It appears there will be four new faces on the Mt. Lebanon school board as unofficial election results show that incumbent Rodney Shepherd lost his bid for another term to newcomer Josephine Posti by 21 votes.

The other three open seats on the board went to Mr. Shepherd's running mates. They are Mark Hart, 41, director of business and chief financial officer of the Pittsburgh Steelers; Alan Silhol, 49, chief counsel for the real estate division of American Eagle Outfitters Inc.; and Dan Remely, 54, president of H-Squared Properties.

The four men called themselves The Committee For Value in Education and ran on a platform that promised they would provide a high-quality education while keeping an eye on finances.

According to unofficial results, Mr. Hart was the highest vote getter with 5,634, followed by Mr. Silhol, 5,450 votes. Coming in third was Mr. Remely, 3,749 votes.

Advertise with us

Ms. Posti 37, owner of an advertising and public relations firm, received 3,337 votes and Mr. Shepherd, 48, a lawyer in private practice, got 3,316 votes.

The sixth candidate in the race, Faith Stipanovich, 45, payroll manager for the Allegheny County controller's office, received 2,926 votes.

Some of the candidates were comparing the Shepherd-Posti race to the infamous 1948 presidential race in which newspaper headlines declared Republican Thomas Dewey as the winner, but results later confirmed Democrat Harry S. Truman was the victor.

That's because the members of Mr. Shepherd's slate declared a victory sweep about 10:15 p.m. Tuesday night, based on election results that members of the Mt. Lebanon Republican Party had gathered from polling places. Those results showed Mr. Shepherd winning the fourth seat by 200-some votes.

Because of those results, the only ones available at that point in the evening, Mr. Shepherd went home believing he was a winner and Ms. Posti went to bed believing she had lost.

Advertise with us

But when Allegheny County unofficial election results were released later in the evening, they showed Ms. Posti ahead by 21 votes.

Mr. Shepherd said he went to bed knowing the results were not official, but still thinking that he had won.

He found out in the morning that the totals had changed. He believes the anti-incumbent sentiment in the community led to the close race between him and Ms. Posti.

Mt. Lebanon residents have expressed anger at the current school board for the $500,000-plus separation agreement given to former Superintendent Margery Sable a year ago and for other spending issues, including cost overruns on elementary school renovations.

"I had people tell me they weren't going to vote for me just because I was on the board," Mr. Shepherd said.

Advertise with us

He is the second incumbent to be voted off of the board. Former board President Ron Hoffman lost his re-election attempt in the primary.

Mr. Shepherd said he was uncertain if he would ask for a recount. But Mr. Remely said he expected the Value for Education slate to ask for one.

He said candidates have 20 days from the date of election to file a petition requesting a recount. They must have three electors from each of the 38 voting districts sign the petition and must pay a $50 fee for every district recounted.

Mr. Remely said he was uncertain if a recount could be held before the Dec. 5 reorganization meeting of the Mt. Lebanon school board.

Ms. Posti said she was looking forward to "working with Dan and Alan and Mark. I think we are like-minded on a lot of issues."

Advertise with us

Mr. Hart said voters had sent a message to the school board.

"I think it's clear that voters want a complete change in how the board operates."

Mr. Hart vowed during his campaign to try to uncover the reasons that Dr. Sable was asked to resign with three years left on her contract. No public explanation has been given by the board.

Since all of the candidates have said they opposed the construction of a free-standing natatorium on the high school campus, a project the current board has been discussing and planning since early this year, it appears likely that project will be called to a halt.

"All of us wanted to sit back and see what we could do with the high school and see if there isn't some savings to the community in doing it that way," Mr. Remely said, referring to the fact that the board is embarking on discussions about major renovations or new construction at the high school.

The school board candidates favored including a new pool as part of the larger renovation project.