Lawyers D. Scott Lautner and Rose Turzak, who are the challengers in the race for magisterial district judge in Pleasant Hills, South Park and Jefferson Hills, say they are running because they believe a lawyer should fill the post.
But incumbent Mary Grace Boyle, of Jefferson Hills, said her 24 years in office gave her as much, if not more, expertise in her field than any legal degree and that her long tenure proves that she is a "tough, but fair judge."
Boyle, 55, is running for her fifth six-year term, but her campaign is now clouded with controversy.
It was reported yesterday that the district attorney's office referred to the state Judicial Conduct Board evidence it gathered on complaints that Boyle is using her office for campaign activities
Lautner has lodged the same complaints about Boyle's use of her office and other campaign tactics.
Boyle has denied wrongdoing.
Turzak, 49, of South Park, operates a law practice in Castle Shannon, and Lautner, 34, has a practice in Pleasant Hills, where he lives. All candidates are cross-filed to run on the Republican and Democratic tickets for the May 17 primary.
Neither challenger has held public office before. In addition to her lack of a law degree, Boyle needs to be replaced because she does not handle all cases fairly, Lautner contends, and she is particularly harsh on defendants facing alcohol-related charges. Lautner sought and was granted a Common Pleas Court order in April 2004 that moves all of his cases slated for Boyle to Bethel Park District Judge Rob Wyda.
As for the court order, the details of which are sealed, Boyle said: "Apparently, he's afraid to come in front of me. If he's such a great attorney, I don't know why he'd be afraid to come here. No other attorneys are afraid to come here."
Boyle said the order was not appealed because she knew Lautner was going to run against her.
Turzak said that although state doesn't require district judges to have law degrees, the complexities of the law make it difficult for someone without a degree to apply it. She said she was taking her campaign door to door in the district, explaining her credentials.
"I've hit over 1,200 houses so far. People are indicating they are not happy," Turzak said. She declined to say why people are not happy with Boyle, saying: "I'm not going down that route. I'm running because I think I would be a good judge."
Boyle said that although she has a wide knowledge of the law, a law degree isn't necessary to do her job.
"This is a local court where people can come without an attorney and have their cases heard. This is a small claims court where people can come and explain their side of the story and have it heard by someone in their community. That's what the local court was meant to be," she said, adding that statewide, the majority of district judges are not lawyers.
Boyle said she has presided over about 132,000 cases during her two dozen years in office and has performed more than 1,200 marriages.
Lautner said he was running because, "I believe it's time for a change in the community. I don't believe that Mary Grace Boyle has the judicial temperament for the job."
Launter accused Boyle of being "super hard" on cases involving alcohol and said he believed her handling of those cases might be related to her daughter's death.
Boyle's daughter, Kelly, 22, was killed in November 1994 when she was thrown from a vehicle driven by her boyfriend, who was legally drunk.
Boyle said her handling of alcohol-related cases had nothing to do with her personal life. She said she strictly followed the law, including a state law that requires anyone under the age of 21 who is convicted of an alcohol-related offense to have his or her license suspended.
She said Lautner didn't like the application of that law because, before the court order moving his cases to Wyda, Lautner brought 124 cases before her involving teens involved with alcohol or drugs.
"My position is, children need to be accountable and need to understand what they are doing and need to learn from their mistakes, and the state says they must have their license suspended if they are convicted. He's made a career of trying to circumvent that law," Boyle said.
Lautner said that because the order is sealed, he can't comment on it, nor could his lawyer, Sean Audley.
Wyda said he also did not know the details surrounding the court order.
But Wyda said he had to seek a second order against Boyle to get forwarded to his office paperwork on Lautner's cases because Boyle failed to comply with the first order.
Lautner said Boyle conducts herself unprofessionally in the courtroom. "I can't tell you how many times I've seen her belittle someone. It's one thing to find someone guilty, but it's another to demean or belittle them. It's unnecessary."
Boyle said any comments that she has made to defendants were done to educate them. "I'm trying to educate them so that they don't run the red light again and maybe kill somebody. I've certainly never tried to intimidate or belittle anybody," she said.
Lautner accused Boyle of trying to "harass and intimidate voters" by calling people who signed his election petitions and those with his signs in their yards to ask them to put her signs out.
Some of the calls, Lautner contended, came from her district court office, which is a violation of state ethics rules.
Boyle said she and her campaign staff called people who signed the petitions because they suspected that Lautner's petitions were handled improperly.
Though she said she was able to determine that Lautner and his workers didn't follow correct procedures for collecting signatures, she decided not to pursue the matter.
She said she thought they were using cell phones. Boyle said there was nothing illegal about calling people who display Lautner's signs.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.