Concerns about rising taxes and mixed opinions on a new property tax reduction law characterize this year's Upper St. Clair school board primary race May 17.

Three incumbents and six other candidates are running for four seats on the board. Each seat has a four-year term.

Clark R. Nicklas, whose term expires this year, is not seeking re-election.

The three incumbents are David E. Bluey, Russell R. Del Re and Vicki A. McKenna, who was appointed to fill the unexpired term of Albert E. Ferrara Jr. after he resigned in June .

Advertise with us

McKenna, who was vice president of the district's PTA Council before she joined the board, said she believed considerable tax increases had caused some people to lose trust in the board's fiscal management.

In helping to curtail these increases, she said, she will make decisions based not "just on spreadsheets," but also on the experience she's gained from volunteering at the schools.

Hoping for a comeback after his defeat in 2003 is dentist William M. Sulkowski, who served on the board from 1999 to 2003.

A member of the board's budget committee during his term, he said the board could prevent a tax increase without cutting educational programs by reducing the number of administrators and decreasing administrative costs, such as retirement benefits.

The other candidates include newcomers Amy Billerbeck, president of the Upper St. Clair PTA Council and a former banker; real estate and bankruptcy lawyer Carol B. Coliane; physicians Daniel A. Iracki and Dennis J. Phillips, and retired special education teacher Russell W. Ripper.

Advertise with us

All nine candidates have cross-filed to run on the Democratic and Republican tickets.

Opinions on Act 72, the new state law that proposes to use slot machine money to reduce property taxes, are mixed. The district must choose whether to participate by May 30 and may opt out after four years under certain conditions.

Billerbeck has strongly opposed participating in the program for several reasons.

One is a provision that requires districts to call a referendum on tax increases above an inflation index, subject to certain exceptions.

This requirement might lead to cuts in educational programs, she said.

Advertise with us

She also objects to using gambling money to pay for education and the requirement that districts prepare their budgets several months earlier than usual.

Although Bluey, Iracki and Sulkowski thought the tax-increase referendum could help control spending, they spoke out against other aspects of Act 72, saying it unfairly benefits Philadelphians and that Upper St. Clair residents wouldn't get much of a tax break, if any.

Ripper said he supported Act 72 because "we need to do something for tax relief." Although, he said, he's somewhat concerned about the referendum provision, he doubts that the district's tax increases, outside of one of the exceptions, will rise to the level requiring one.

Despite their differing positions on Act 72, the candidates seem united on the issue of tax increases.

Phillips said that although the board should generally defer to administrative recommendations, it should exercise keen fiscal oversight.

Advertise with us

And Bluey said that, especially in light of the district's debt level of about $70 million, the board needs to be sure there's a "strong objective base" for expenses instead of just a "feeling" that they're needed.

To control spending without harming educational programs, Coliane suggests reducing administrative costs, such as travel and conferences, and to keep a closer watch on spending,

Bluey and Del Re have asked the district's director of business and finance, M. Jane Sierzega, for an analysis of district trends in staff hiring.

Ripper said that while special education is expensive and therefore might be seen as a target for spending cuts, it probably would be difficult to do so without harming students.