The race for magisterial district judge in the district that includes Elizabeth and Forward townships and Elizabeth and West Elizabeth boroughs includes two candidates who have been in the headlines.
Incumbent Ernest L. Marraccini, 60, of Elizabeth Borough, who has been in office since 1992, made news in February when the state Judicial Conduct Board announced that it filed six misconduct charges against him in connection with proceedings on May 25, 2004, when he filled in for Magisterial District Judge Susan Evashavik of Forest Hills.
According to the board's complaint, Marraccini told defendants awaiting hearings on some 30 traffic violations that they were all not guilty and ordered them to leave without taking any testimony in the cases.
Dale T. Provins Sr., 53, of Elizabeth Township, a former Jefferson police officer, was the subject of news coverage in 1997 when he was fired from the department after he was accused of beating a suspect in an interrogation room.
Before his termination, Provins had been with the department for 22 years and had been suspended a number of times before for various alleged infractions.
Marraccini and Provins said the allegations against them don't tell the whole story and should not prevent them from being elected.
Marraccini said he is not permitted to discuss the case against him or to offer any public rebuttal, though he will have a hearing on the charges against him with the state Court of Judicial Discipline. The court, if it finds evidence to support the charges, can impose sanctions ranging from reprimand to dismissal.
However, Marraccini said he took the actions he did that day because "I believe I was asked to take part in a procedure that was lacking due process."
Marraccini said he believes he should be re-elected because he has a record of being "fair and impartial" in the cases that he has handled and because his years of experience and his education make him qualified.
During his years on the local bench, Marraccini said he has heard more than 30,000 cases and collected some $2 million in fines.
Marraccini holds a bachelor's degree in history from the University of Chicago and a doctorate in anthropology from Columbia University, where he taught for several years before he abandoned academia and returned home to work in his family's grocery business before running for district justice.
Marraccini said he had no comment on Provins' past controversies, but pointed out that Provins would not be able to take office if he is elected because he has not met either of the requirements for becoming a district justice -- either attending a month-long, state-sponsored training course for district judges and passing the accompanying exam or passing the state bar exam.
Provins earned a law degree from Duquesne University in 1996, but did not pass the bar exam when he took it. However, Provins said, he is scheduled to attend a session of the state-sponsored training for district judges in June.
In defending his record as a Jefferson police officer, Provins said the list of suspensions he faced that eventually led to his removal from his job illustrate a "longstanding political witch hunt that went on and on and on and on."
He said his role as a Fraternal Order of Police representative often put him "on the opposite side of the table" of some borough officials.
In the case that led to his dismissal, Provins has steadfastly maintained that he did not beat the suspect, William Miller, but simply restrained him when he lashed out at police. Provins and two other officers took Miller and his wife into custody in April 1997 as they were moving out of a condemned motel where Miller was an assistant manager.
After a search of Miller's car, he was charged with criminal trespass, burglary, possession of heroin and conspiracy to commit burglary. His wife faced similar charges.
The charges were dropped before a trial scheduled for November 1997 when a judge that the officers had no probable cause to stop the Millers, search their car or arrest the couple.
Provins said he appealed the civil service ruling to remove him from his job through several levels of the judicial system, but eventually gave up because he found another job in the telecommunications industry making substantially more money than he made as a police officer.
Provins never faced criminal charges in the matter.
In recent years Provins said he has worked for a firm called Equant, installing internet equipment around the world. The job has required him to do extensive international travel, he said,.
Provins said he believed his experience of being unjustly accused and prosecuted will make him a good judge. "I realize that when people come before the court there are a lot of other issues involved. My experience gives me the balance to see both sides," he said.
Provins said the departmental charges that he faced should not prevent him from serving as a judge but that the charges Marraccini faces "relate to his the way he does his job."
Provins said that as a police officer he appeared in front of Marraccini and "did not have a problem in his court."
He described Marraccini as "pleasant" and "pretty nice to me." But, Provins said, he's heard from others that Marraccini's court "is not as open as it should be" and "he has biases when it comes to certain types of cases." Provins declined to identify the types of cases or biases.
PRIMARY 2005




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.