Incumbent Magisterial District Judges Mary Grace Boyle of Pleasant Hills and Ernest Marraccini of Elizabeth Borough both won re-election to new six-year terms despite being the target of separate state Judicial Conduct Board investigations.
Boyle, 55, soundly beat out her opponents, D. Scott Launter, 34, of Pleasant Hills, and Rose Turzak, 49, of South Park, both attorneys, to win a fifth term.
According to unofficial returns from the Allegheny County Department of Elections, Boyle got 2,200 votes on the Democratic ticket and 1,470 on the Republican. Lautner, who came in second in the race, garnered 1,498 votes on the Democratic side and 913 on the Republican. Turzak trailed with 595 votes from the Democrats and 217 from the Republicans.
Marraccini, 60, of Elizabeth Borough, topped his challenger, Dale Provins, 53, a former Jefferson police office. Provins was fired in 1997 after being accused of beating a suspect in an interrogation room. Marraccini won a third term with 1,857 votes on the Democratic ticket and 632 on the Republican. Provins received 785 Democratic votes and 402 Republican votes.
Boyle could not be reached for comment. Lautner said he was disappointed in the results but that wished Boyle "the best of luck in her future endeavors.''
Turzak said she also was disappointed with the race results but felt she had tried her hardest.
"I felt I ran a good campaign. The rest was up to the people," she said.
In April 2004, Lautner sought and received a court order from Common Pleas Judge Joseph James to have all of his cases that would have been held before Boyle transferred to Magisterial District Judge Rob Wyda of Bethel Park in a case that triggered a state Judicial Conduct Board inquiry.
The order has been sealed and Lautner has said he has been advised not to talk about it because of the ongoing inquiry.
In addition, last month it was reported that Boyle faces a state Judicial Conduct Board investigation into allegations that she has used her court office and staff for re-election activities in violation of a state Supreme Court order. The investigation was started by the Allegheny County District Attorney's office and turned over to the judicial board.
Boyle, whose district covers Pleasant Hills, Jefferson Hills and South Park, has denied any wrongdoing.
The six misconduct charges filed against Marraccini in February by the Judicial Conduct Board appeared not to affect his re-election bid. The charges stem from an incident last year when Marraccini was filling in for Forest Hills Magisterial District Judge Susan Evashavik and he threw out 33 summary traffic cases without taking testimony.
Before the election, Marraccini explained that the reason he threw the cases out was because he felt he was asked to participate "in a procedure that was lacking due process."
"Most people I talked to disregarded (the charges) because they saw them as political or trivial," Marraccini said after his victory.
"I thank the voters for the confidence that they've shown in me." His district covers Elizabeth and Forward townships and Elizabeth and West Elizabeth boroughs.
Provins, of Elizabeth Township, said he had hoped to win the judge's seat because he felt that with 22 years of police experience, he was qualified for the job.
"The reason I ran for the office was that I felt a change was needed and I felt I was qualified. But the voters have spoken. I appreciate everyone who came out to support me," Provins said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.