Much to the amazement of her critics, incumbent Baldwin-Whitehall school board member Beverly Jo Coon won more than 1,200 votes, even though she stopped campaigning after she was charged with trying to kill her estranged boyfriend, former Bethel Park Superintendent Ronald Grimm.

Related article

Suddenly, a search needed for top Bethel Park schools post

Residents of the Baldwin-Whitehall School District voted overwhelmingly Tuesday to throw out Ms. Coon, a school director who brought scandal to both their school district and neighboring Bethel Park. On the same night, Dr. Grimm submitted his resignation in Bethel Park.

Advertise with us

Even though she placed sixth, Ms. Coon ended up with 1,241 votes, compared with the 6,002 garnered by the top vote-getter, newcomer Nancy DiNardo. Other winners were incumbent board President John Schmotzer, with 5,496 votes; Edward Moeller with 4,354 votes; and George L. Pry, with 4,284 votes.

Incumbent Michael Stelmasczyk, who tried to distance himself from Ms. Coon, placed fifth, with 3,784 votes.

People who showed up at Napoli's Restaurant on Tuesday night, where Mr. Schmotzer, Mr. Pry and Mrs. DiNardo were celebrating, groused that so many people voted for Ms. Coon, despite the fact that she is charged with attempted homicide, arson, stalking and other offenses.

"A lot of people pull the lever and vote straight Democratic," reasoned Guy Defebo, of Whitehall, a poll worker.

But others said Ms. Coon had supporters who stood by her, despite her problems.

Advertise with us

In rejecting Ms. Coon and Mr. Stelmasczyk, the voters rejected the two chief naysayers who have questioned the validity of spending more than $60 million to renovate Baldwin High School.

Another critic of the massive renovation project, incumbent board member Paul Homer, lost his seat in the spring primary.

Mr. Stelmasczyk blamed his defeat on several last-minute mailings by his opponents that had the criminal charges against Ms. Coon "plastered all over them."

"I am glad to be away from this Schmotzer regime," Mr. Stelmasczyk said, calling his opponents "vile and deceitful."

Mr. Stelmasczyk said he believed the high school renovation project, which has been delayed until at least December, will just keep increasing in cost, until it is "$80 million or more."

Advertise with us

"Ed Moeller is the only one [on the new board] who will have any kind of empathy with the taxpayers," Mr. Stelmaszcyk said.

"For the rest of them, the sky will be limit on spending."

Mr. Schmotzer contends that his team will use the taxpayers' money wisely to renovate the school and provide "excellent" educational opportunities for the students.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.