Why would a school director who still has two years left on his term run for another available seat on the same board?
Bethel Park's Charles G. Koch said it was because he wanted to give people the opportunity to vote for a candidate who is committed to Act 72. That new state legislation proposes sharing slot machine revenue via property tax breaks for homeowners whose districts increase the earned income tax and hold referendums on certain tax increases.
So Koch decided to run in the May 17 primary for one of four four-year terms up for election.
If he wins, the board would appoint his replacement for his unexpired term. If he loses, he retains his seat.
"I'm kind of flabbergasted there aren't more people running," Koch said. There are five candidates for the four seats. All are crossfiled to run as Republicans and Democrats.
Besides Koch, the remaining incumbents -- Daniel B. Duff, Connie H. Ruhl and Richard N. Rose -- have formed a ticket with newcomer Charles H. Scheuble.
Duff, 46, is completing his first four-year term on the board. He has been board president for the past two years. He is a surgical sales representative with Bausch & Lomb and has lived in Bethel Park since 1985. He has been married for 22 years and he and his wife have two children in the district.
"I think I have brought a lot of insight to the board," Duff said. "I would like to continue the progress the board has made over the last few years."
Specifically, Duff said, he believes the board has benefitted from his leadership skills and his ability to be a mediator.
Duff has not decided how he'll vote on Act 72, but he is doing a lot of research so, he said, his decision will be well thought out.
"It's a real double-edged sword," he said. "There's some pretty big ramifications there. Some of them are good. Some of them aren't."
Budget control is important to Duff, who noted, "You don't develop a budget and then raise taxes for it. You only spend what you have." That job continues to be challenging because of unfunded mandates for such projects as No Child Left Behind and requirements for special education and English as a second language instruction, he said.
Koch, 62, is serving his seventh consecutive year on the board. He also served one year in 1990, when he was appointed to finish a term. Koch recently retired as the business manager of the Chartiers Valley School District.
Koch graduated from Bethel Park High School in 1960 and moved back with his family in 1989. He has been married for 19 years and he and his wife have four adult children and six grandchildren.
For this election, he said, he tried to build a slate of candidates to support his position on Act 72 but was unsuccessful. But he believes his candidacy represents a "referendum on the issue" of Act 72.
State law requires boards to opt in by May 30, and Koch would be on the board for that decision regardless, although a recent lawsuit and proposed legislation are attempting to delay the deadline.
Koch downplays other districts' resistance to the legislation. "I don't believe the problems are nearly what the school districts expect," he said.
He is in favor of shifting taxes from property taxes toward earned income taxes and supports having referendums on larger budget increases.
Koch said he had a conservative approach to financing and believed the budget should be created around how much revenue the district has to spend, not how much it could get by raising taxes.
"I do believe we need to live within constrained revenue," he said.
He believes the board should consider how the district's curriculum should change before it commits to building projects. He said the board should devise long-term plans for facility maintenance and require the administration to follow through.
Rose, 71, is completing his 24th year on the board. He is a retired former accountant for PPG Industries.
"I kind of enjoy doing something with the kids," he said, explaining his decision to run again. "There's a teachers contract up this year and there's a building program and I want to be there for those."
He and his wife of more than 50 years have lived in Bethel Park for 31 years. They have two grown children and two grandchildren who live out of the area.
Rose has been on the board of the Allegheny Intermediate Unit for more than 20 years and is president of the Pathfinder school board. He also helped found the Asset science program.
He is not a fan of Act 72.
"I think it's a terrible piece of legislation," he said. He doesn't mind the proposed tax relief, but he doesn't like the deadlines that "force us into [a decision] by May, having no idea what the revenue will be."
Rose would rather delay the vote until it's determined how much revenue would be involved. He thinks that, if the legislators want referendums on tax increases, that issue should stand on its own.
As for the teachers contract, "I just want a fair settlement for both sides without a strike," he said. And he said the building program would need to be prioritized, as there are "more needs than money."
Ruhl, who declined to give her age, is completing her 10th year on the board after being appointed to a two-year term and being elected for two four-year terms.
She is a self-employed education business consultant and a part-time special projects coordinator for the Airport Area Chamber of Commerce. She teaches business classes at Point Park University and Waynesburg College. She and her husband have been married for 44 years and have lived in Bethel Park for 42 years. They had three children, two of whom are grown and live out of state and one of whom died.
She wants another term to help finish projects, including the district building plan.
"I think we've made progress, but I think we're at a crossroads and I'd like to see us complete that process," she said. "I would like to see it all through."
Ruhl believes her experience on the board allows her to add "a little bit of history" to the decision-making process.
As for Act 72, "I am not thoroughly convinced and haven't really decided," she said, adding, "I'm not afraid of referendum." She does not want to miss any tax relief for Bethel Park residents. She hopes the state delays the May 30 deadline.
Ruhl said her biggest concern was ongoing maintenance of the school facilities.
"We've let things fall apart and saved on the money," she said. "We have to think about long-term maintenance." She proposed an escrow-type account to set aside money only for maintenance of facilities.
As for building new facilities, such as sports venues, she suggested they could be privatized or the district could build facilities in cooperation with the municipality. "Timing, again, is everything," she said.
Scheuble, 51, is making his first run for public office. He has been active with the Republican Party and civic groups such as the Bethel Baseball Association.
He is vice president of J.B. O'Connor Co., a local manufacturer's representative, and has lived in the municipality for 24 years. He has been married for 26 years. He and his wife have a son at Bethel Park High School and another at St. Thomas More school.
"It's something I want to do at this stage in my life," he said of his run.
One of the biggest issues in the district is the need to improve facilities, he said.
"I think just in general, the infrastructure of the high school complex needs repairs," Scheuble said, noting the elementary schools and the athletic facilities have to be upgraded.
He said tax increases should be a last resort.
"I think we have to find creative solutions" for financing, he said, mentioning selling naming rights and pursuing grants as options.
If he had to vote on Act 72 today, he would probably not support it, although he still wants more time to research it.
"I think people with kids in Bethel schools will tell you they're very satisfied with education," he said, adding the quality of the programs and activities is good.
He said he knew "great numbers" of people who bought starter homes in Bethel Park but moved because the school facilities had to be improved.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.