It stands to reason that, during a typical election year, a 13-term incumbent in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives, as is Tom Petrone, could expect to cruise easily to re-election on years of goodwill for pet projects for his district.

This is not a typical election year. Mr. Petrone, meet thy pay raise.

Mr. Petrone, D-Crafton Heights, is one of dozens of state legislators facing heat for last year's pay raise debacle. He faces three challengers in the Democratic primary in the 27th Legislative District, which includes neighborhoods in Pittsburgh's West End, Avalon, Ben Avon, Crafton, Dormont, Emsworth, Glenfield, Ingram, Neville and parts of McKees Rocks and Stowe.

His Democratic opponents, Dan Cindric, Mike Galovich, and Frank Liberatore have hammered away at Mr. Petrone's integrity in regard to the raise.

Advertise with us

In November, he will be challenged by Republican Bill Ogden, who is the lone GOP candidate.

"[Mr. Petrone] voted for the pay raise, and that was a betrayal of trust," Mr. Galovich said.

"The whole thing speaks to a lack of integrity and accountability to the people of the district," Mr. Cindric echoed.

For the record, Mr. Petrone, 68, of Crafton Heights, has said he argued against the pay raise behind closed doors before it passed, then voted for it, then donated it to help constituents, then voted to rescind it and is now paying it back.

Despite the controversy, Mr. Petrone, a Navy veteran, has earned the endorsement of his party's committee. He could not be reached for comment, but sent a statement listing his accomplishments.

Advertise with us

Elected in 1980, Mr. Petrone is the seven-term minority chairman of the House Urban Affairs Committee. He touts his record of support for establishment of the county's Regional Asset District and the state's Keystone Opportunity Zone program, as well as past support for regionwide projects such as the new David L. Lawrence Convention Center, Heinz Field, PNC Park and the renovation of the Fort Pitt Bridge and Tunnel.

His challengers are running under the banner of PA- CleanSweep, a political organization looking to oust all incumbents in state government.

Mr. Cindric, 56, an engineer from Crafton, is a member of Crafton council, to which he was elected in 1999. He endorses more transparency in state government and has said the Legislature should be held to the same standards of the Sunshine Law as municipal governments, requiring them to do their business in public.

He supports term limits and an overhaul of the state campaign finance rules, which he said should be more in line with the McCain-Feingold law governing donations to federal elections.

Mr. Cindric said he was skeptical of property tax relief to come from future gambling revenues and that a more realistic plan should be enacted, similar to what officials did in Crafton, which gives seniors with annual incomes less than $30,000 a 25 percent discount on local taxes. He recognizes that property taxes can't be eliminated, but is for reducing them by raising the sales and income taxes.

Advertise with us

Mr. Galovich, 46, of Crafton Heights, is employed as a supervisor in a section of the Allegheny County Register of Wills Office. He sees this race as a chance to restore trust to the office and oust an incumbent he calls a career politician.

"That's the problem. He's entrenched," Mr. Galovich said.

He said he would like to enhance development in the district, particularly at the Chartiers Industrial Park.

Although he is not emphatic about eliminating the property tax, Mr. Galovich favors at least reducing it through a combination of small increases in the state sales and income taxes.

Mr. Liberatore, 79, a retired construction engineer and World War II veteran from Ingram, said he wants to get rid of school taxes completely by raising the state sales and income taxes. He previously challenged Mr. Petrone unsuccessfully as a member of the Reform Party in 2000.

Mr. Ogden, 45, of Crafton, is a veteran of the Army and a former military policeman. He is a personal trainer and, since 1992, has run Bill Ogden's Weight Room, a gym in Crafton. He is a member of Crafton council and the only Republican in the race.