, Rebecca J. Gralish, Diana Kazour and Dennis P. Lavelle Sr.
All have cross-filed.
Mr. Fischer, 44, of Baldwin Borough, operations manager of the Allegheny County controller's office, is seeking his second term. He is a critic of the state and federal governments for all the restrictions and unfunded mandates they impose on school districts.
Mr. Fischer said he would like to try to interest Brentwood School District in exploring ways the two districts could share services to save money.
"I think Baldwin-Whitehall is at a crossroads," Mr. Fischer said. "Decisions that this board makes and subsequent boards in the future will determine whether the board manages growth or decline."
Mrs. Hunnewell, 70, of Whitehall, a retired housewife, has spent 20 years on the board, though not consecutively.
She is known for her pointed, sometimes blunt, comments about everything from the unsettled teachers' contract to why kids don't know their geography.
"I call it the dumbing down of education. Cash registers have to make change. No one knows English grammar and no one knows geography," she said.
She supports the board's "solid position" to not cave in to the demands of the Baldwin-Whitehall Education Association, which has been without a contract since June 30 and engaged in a seven-day strike in February.
Many voters are bound to be confused by the candidacy of Mr. Schmotzer, of Whitehall, because his brother, John Schmotzer, is on the school board and served as its president last year.
"Anyone who knows us will not be confused," said Martin Schmotzer, 51, who has lived in the district for 25 years and served on the school board from 1987 to 1993.
His two daughters attend elementary school at Carlow University Campus School.
Mr. Schmotzer said that was because he and his wife, Amy, want their children to have a Catholic influence in elementary school, but plan to send them to public high school.
Mr. Schmotzer said he was a self-employed businessman. He was in the news in 2000 when he was arrested and accused of stealing $50,000 in public funds while he worked for former Deputy Clerk of Courts Joyce Lee Itkin.
He returned the money, but was fired from his job in April 1997 and charged with multiple counts of theft by deception. The records in his case were expunged, according to court documents he provided the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
"My record is 100 percent clear," he said.
Promising to run a positive campaign, Mr. Schmotzer said he thought the school district needed his experience and ideas. "The cost of education is ridiculously high," he said.
Mr. Zeman, 32, of Baldwin Borough, is making his second try for the board. He has served twice in recent years on the district's budget review committee and researched the pros and cons of selling school district naming rights to a business. He is a payroll manager for PJAX in Gibsonia.
A resident for 28 years and the son of a retired teacher, Mr. Zeman said, he can see the issues that school boards face from many sides: as a parent of small children and a spokesman for retired homeowners.
"You want to take care of your older voters, but you want to encourage younger people to move here," he said.
Mr. Egger and Mr. Stiffey, both of Baldwin Borough, are running as a team.
Mr. Egger, 55, a real estate agent and head clerk in a convenience store, has served one term on the board that ended in 2003. He would like to see the district, which includes Baldwin Borough, Baldwin Township and Whitehall, merge with the Brentwood School District as a way to save money. He also wants to restructure the school district's administrative staff.
"I think we are top heavy in administration," he said. "We have to live within our means."
Mr. Stiffey, 49, a draftsman for a Downtown engineering firm, is a lifelong resident of Baldwin Borough whose three sons have attended the schools. He is in his third year of serving as a volunteer for the school district's budget advisory committee, which analyzes the budget and offers suggestions.
"It was a real eye-opener," Mr. Stiffey said of that experience. "Ninety-nine percent of our ideas were not used."
Mr. Stiffey, who is making his first run for public office, wants to see the school district run like a business instead of with an "open wallet."
"I think the situation on the school board is that they are all for education, but I think we need to run the school like a business," he said.
"We can't have everything," he said.
Ms. Kazour, 44, who has lived in Baldwin Borough for 14 years, is a bank teller manager, former teacher and former part owner of Pitaland in Brookline. A native of Lebanon, she is making her first run for office.
"I do volunteering. I feel that I can make a difference in someone's life," said Ms. Kazour, who is divorced and has three children who attend or have attended Baldwin-Whitehall schools.
Mr. Clemence, 52, of Baldwin Borough, who is making his first run for office, is a colon hydrotherapist and certified natural health professional.
He has lived in Baldwin Borough for 20 years and has two children in the schools. He hopes he can lend his expertise to making changes in the school lunch program to make it healthier. He also thinks the board should work on getting its meetings broadcast on cable television.
Two candidates, Ms. Gralish, of Baldwin Borough, a homemaker, and Mr. Lavelle Sr., of Baldwin Borough, a small-business owner, could not be reached for comment.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.